You’ve seen the jars in the grocery store. They’re expensive. Sometimes eight or nine dollars for a single quart of liquid that looks suspiciously like watered-down apple juice. If you’ve ever wondered, how do you make your own bone broth without spending a fortune or ending up with a pot of salty brown water, you aren't alone. Most people mess this up the first time because they treat it like a standard soup stock. It isn't soup stock. Stock is about flavor; bone broth is about collagen, glycine, and that weird, jiggly gelatinous texture that proves you actually extracted the good stuff from the marrow and joints.
I remember the first time I tried this. I threw some leftover chicken bones in a pot, boiled them for three hours, and felt like a culinary genius. It was fine. It tasted like chicken. But it didn't "gel" when it got cold. That's the litmus test. If your broth stays liquid in the fridge, you didn't make bone broth—you made a thin tea. To get the real benefits, you need heat, time, and a very specific ratio of parts.
Why Your Ingredients Matter More Than Your Method
Most people start with whatever is left over from Sunday dinner. That’s a great start, but it’s rarely enough. If you want that deep, viscous quality, you need the "ugly" bits. We're talking feet, necks, knuckles, and joints. These are the collagen goldmines. According to Dr. Cate Shanahan, author of Deep Nutrition, the connective tissue found in these specific cuts is what provides the structural proteins our bodies crave. If you’re just using a picked-over rotisserie carcass, you're missing the engine room of the broth.
You should aim for a mix. Use the marrow bones for flavor and the knuckle bones for the gel. If you're doing beef, ask your butcher for "pipe" bones (the long ones with marrow) and "knuckle" bones. For chicken, the secret weapon is feet. Honestly, it looks a bit macabre when you first toss a couple of yellow chicken feet into a pot, but the results speak for themselves. They are almost pure collagen.
Don't overcomplicate the vegetables. A few carrots, some celery, an onion with the skin still on (it gives the broth a beautiful amber color), and maybe some peppercorns. If you add too many greens like broccoli or kale, the broth gets bitter. Keep it simple. The bones are the star.
👉 See also: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
The Roasting Secret and the Low-Simmer Struggle
Stop. Do not put raw beef bones in water. If you do, your broth will taste like iron and sadness. You have to roast them first.
Throw your bones on a sheet pan at 400°F for about thirty minutes. You want them browned, nearly charred in spots. This is the Maillard reaction at work. It creates the complex flavors that make the broth drinkable on its own. Chicken bones don't strictly need this if they’re already from a roasted bird, but it never hurts.
Once they’re roasted, everything goes into the pot. Or the Crock-Pot. Or the Instant Pot.
Now, here is where how do you make your own bone broth becomes a test of patience. If you’re using a traditional stovetop pot, we are talking about a 12 to 24-hour simmer for chicken, and up to 48 hours for beef. It shouldn't be a rolling boil. If you boil it hard, you’ll emulsify the fats into the liquid and end up with a cloudy, greasy mess. You want a "lazy bubble." Just one or two bubbles breaking the surface every few seconds.
✨ Don't miss: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
The Vinegar Myth
You'll see a lot of recipes insisting on Apple Cider Vinegar (ACV). The theory is that the acid pulls the minerals out of the bones. Scientifically, the jury is out on whether two tablespoons of vinegar in a gallon of water actually changes the mineral density of the final product. However, it does help break down the connective tissue slightly. Use it, but don't think it's doing all the heavy lifting. The heat does the work.
Troubleshooting the "No-Gel" Problem
It is heartbreaking to spend 24 hours hovering over a stove only to have a liquid result. If your broth didn't gel, one of three things happened:
- Too much water. This is the #1 mistake. You only want the water to cover the bones by about an inch or two. If you fill a massive stockpot to the brim with only one carcass, you’ve diluted the collagen too far.
- Not enough joints. You used marrow bones but no knuckles or feet. Marrow is fat; joints are gelatin.
- Not long enough. Beef bones are dense. They don't give up their secrets easily. If you stopped at 8 hours, you quit before the magic happened.
Pressure Cookers vs. Slow Cookers
The Instant Pot changed the game for bone broth. What used to take two days now takes about three hours under high pressure. Is it as good? Some purists say no, claiming the high heat destroys some of the more delicate amino acids. But for most of us living real lives, a 3-hour broth that actually gels is better than a 48-hour broth we never have time to make.
If you use a pressure cooker, the same rules apply: don't overfill with water. Let it depressurize naturally. If you vent it manually (the "quick release"), the sudden change in pressure can cause the liquid to boil violently inside, which makes the broth cloudy.
🔗 Read more: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Straining and Storage
Once it's done, you need to get the solids out fast. Use a fine-mesh strainer. If you want it really clear, line the strainer with cheesecloth.
Don't put a giant pot of boiling hot liquid directly into your fridge. You'll raise the internal temp of your refrigerator and spoil your milk. Instead, sink the pot in a sink full of ice water for twenty minutes to bring the temp down.
Once it's chilled, a layer of fat will settle on the top and harden. This is the "fat cap." Don't throw it away! It acts as a natural seal that keeps the broth fresh for longer in the fridge. When you're ready to use the broth, just crack the fat layer off. You can use that fat (tallow or schmaltz) for roasting potatoes later. It’s liquid gold.
Real World Application
So, how do you make your own bone broth part of your routine? I keep a gallon-sized freezer bag in my kitchen. Every time I peel a carrot, chop an onion, or finish a roast chicken, the scraps go in the bag. When the bag is full, it's broth day.
It’s not just for sipping. Use it to cook rice or quinoa. The grains soak up the protein and flavor, turning a boring side dish into something nutrient-dense. Use it to deglaze a pan after searing a steak.
Actionable Steps for Your First Batch
- Source the right bones: Go to a local butcher and specifically ask for "knuckle bones" and "chicken feet." These are often very cheap because most people don't want them.
- Roast for color: Roast beef or pork bones at 400°F until dark brown. Skip this for chicken if you're in a hurry, but never for beef.
- The 1-inch rule: Put your bones in the pot and add just enough filtered water to cover them by one inch.
- Low and slow: Set your slow cooker to "low" and walk away for at least 18 hours. If using an Instant Pot, 120 minutes on High Pressure with a natural release.
- The Chill Test: Strain the liquid into glass jars and refrigerate overnight. In the morning, it should have the consistency of Jell-O. If it does, you've succeeded.
- Freeze the excess: Bone broth only lasts about 4-5 days in the fridge. Pour the extra into silicone muffin tins or ice cube trays, freeze them, and then toss the "broth cubes" into a freezer bag for easy portioning later.
The difference between homemade broth and the store-bought "stock" is night and day. You'll feel it in the mouthfeel—that silky, coating sensation—and you'll see it in the way your soups have a body and depth that bouillon cubes can't touch. Just remember: more bones, less water, and plenty of time.