You’re standing in St. Peter’s Square, neck craned, eyes glued to a tiny copper chimney. Thousands of people are doing the exact same thing. It’s quiet—eerily quiet for Rome—and everyone is waiting for a puff of smoke. If it's black, we wait. If it's white, the world has a new leader for 1.4 billion Catholics. But the big question everyone asks while checking their watches is: how long to elect a new pope exactly?
Honestly, there isn’t a set timer. No buzzer goes off. But if history is any guide, you probably won't be standing in that square for three years.
Back in the day, things were messy. Like, "we’re going to rip the roof off your building" messy. In 1268, the cardinals just couldn't agree. They sat around for nearly three years—1,006 days, to be precise—trying to pick a successor to Pope Clement IV. The local villagers in Viterbo finally got so fed up they locked the cardinals inside, cut their food down to bread and water, and literally took the roof off to let the rain in.
Guess what? It worked. They picked Pope Gregory X pretty quickly after that.
The Modern "Fast Track"
Today, the process is way more streamlined. If you're looking at the last century, the wait time has shrunk significantly. Most modern conclaves are wrapped up in two to five days.
🔗 Read more: Salt Lake City UT Amber Alert: Why Minutes Matter and What You Need to Do Now
Take a look at the track record:
- Pope Francis (2013): 2 days (5 ballots)
- Pope Benedict XVI (2005): 2 days (4 ballots)
- Pope John Paul II (1978): 3 days (8 ballots)
- Pope John Paul I (1978): 2 days (4 ballots)
- Pope Pius XII (1939): 1 day (3 ballots)—basically a speed run.
Basically, the Church has gotten really good at this. The cardinals don't just walk in cold; they spend about two weeks before the conclave starts in "General Congregations." They talk. They lobby. They figure out the "vibe" of the next papacy. By the time they are actually locked in the Sistine Chapel (the word conclave literally means "with a key"), they usually have a shortlist in mind.
Why Some Conclaves Drag On
Even with the modern setup, things can stall. To win, a candidate needs a two-thirds majority. That’s a high bar. If you have two powerful factions—say, the "progressives" and the "traditionalists"—and neither wants to budge, you get a deadlock.
When that happens, the schedule is pretty grueling:
👉 See also: Recognition of Palestinian state: Why the Map is Changing Right Now
- Day One: Usually just one afternoon vote. It's often a "testing the waters" ballot.
- Days Two to Four: Four votes a day—two in the morning, two in the afternoon.
- The Pause: If there's no winner after three days of actual voting, they take a mandatory break. No voting. Just prayer, "informal discussion," and probably a lot of intense whispering over espresso.
The rules, updated by Pope Benedict XVI in 2013, are designed to prevent a "hostage situation." After roughly 12 or 13 days of failure, the cardinals can decide to move to a runoff between the top two candidates. However, they still need that two-thirds majority to win the runoff. This prevents a simple majority from just "waiting out" the clock to force through their favorite person.
The Logistics of the Wait
The clock doesn't start the second a pope dies or resigns. There’s a period called Sede Vacante (the seat is vacant).
First, there are the Novemdiales—nine days of official mourning and funerals. Then, the cardinals have to wait 15 to 20 days to make sure everyone from the far corners of the globe has time to get to Rome. In 2013, they tweaked this because travel is faster now, but the buffer is still there.
Once the doors are locked, the cardinals move into the Domus Sanctae Marthae. It’s a guesthouse inside the Vatican. Before 1996, they actually had to sleep on cots in rooms around the Sistine Chapel. It was cramped, hot, and miserable. Some historians think conclaves used to be faster because the cardinals just wanted to go home and sleep in a real bed. Now that they have a decent hotel, maybe they aren't in such a rush?
What Actually Happens Inside?
It's surprisingly low-tech. No iPads. No Twitter. No secret texting. They use paper ballots. Each cardinal writes "I elect as Supreme Pontiff..." and a name, folds it, and walks up to the altar under Michelangelo’s Last Judgment.
They swear an oath: "I call as my witness Christ the Lord who will be my judge, that my vote is given to the one who before God I think should be elected."
If no one gets the magic number, the ballots are tied together with a needle and thread and tossed into a stove. They add chemicals to make the smoke black. If someone wins, they use different chemicals (and ring the bells of St. Peter's just to be clear) to make the smoke white.
Does "White Smoke" Mean It’s Over?
Not quite. Once the vote is settled, the winner is asked: "Do you accept your canonical election as Supreme Pontiff?"
If he says yes (and he usually does, though some have reportedly cried or tried to decline), he picks a name. Then he heads to the "Room of Tears"—a tiny room off the Sistine Chapel—to put on his white cassock. They keep three sizes ready (small, medium, and large) because they don't know who is going to win.
After that, the Senior Cardinal Deacon heads to the balcony and shouts the famous words: Habemus Papam! (We have a Pope!). Only then is the "how long" question finally answered.
Actionable Insights for the Next Conclave
If you’re tracking a future election and wondering how long to elect a new pope, keep these tips in mind:
🔗 Read more: Did John Fetterman Leave the Democratic Party? What Really Happened
- Watch the First Two Days: If white smoke doesn't appear by the end of day two, it means there's a real split in the College of Cardinals.
- The "Friday" Rule: In the last few elections, the trend has been a Tuesday start with a Wednesday or Thursday finish.
- Ignore the Rumors: The Vatican is a sieve for leaks eventually, but during the actual conclave, the signal-jamming technology is top-notch. If someone on X (formerly Twitter) says they know the tally at 2:00 PM, they’re probably guessing.
- Check the "Papabili" List: Look at the age of the frontrunners. A College of older cardinals often leans toward a "transitional" pope, which can sometimes lead to a faster consensus than a younger, more "revolutionary" choice.
The reality is that while the ritual is ancient, the men in the room are very aware that the world is watching. They don't want to look divided. A quick election (2-3 days) is a sign of unity. A long election (over a week) suggests a church in the middle of a serious identity crisis. Either way, the chimney tells the story.