The question of how many farmers have been murdered in South Africa is one of those topics that usually ends up in a shouting match. Depending on who you ask, you'll hear it's a "white genocide" or, on the flip side, that it's just normal crime being blown out of proportion. Honestly? The truth is somewhere in the messy middle, buried under layers of police reports, private databases, and a whole lot of political noise.
If you’re looking for a simple number, it doesn’t really exist.
The Numbers Game: Why Stats Never Match Up
The biggest headache in figuring out the death toll is that different people use different definitions. The South African Police Service (SAPS) follows the National Rural Safety Strategy. To them, a "farm murder" is an act of violence against people living, working, or visiting "farms and smallholdings."
But here’s the kicker: that includes the farm owner, their family, the farm workers, and even people just passing through.
According to the latest SAPS figures for the 2024/2025 financial year, the numbers have actually been trending downward. For instance, in the fourth quarter (January to March 2025), official police records showed 6 murders in farming communities.
👉 See also: Casey Ramirez: The Small Town Benefactor Who Smuggled 400 Pounds of Cocaine
- 3 victims were farm employees
- 2 victims were farmers
- 1 victim was a farm dweller
Compare this to the 1990s, when the Transvaal Agricultural Union (TAU SA) recorded over 150 murders in a single year (1998 was particularly brutal). By 2023/2024, the annual total sat at 49 murders on farms nationally.
AfriForum vs. The Police: The 2024 Discrepancy
While the government says things are improving, civil rights groups like AfriForum aren't buying it. They run their own database, and their numbers are almost always higher. In 2024, AfriForum recorded 176 farm attacks resulting in 37 murders.
Why the gap? Basically, it comes down to trust and reporting.
Many farmers don't feel the police accurately classify every attack. There was a big spat in early 2025 where AfriForum's Jacques Broodryk challenged Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, claiming the minister was "downplaying" the crisis by reporting only one murder in a quarter where AfriForum had documented eight.
✨ Don't miss: Lake Nyos Cameroon 1986: What Really Happened During the Silent Killer’s Release
Is it a "Genocide"?
You've probably seen the headlines or the tweets from international figures. The "white genocide" claim is a massive talking point, but the data doesn't really support the idea of a coordinated racial extermination.
The Institute for Security Studies (ISS) and various independent inquiries have found that the primary motive for these attacks is robbery. Farms are isolated. They often have cash or firearms on-site. They are, quite simply, "soft targets" in a country with a staggering national murder rate.
To put it in perspective:
South Africa saw over 25,000 murders in the last 12-month cycle. Farm murders—while horrific and often involving extreme brutality—account for roughly 0.2% of all homicides in the country.
The victims aren't just white farmers, either. Black farm managers, workers, and dwellers are frequently caught in the crossfire. In the 2025 reports, several of the victims identified by DIRCO (Department of International Relations and Cooperation) were African employees.
🔗 Read more: Why Fox Has a Problem: The Identity Crisis at the Top of Cable News
The Brutality Factor
What makes people so obsessed with how many farmers have been murdered in South Africa isn't just the quantity—it’s the quality of the violence. These aren't just quick robberies. There are frequent reports of torture, including the use of blowtorches, boiling water, or power tools.
Experts like Dr. Chris de Kock suggest this "excessive violence" is sometimes a way to force victims to reveal the location of a safe, but others argue it reflects a deeper social resentment or "frenzy" during the crime.
Where Does This Leave Us?
If you're a farmer in the Free State or Limpopo, the statistics don't really matter when you're locking your gates at night. The reality is that rural safety is a massive failure of the state. While the government claims 99% of rural police stations have implemented safety strategies, the response times in remote areas remain abysmal.
What you should take away from the current data:
- The trend is down: Compared to the late 90s and early 2000s, the number of murders has decreased.
- Race is complicated: Both Black and white people are victims, though the political narrative often focuses on one side.
- Isolation is the enemy: Most attacks happen because farms are easy to hit and hard to defend.
Practical Steps for Rural Residents
If you are living in a rural area or looking to support those who do, don't wait for a change in national policy. Most experts recommend:
- Joining a Neighborhood Watch: AfriForum and other local groups have established radio networks that are often faster than calling 10111.
- Layered Security: It's not just about one fence. You need "zones"—early warning sensors at the perimeter, dogs closer to the house, and a "safe room" inside.
- Data Transparency: If an incident occurs, report it to both the SAPS and a private monitoring group (like AfriForum or TAU SA). This ensures the "official" numbers can be cross-checked.
The situation is tragic, but it’s not a simple black-and-white story. It’s a symptom of a country struggling with one of the highest crime rates in the world, where those on the geographic fringes are often left to fend for themselves.