You're sitting there with a flight in three hours. You found this incredible 40-minute documentary on retro gaming or maybe a specific coding tutorial you need for a project, and you know the airplane Wi-Fi is going to be absolute garbage. Naturally, you wonder: how do you convert a youtube video to mp4 so you can actually watch it offline?
It sounds like it should be easy. It isn't. Not really.
The internet is currently a minefield of "free" converters that are basically just delivery vehicles for malware, intrusive pop-up ads for online casinos, and weird browser extensions that track your every move. It’s frustrating. Most people just want a file they can drop into VLC or QuickTime without feeling like they need to format their hard drive afterward.
The Elephant in the Room: Is This Even Legal?
Before we get into the "how," we have to talk about the "should." Technically, downloading videos violates YouTube’s Terms of Service. They want you on the platform. They want you seeing ads. That's how the lights stay on.
If you’re using a tool to rip a creator’s work just to avoid giving them a view, that’s kinda crummy. However, there are legitimate fair use cases. Maybe you’re a video editor needing a three-second clip for a transformative critique. Maybe you're a student in a rural area with intermittent connectivity. Or maybe you just pay for YouTube Premium—which is the only "official" way to do this—but you're annoyed that the downloads stay locked inside the app.
Legal experts like those at the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) have long debated the nuances of time-shifting and space-shifting media. Generally, if you aren't redistributing the file or making money off it, you're in a gray area, but the tools themselves often live in a perpetual game of cat-and-mouse with Google’s legal team.
The Desktop Powerhouse: yt-dlp
If you ask any data hoarder or serious tech enthusiast how do you convert a youtube video to mp4, they aren't going to point you to a website with flashing "DOWNLOAD NOW" buttons. They’re going to tell you to use yt-dlp.
It’s a command-line tool. Don't panic.
I know, the "command line" sounds like something out of a 90s hacker movie. But honestly, it’s the most robust, clean, and honest piece of software for this task. It’s an open-source branch of the original youtube-dl project, which hit some legal snags a few years back but was eventually vindicated because, well, code is speech.
Why is it better? No ads. No tracking. It fetches the highest quality possible, including 4K and 8K, which most web-based converters can't touch. Most web tools cap out at 720p or 1080p because processing 4K video on a server is expensive for them.
To use it, you basically install it via a package manager like Homebrew on Mac or just download the .exe for Windows. You open your terminal, type yt-dlp -f mp4 [URL], and hit enter. It’s done. It’s fast. It’s surgical.
The Problem With Online Converters
We’ve all been there. You Google "YouTube to MP4," click the first result, and immediately get a notification that "Your PC is infected with 14 viruses." It’s a lie, obviously. These sites rely on aggressive advertising networks.
But let's say you find a "clean" one. Here is what's happening behind the scenes:
The site’s server fetches the video from YouTube, uses a library like FFmpeg to mux the video and audio streams into an MP4 container, and then hosts that file for you to download.
This costs them money in bandwidth.
To offset that, they often compress the living daylights out of your video. That "1080p" MP4 you just downloaded? It probably has a bitrate so low that the shadows look like Minecraft blocks. If you care about visual fidelity, web converters are almost always a compromise.
Handbrake and the Two-Step Method
Sometimes, you don't get an MP4. You get a WebM file.
YouTube loves the WebM format (VP9 or AV1 codecs) because it’s efficient. It keeps file sizes small while maintaining high quality. But your old iPad or your car’s headrest monitor might only play MP4 (H.264).
This is where Handbrake comes in.
Handbrake is a free, open-source transcoder. It’s the industry standard for a reason. If you have a video file that won’t play on your device, you toss it into Handbrake, select the "Fast 1080p30" preset (which targets MP4), and let it rip.
It’s a two-step process:
- Get the video onto your drive (using yt-dlp or a trusted downloader).
- Convert it to the specific flavor of MP4 your device requires.
Is it more work? Yeah. Is the quality better? Tenfold.
📖 Related: Why Aren't My AirPods Max Connecting? Real Fixes for Apple’s Premium Headphones
Mobile Woes: Doing This on iPhone or Android
Mobile is where things get tricky. Apple and Google both have a vested interest in you not downloading YouTube videos. You won't find a "YouTube to MP4" app in the App Store; it would be kicked off in ten minutes.
On Android, you have "sideloading." Apps like NewPipe or SkyTube are legendary in certain circles. They are third-party YouTube clients that allow for direct downloads. You won't find them on the Play Store, though. You have to go to F-Droid or their official sites. It’s a bit "wild west," so you have to trust the developers.
On iPhone? You're mostly stuck with the "Shortcuts" app. There are community-made shortcuts (like R⤓Download) that use a series of web-scraping scripts to pull the video. They break constantly because YouTube changes its code almost weekly to stop exactly this kind of thing.
Quality Settings: Why Your Video Looks Grainy
When you ask how do you convert a youtube video to mp4, you also need to ask about bitrate.
An MP4 is just a "container." Think of it like a box. Inside that box, you have the video track and the audio track. The video is usually encoded in H.264 or H.265.
If you use a cheap converter, it might use a very high compression ratio to save on their own server costs. This results in "banding"—where a smooth sunset looks like a series of ugly orange stripes. To avoid this, always look for tools that allow "Passthrough" or "High Profile" encoding.
VLC: The Secret Converter
Most people know VLC as the "player that plays everything."
Few people realize it’s also a converter.
If you have a video file—or even a network stream—you can go to Media > Convert / Save in VLC. You paste the YouTube URL (though this is buggy lately due to YouTube's encryption), choose "Video - H.264 + MP3 (MP4)," and tell it where to save.
It’s a bit clunky. The interface looks like it hasn't been updated since 2004. But it works without you having to install some "FreeVideoDownloaderPro_Setup.exe" that changes your default search engine to something weird you've never heard of.
The Risks You Aren't Thinking About
Beyond the malware, there's the privacy aspect. When you paste a URL into a random conversion website, you are telling that site's owner exactly what you're interested in. They have your IP address. They have your video preference.
In an era of data harvesting, that's just one more piece of the puzzle for brokers. This is why local tools—software that runs on your machine, not someone else's server—are always the superior choice for the privacy-conscious.
What About 4K?
Here is a technical hurdle: YouTube stores high-resolution video (above 1080p) and audio as separate streams. This is called DASH (Dynamic Adaptive Streaming over HTTP).
This is why many "simple" converters only give you 720p. They aren't smart enough to download the 4K video stream, download the audio stream, and then "glue" them together.
Tools like yt-dlp do this automatically using a helper called FFmpeg. It’s the "pro" way. If you’re trying to get a 4K video of a space launch for a high-res presentation, don't bother with websites. They will let you down 99% of the time.
Step-by-Step Reality Check
If you want to do this right now, here is the most reliable path:
- Download yt-dlp. If you are on Windows, put the .exe in a folder.
- Download FFmpeg. This is the "engine" that handles the actual converting. Put it in the same folder as yt-dlp.
- Open Command Prompt. Navigate to that folder.
- Run the command. Use
yt-dlp -f "bestvideo[ext=mp4]+bestaudio[ext=m4a]/best[ext=mp4]/best" [YOUR_URL].
This specific command tells the software: "Find me the best MP4 video and the best audio and merge them. If you can't find a ready-made MP4, find the best thing available and make it an MP4."
It is the "set it and forget it" solution.
Summary of Actionable Steps
Stop searching for "free online converters." Most are junk. Instead, invest ten minutes in setting up a local tool.
- For the tech-savvy: Use yt-dlp combined with FFmpeg. It is the gold standard, period.
- For the casual user: Use VLC Media Player's built-in conversion feature, but be prepared for it to fail on certain protected videos.
- For mobile users: Look into NewPipe (Android) or the Shortcuts app (iOS), but keep your expectations low regarding longevity.
- For editors: Always check the bitrate. An MP4 is only as good as the data inside it. If the file size seems too small for a 10-minute video (like under 50MB for 1080p), the quality is going to be poor.
The landscape of video conversion is always shifting. Sites that work today will be seized by authorities or blocked by Google tomorrow. By using open-source desktop tools, you bypass the cycle of broken websites and keep your hardware safe from the more "adventurous" parts of the internet.
Once you have your MP4, check the metadata. Sometimes these tools leave weird titles or missing thumbnails. You can use a tool like Mp3tag (it does MP4s too) to clean up the file names so your media library looks professional and organized. Ready your storage, because once you realize how easy it is to archive high-quality video, you'll start running out of hard drive space faster than you think.