You probably remember 2015 for a few specific things: that dress that was either blue or gold, the "Left Shark" at the Super Bowl, and a sudden, frantic obsession with two pencils balanced on a piece of paper. People were screaming. Phones were recording. Everyone wanted to know, how do you play the Charlie Charlie game, and more importantly, was a Mexican demon actually moving the stationary?
It was a weird time.
If you weren't on social media back then, or if you’re just now stumbling upon this bizarre piece of internet history, the game is essentially a "low-budget Ouija board." It requires almost zero equipment. No fancy wooden boards or planchettes. Just gravity, breath, and a healthy dose of suggestibility.
Setting the stage for Charlie
Let's get the logistics out of the way first. People often overcomplicate this, but the "ritual" is incredibly simple. To start, you need a plain sheet of paper. You draw a cross on it to create four quadrants. In two of the diagonal corners, you write "Yes," and in the other two, you write "No."
Then comes the tricky part. You take two pencils. You lay one down horizontally on the center line. Then, you balance the second pencil vertically on top of it, creating a delicate 3D cross.
The balance has to be perfect. If it's not, the top pencil will just roll off before you even say a word. Once it's steady—literally hanging by a thread of friction—the players chant the phrase: "Charlie, Charlie, can we play?" or "Charlie, Charlie, are you here?"
Then you wait.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
If the top pencil rotates toward "Yes," the room usually dissolves into absolute chaos. People jump over couches. They scream. They run out of the room. It’s a classic viral reaction. But the mechanics of how do you play the Charlie Charlie game are less about the supernatural and much more about basic physics.
The science behind the "demon"
Honestly, the "demon" isn't a demon. It’s gravity. And breath. And maybe a little bit of the vibration from your own racing heartbeat or the person sitting next to you shifting their weight.
Scientists and skeptics were quick to point out that balancing a round pencil on top of another round pencil is an exercise in extreme instability. The surface area where the two pencils touch is microscopic. Because of this, even the slightest gust of air—even the exhaled breath from someone asking the question—is enough to tip the scales.
Think about it. You’re leaning in close. You’re whispering or shouting "Charlie, Charlie." You are literally blowing air directly at a delicately balanced object.
There’s also the "ideomotor phenomenon." This is the same psychological quirk that makes Ouija boards "work." Your body makes tiny, unconscious micro-movements based on your expectations. Even if you aren't touching the table, the collective anticipation in a room can lead to subtle environmental changes that nudge the pencil. It's a fascinating look at how our brains want to find patterns and agency in random physical events.
Where did this "Charlie" guy come from anyway?
Despite the internet claims that Charlie is a "Mexican demon," folklorists are pretty quick to debunk that. There is no "Charlie" in Mexican mythology. The name isn't even Spanish. If it were a traditional Mexican legend, he’d likely be called Carlos.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
In reality, the game seems to be a mash-up of several different playground games. Variations of "Juego de la Lapicera" (The Pencil Game) have existed in various parts of the world for decades. Some involved holding pencils between two people’s fingers, similar to a dowsing rod.
The 2015 explosion was a perfect storm of social media mechanics. It started gaining traction in the Dominican Republic and then hopped over to the English-speaking web. It was the perfect "challenge" for the early days of short-form viral video. It was visual, it was scary, and it was easy to replicate.
The dark side of viral scares
While most people played it for a laugh, the game actually caused some genuine panic in certain parts of the world. In some schools in the UK and South America, the game was banned because students were becoming genuinely hysterical.
Psychologists call this "mass psychogenic illness" or mass hysteria. When you have a group of people—especially young people—who are all primed to see something supernatural, the collective fear becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. One person faints or has a panic attack, and suddenly the whole school thinks the building is haunted.
It's a reminder that even "silly" internet trends have real-world psychological impacts.
The marketing twist you probably missed
Here is the "aha!" moment that a lot of people forgot. Right as the Charlie Charlie Challenge was peaking, a trailer dropped for a horror movie called The Gallows.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The movie featured—you guessed it—a spirit named Charlie.
Warner Bros. was accused of manufacturing the entire viral trend as a "guerrilla marketing" stunt. While the game did exist in various forms before the movie, the timing of the massive 2015 surge was suspiciously convenient. It’s one of the most successful examples of how a studio can take an existing urban legend, give it a fresh coat of paint, and let the internet’s natural desire for "spookiness" do all the heavy lifting for the marketing budget.
If you still want to try it
If you’re still curious about how do you play the Charlie Charlie game just to see if you can get the pencils to move, go for it. It's a fun experiment in physics.
- Use unsharpened pencils. The flat edges actually make it harder to move, whereas rounded, high-quality pencils will spin at the slightest breeze.
- Check the floor. If you’re in an old house with slanted floors, gravity is going to do the work for you every single time.
- Control your breathing. Try asking the question while wearing a mask or covering your mouth. You’ll notice the "demon" suddenly becomes a lot less active when you aren't blowing air into the "ritual" space.
Moving past the pencils
The Charlie Charlie craze eventually died down, replaced by Clowns in 2016 and whatever other digital ghosts we've chased since. But it remains a benchmark for how we consume "scary" content. We want to believe, even for a second, that there’s something more than just wood and lead on that paper.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into why these things go viral, look into the concept of "Legend Tripping." It’s a sociological term for when people go to a "haunted" place or perform a ritual to test the limits of the supernatural. Charlie Charlie was just a digital version of going to a haunted bridge at midnight.
Instead of looking for a demon, use the experience to look at how easily the human mind is tricked. Test different pencil types. Change the room temperature. Use a fan to see exactly how much force is required to move the top pencil. You'll find that the "supernatural" usually has a very logical, very physical explanation.
Next Steps for the Curious:
Research the "Ideomotor Effect" to see how your subconscious controls your movement. Alternatively, look up the history of "The Gallows" marketing campaign to see how Hollywood manipulates social media trends. If you want to keep the "spooky" vibe going without the pseudo-demons, look into the history of Victorian Spiritualism—it's where most of these parlor tricks actually originated.