You’re heading to the Enchanted Mountains. Maybe it’s for a basketball game at the Reilly Center, a chaotic graduation weekend, or just a quiet visit to see your kid who’s currently buried in books at Friedsam Memorial Library. Whatever the reason, you need a place to crash. But here is the thing: if you wait too long to book hotels near St. Bonaventure University, you’ll end up staying in a different zip code entirely.
Honestly, the hotel scene in Olean and Allegany is smaller than you think. People assume they can just roll into town and find a room. Nope. Not during Family Weekend. Not when the Bonnies have a big home game. You’ve got to be smart about this.
The Reality of Staying Right on the Edge of Campus
If you want to be able to smell the campus coffee from your window, you have two main choices. They are basically neighbors.
The Fairfield Inn & Suites Olean is about as close as you can get without actually sleeping in a dorm room. It’s a 9-minute walk to campus. It’s clean. It has that fire pit outside that everyone raves about in the reviews. If you’re visiting in the fall when the air gets that sharp, New York chill, sitting by that fire with a drink is pretty much the peak experience. They don't allow pets, though, so leave the dog at home if you're staying here.
Right next door is the Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham Olean/Allegany.
This place is usually the budget-friendly hero of the area. It’s literally steps from the university. Is it fancy? No. Is it functional? Absolutely. It’s pet-friendly, which is a massive win for people traveling with their labradors. It’s also right next to a Dunkin’, which is basically a requirement for surviving a 10:00 AM graduation ceremony.
✨ Don't miss: The Rees Hotel Luxury Apartments & Lakeside Residences: Why This Spot Still Wins Queenstown
Why Distance Matters in Olean
You might see "Olean" on a map and think it’s all one small cluster. It sort of is, but West State Street can get surprisingly congested. If you stay at the Best Western Plus University Inn, you’re still less than a mile away, but you’re in the middle of the commercial strip.
This Best Western is actually one of the higher-rated spots in town. They do a full hot breakfast—not just a sad muffin in a plastic wrap—and they have an indoor pool. If you’re traveling with kids who need to burn off energy while you try to recover from a day of walking the campus hills, this is the spot.
When the Chains are Full: The "Local" Secret
Look, sometimes the Marriott and the Best Western are booked solid six months in advance. It happens. When that hits, you have to look toward downtown Olean or even a bit further out.
The Old Library Inn is a total vibe shift. It’s a historic Victorian bed and breakfast located about two and a half miles from the university. If you hate the "beige" feeling of corporate hotels, this is where you go. It’s got creaky floors, massive windows, and a lot of character. Plus, it’s right next to the Old Library Restaurant, which is arguably one of the best places to get a steak in the Southern Tier.
The Downtown Alternatives
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Olean: This is a bit further down Main Street. It’s newer, very clean, and they have a saltwater pool. It’s about a 10-minute drive to St. Bonaventure.
- Hampton Inn & Suites Olean: Located on Jack Murphy Blvd, it’s tucked away a bit. It’s reliable. You know exactly what you’re getting with a Hampton Inn—consistent beds and decent coffee.
The Ellicottville Pivot
Here is a pro tip that most first-timers miss. If everything in Olean is overpriced or full, look 25 minutes north to Ellicottville.
🔗 Read more: The Largest Spider in the World: What Most People Get Wrong
During the winter, Ellicottville is a ski town, so it’ll be packed. But in the shoulder seasons or even during graduation, places like the Wingate by Wyndham Ellicottville or the Edelweiss Lodge are fantastic. The drive from Ellicottville to St. Bonaventure is an easy, scenic shot down Route 219. You get the benefit of being in a "resort" town with better bars and boutiques, but you're still close enough to make the 9:00 AM campus tour.
Common Misconceptions About Booking Near SBU
People think the prices are static. They aren't.
During a random Tuesday in February, you might snag a room for $95. During Parent’s Weekend? That same room might be $350 with a two-night minimum. The hotels know they have a captive audience.
Another thing: parking. If you stay at the Fairfield or Microtel, you can basically leave your car and walk to the Reilly Center. This is huge because parking on campus during a sold-out basketball game is a nightmare. You’ll spend 45 minutes trying to find a spot near the back of the lot otherwise.
What About Airbnbs?
Honestly, the Airbnb market in Olean is growing. You’ll find some cool spots, like the "Ho-Sta-Geh Retreat" or various historic homes in the Oak Hill district.
💡 You might also like: Sumela Monastery: Why Most People Get the History Wrong
If you have a group of four or more, an Airbnb is almost always a better deal than getting two hotel rooms. There are several entire houses for rent within a mile of campus. Just check the reviews specifically for "smell" and "heating." Some of these older Olean homes can be a bit drafty in the winter months.
Nuance and the "Enchanted Mountain" Factor
One thing to keep in mind is the weather. January and February in Cattaraugus County are no joke. If you book a hotel that requires a 15-minute drive, make sure you’re comfortable driving in lake-effect snow. The roads are well-plowed, but the visibility can drop to zero in a heartbeat.
If you aren't used to winter driving, stay at the Microtel or Fairfield. Being able to walk (or take a very short, slow drive) takes the stress out of a snowy visit.
Summary of Where to Stay Based on Your Needs
- For Walking Access: Fairfield Inn & Suites or Microtel.
- For the Best Breakfast: Best Western Plus University Inn.
- For a Romantic/Historic Vibe: Old Library Inn.
- For Group Trips: Search for Airbnbs in the Union Street or Oak Hill area.
- For a "Vibe" and Better Dining: Head to Ellicottville.
Actionable Next Steps
Before you click "book," do these three things:
- Check the SBU Basketball Schedule: If there is a home game against a rival, hotel prices will spike.
- Call the Hotel Directly: Especially for the Best Western or Fairfield. Sometimes they have "University Rates" for parents that don't show up on Expedia or Booking.com.
- Map the "Back Way": If you're staying in downtown Olean, learn the route via Constitution Ave or Front Street to avoid the bottleneck on West State Street during peak campus events.
The biggest mistake is waiting. In a town this size, the difference between a 2-minute commute and a 40-minute commute is usually just a 24-hour delay in booking.