You're standing in front of your pantry. You've got a hunger that only a tuna melt can fix, and you spot a dusty can of albacore tucked behind the bag of flour. You pick it up. The date on the bottom says it expired six months ago. Now comes the internal debate. Do you risk the sandwich, or do you toss the can and head to the store? Most people think that "Best By" date is a hard deadline. It’s not. Honestly, if the can is intact, that tuna is probably still perfectly safe to eat, even if the quality has dipped a little.
How long does canned tuna last? It’s a question with a short answer and a long, slightly more complicated one.
The short answer: usually three to five years from the date of production. But here's the kicker—that’s just the manufacturer covering their back. Most experts, including those at the USDA, will tell you that canned goods can actually stay safe for years, even decades, as long as the seal hasn’t been compromised. Canned food is basically a time capsule.
The Science of Sterile Seals
Canning is a brutal process. That’s why it works. The fish is sealed in the can and then heated under pressure to temperatures well above boiling, usually around 240°F to 250°F ($115$°C to $121$°C). This kills everything. Every bacteria, every spore, every little thing that could make you sick or rot the meat is vaporized. Once that can cools and the vacuum seal holds, nothing new can get in.
As long as that vacuum remains, the tuna cannot rot in the traditional sense. It can’t.
However, time is a jerk. Even if the food is sterile, chemical reactions are still happening inside that tin. Over many years, the texture of the tuna might become mushy. The fats can oxidize slightly, giving it a "metallic" or "off" flavor, even if it won't actually give you food poisoning. This is why brands like Starkist or Bumble Bee put a "Best By" date on the can. They aren't telling you when it becomes toxic; they’re telling you when they no longer want to be held responsible for it tasting like a gourmet meal.
What the USDA Actually Says
The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service is surprisingly chill about this. They categorize high-acid foods (like canned tomatoes or fruit) as lasting about 18 months. But low-acid foods? That includes canned tuna, chicken, and beans. They state that these products will keep their "best quality" for 2 to 5 years.
Wait. Did you catch that?
They say "best quality," not "safety." If the can is in good shape—no bulges, no deep dents, no rust—the food inside is technically shelf-stable indefinitely. I’ve seen survivalists open cans of meat from the 1970s that were perfectly edible, though I wouldn't exactly call them delicious.
Checking for Danger
Don't be reckless. You need to look for specific red flags before you crack that can open.
- The Bulge: If the lid or the sides of the can are bulging out, throw it away. Do not open it. Do not smell it. Just get rid of it. That pressure usually means Clostridium botulinum has found a way to grow, and that’s a one-way ticket to the ER.
- The Rust: Surface rust you can wipe off with your thumb is fine. But if the rust is pitted and deep, it might have created microscopic holes that let air and bacteria inside.
- The Dent: Small dents on the side of the can are usually okay. Dents on the "seam" (where the lid meets the body) are a dealbreaker. If that seam is pinched, the vacuum is probably gone.
- The "Pschhh" Sound: When you pierce the can, you should hear a little hiss of air being sucked in. If liquid or gas squirts out under pressure, the tuna has gone bad.
Storage Variables That Change Everything
Where you keep your tuna matters more than the date on the tin. If you leave your canned tuna in a hot garage in Arizona, it’s going to degrade fast. Heat speeds up the chemical breakdown of the proteins and the lining of the can.
Ideally, you want a cool, dark place. 60°F to 70°F is the sweet spot.
I once knew a guy who kept his emergency stash in a crawlspace that flooded every spring. He ended up with "rust-through," where the moisture from the outside ate through the tin. If you live in a humid climate, keep your cans in a plastic bin. It sounds overkill until you’re hungry and your only meal is a rusty mess.
Pouch vs. Can: Does it Matter?
Lately, the foil pouches are everywhere. They're convenient. No draining! But they don't last as long as the cans.
Pouches are made of layers of plastic and foil. They are thinner and more susceptible to punctures or seal failure over time. Most manufacturers give pouches a shelf life of about 18 months to 3 years. If you’re building a long-term "prepper" pantry, stick to the cans. If you’re just buying lunch for next month, the pouch is fine.
The Sensory Test (The "Nose" Knows)
Let’s say the can looked fine, you opened it, and now you’re staring at it.
📖 Related: Other Words for Saddening: Why We’re All Saying It Wrong
Tuna always smells a bit... fishy. We know this. But there is a specific, sharp, acrid smell that indicates spoilage. If it smells like ammonia or "rotten eggs," stop.
Look at the color. High-quality tuna should be pinkish or light tan. If it has turned dark brown or grey, or if there are spots of green or black mold (which is rare in a sealed can but possible if the seal was weak), toss it. Sometimes you’ll see little white crystals. Those are usually just struvite, a natural mineral buildup in canned seafood. They aren't glass, and they won't hurt you. They just crunch a bit.
What Happens After You Open It?
This is where people actually get sick. Once that seal is broken, the "indefinite" clock stops.
You should never store the tuna in the open tin in the fridge. The metal can oxidize and leach a metallic taste into the fish once it's exposed to oxygen. Move the leftovers to a glass or plastic airtight container.
In the fridge, opened tuna lasts:
✨ Don't miss: How to Refuse Invitation Politely Without Losing Your Friends or Your Mind
- 3 to 4 days at most.
- If it’s mixed with mayo (tuna salad), the clock is even tighter because of the other ingredients.
If you aren't going to eat it in three days, you can actually freeze it. Just put it in a freezer bag. It’ll stay good for a couple of months, though the texture gets a little grainy after it thaws.
Environmental Impacts of Over-Tossing
We waste an incredible amount of food because of date labels. According to ReFED, a non-profit focused on food waste, standardizing date labels could save hundreds of thousands of tons of food from landfills. Canned tuna is a major culprit.
Before you dump that can, remember that the "expiration" is an estimate of peak flavor. If you're using the tuna in a casserole or a highly seasoned pasta dish, you probably won't even notice if it's a few years past the date.
Actionable Steps for Your Pantry
Stop treating the "Best By" date as a law. Treat it as a suggestion.
First, go through your pantry and rotate your stock. Use the "FIFO" method: First In, First Out. Put the newest cans in the back and the oldest in the front. This prevents you from ever having to wonder about a ten-year-old can of tuna.
Second, if you find a can that is a year past its date, perform the visual inspection. Check the seams. Check for bloating. If it passes, open it. Use your nose. If it smells like tuna, it's tuna.
🔗 Read more: Why Most Tattoo Designs for Men on Leg Fail to Age Well
Third, invest in a good manual can opener that doesn't leave jagged edges. This helps you see the seal clearly as you open it.
Lastly, if you're ever truly in doubt—if the can is weirdly sticky or the smell makes you gag—just toss it. Food poisoning from botulism is rare, but it's not worth a $2 can of fish. Most of the time, though? That "expired" tuna is just waiting for some mayo and a piece of toast.