Hollywood is a liar. We’ve all seen the scene: a man in a suit suddenly gasps, clutches his chest with both hands, and collapses onto a mahogany boardroom table. It’s dramatic. It’s clear. It’s also kinda rare in the real world. Honestly, if you’re waiting for a "crushing" pain that feels like an elephant sitting on your ribs, you might miss the subtle, strange, and frankly annoying signals your body sends out hours before things get critical.
How can you tell if you're having a heart attack when it feels more like a bad case of Mexican food from the night before? It’s a terrifying question. The reality is that many people—especially women and people with diabetes—don't experience the "classic" symptoms. Instead, they get a weird ache in their jaw or a sudden, overwhelming exhaustion that feels like they’ve just run a marathon while sitting on the couch.
A heart attack, or myocardial infarction, happens when the blood flow to a part of the heart is blocked. This is usually due to a buildup of fat, cholesterol, and other substances, which form a plaque in the arteries (coronary arteries). Sometimes, that plaque ruptures and forms a clot. No blood means no oxygen. No oxygen means the heart muscle starts dying. Fast.
The Physical Reality of the "Slow Burn"
It isn’t always a lightning bolt. According to the American Heart Association, many heart attacks start slowly, with mild pain or discomfort. You might even find yourself wondering if you should just take an antacid and lie down. Don't.
Chest discomfort is the most common symptom, but it doesn't have to be "pain." People describe it as pressure, squeezing, fullness, or just a heavy sensation. It usually lasts more than a few minutes, or it might go away and then come back. If you’re feeling a fluttering or a sharp poke that only lasts a second when you breathe in, that’s often something else, like pleurisy or a strained muscle. But that dull, persistent "weight"? That’s the red flag.
Then there’s the referred pain. Your nervous system is a bit of a mess when it comes to internal organs. The nerves that carry signals from the heart often travel the same pathways as nerves from the arms or the neck. Your brain gets confused. This is why you might feel a strange numbness in your left arm, or even your right one. Or your back. Some people swear they just thought they had a toothache because the pain radiated up into their lower jaw.
Why Women Experience This Differently
We need to talk about the gender gap here because it’s literally a matter of life and death. For decades, medical research focused on men. Consequently, the "standard" symptoms were based on male physiology.
🔗 Read more: Ingestion of hydrogen peroxide: Why a common household hack is actually dangerous
Women are much more likely to report shortness of breath, nausea, and back or jaw pain. In fact, a study published in Circulation found that nearly 40% of women experienced indigestion in the weeks leading up to their heart attack. They didn't have chest pain at all. They just felt "off." They felt flu-like.
If you are a woman and you suddenly feel a cold sweat breaking out while you're just watching TV, or if you feel an unusual fatigue that makes it hard to walk to the mailbox, pay attention. Your body is screaming, even if it's not using the "chest pain" megaphone. It’s a quiet urgency.
The Subtle Warning Signs You’re Likely to Ignore
Let's break down the stuff that doesn't make it into the movies.
Lightheadedness and Dizziness.
If you suddenly feel like the room is spinning or you might faint, and it’s accompanied by chest discomfort or shortness of breath, your heart might not be pumping enough blood to your brain. This isn't the "I stood up too fast" dizzy. It's a "something is very wrong with my internal gravity" dizzy.
Cold Sweats.
This is a big one. It’s often called diaphoresis. If you’re not exercising and you aren't in a hot room, but you’re suddenly drenched in a cold, clammy sweat, your sympathetic nervous system is in overdrive. It’s the "fight or flight" response kicking in because your heart is under stress.
Nausea and Stomach Pain.
This is why so many people die at home thinking they have food poisoning. Heart attacks can cause GI distress. The vagus nerve, which runs near the heart, also interacts with the digestive system. Stimulate one, and the other reacts. If the "indigestion" feels different than your usual heartburn—maybe it’s more "gnawing" or is accompanied by a sense of impending doom—get help.
💡 You might also like: Why the EMS 20/20 Podcast is the Best Training You’re Not Getting in School
How Can You Tell If You're Having a Heart Attack or Just Panic?
This is a tough one. The symptoms of a panic attack and a heart attack overlap almost perfectly. Rapid heart rate? Check. Sweating? Check. Shortness of breath? Check. Feeling like you’re going to die? Double check.
The main difference is often the duration and the trigger. Panic attacks usually peak within 10 minutes and then start to subside. Heart attack symptoms tend to persist or worsen over time. Also, heart attack pain often changes with physical exertion. If you walk up a flight of stairs and the pain gets worse, it’s likely your heart. If the pain stays the same regardless of whether you're running or sitting, it might be anxiety—but you shouldn't bet your life on that distinction.
Dr. Sharonne Hayes from the Mayo Clinic often points out that if you've never had a panic attack before and you start having these symptoms after age 40, it's safer to assume it's the heart. Don't let embarrassment keep you from the ER. Doctors would much rather tell you that you're stressed than perform an autopsy.
The Science of "Silent" Heart Attacks
About 1 in 5 heart attacks are "silent." This means the person has no idea it happened until a doctor sees the damage on an EKG months or years later.
Silent myocardial infarctions (SMIs) are especially common in people with diabetes. High blood sugar over long periods can damage the nerves that carry pain signals from the heart. Essentially, the "alarm system" is broken. In these cases, the only clues might be a slight increase in fatigue or a mild shortness of breath during activities that used to be easy.
What to Do Right Now
If you suspect you or someone else is having a heart attack, the clock is your biggest enemy. "Time is muscle." Every minute the blood flow is blocked, more heart tissue dies.
📖 Related: High Protein in a Blood Test: What Most People Get Wrong
- Call 911 immediately. Do not drive yourself. Do not let a friend drive you unless you have absolutely no other choice. Paramedics can start treatment the second they arrive. They have EKGs in the ambulance. They can transmit that data to the hospital so the cardiac cath lab is ready before you even through the doors.
- Chew an aspirin. Unless you are allergic or have been told by a doctor never to take it. Chewing a full-strength (325mg) aspirin or four baby aspirins helps thin the blood and can break down the clot that’s causing the blockage. Chewing it gets it into your bloodstream faster than swallowing it whole.
- Stay still. Don't pace. Don't try to "walk it off." Sit down, stay calm, and try to breathe deeply. Any physical exertion puts more demand on your struggling heart.
- Be loud at the hospital. If you get to the ER, don't say "I'm having some chest discomfort." Say, "I think I'm having a heart attack." Those magic words trigger a specific protocol that moves you to the front of the line.
A Note on E-E-A-T and Medical Reality
It’s vital to remember that I am an AI, not a doctor. While this information is based on established protocols from the American College of Cardiology and the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, every human body is a unique biological machine.
Sometimes, the symptoms don't fit the script. Some people just feel a "fullness" in their throat. Others feel like they have a pulled muscle in their upper back. The bottom line is that you know your "normal." If you feel a sensation that is new, persistent, and "wrong" in your chest, upper body, or general energy levels, it warrants a professional opinion.
Medical science has come a long way. With modern interventions like stents and clot-busting drugs (thrombolytics), a heart attack is no longer an automatic death sentence. But those tools only work if you get to them in time.
Actionable Steps for Prevention and Preparedness
Knowing how can you tell if you're having a heart attack is the "break glass in case of emergency" plan. But you should also be proactive.
- Get a Calcium Score Test. If you're over 40 and have risk factors, this quick CT scan measures the amount of calcified plaque in your coronary arteries. It’s a much better predictor than cholesterol alone.
- Know your numbers. Keep track of your blood pressure and A1C levels. High pressure wears down the artery walls, making it easier for plaque to stick.
- Listen to your "prodromal" symptoms. Many people, in hindsight, realize they felt unusually tired or had "indigestion" for two or three days before the big event. If you feel weirdly "off" for more than 24 hours, call your primary care doctor.
- Carry a list. Keep a list of your medications and allergies in your wallet or on a medical ID on your phone. If you become unresponsive, this helps the EMTs tremendously.
The best way to handle a heart attack is to catch it while it's still just a "possibility" and not a "catastrophe." Trust your gut. If something feels life-threatening, treat it that way until a professional tells you otherwise.
Next Steps for Your Health:
- Audit your family history: Talk to your relatives to see if anyone had a "sudden" heart event before age 55. Genetic predisposition is a major factor that lifestyle can't always override.
- Schedule a baseline EKG: Having a "normal" EKG on file gives doctors something to compare against if you ever show up in the ER with vague symptoms.
- Review your symptoms: If you're currently feeling any of the "atypical" signs mentioned—like unexplained jaw pain or extreme fatigue—contact a healthcare provider immediately for an evaluation.