Finding a place to crash in Broad Ripple is trickier than most people realize. You look at a map, see the vibrant "Village" area with all the bars, the Monon Trail, and the White River, and you think, "I'll just grab a room right there."
Then you realize there is exactly one traditional hotel in the heart of the neighborhood. One.
If you’re coming to Indy for a show at The Vogue, a graduation at Butler University, or just to eat your weight in tacos and local brews, you’ve basically got three choices: the boutique lodge on the trail, a rental house, or a "nearby" hotel that’s actually a fifteen-minute Uber ride away in Keystone or Downtown. Honestly, picking the wrong one can turn a walkable weekend into a logistical headache.
The Only Game in Town: Hotel Broad Ripple
Let’s talk about the Hotel Broad Ripple. It’s located at 6520 Westfield Blvd, and it’s basically the crown jewel of the neighborhood for anyone who hates cookie-cutter Marriotts. It isn’t really a "hotel" in the way you’re thinking—it’s more like an upscale lodge-style inn.
The property is split. You’ve got the Main Lodge, the Cottage rooms, and the Corduroy Tower. If you can snag a room in the Tower, do it. The views of the neighborhood and the canal are the best you’ll get. Plus, it’s literally steps from the Monon Trail. You can walk out the door, turn left, and you’re in the middle of the Village in three minutes.
📖 Related: Novotel Perth Adelaide Terrace: What Most People Get Wrong
One thing that surprises people is the "Honor System" bar. They have a Bunkhouse Lounge where you can grab a local craft beer or a glass of wine and just write it down. It feels very midwestern and trusting. But heads up: there is no full-service restaurant on-site. They do a continental breakfast, but for dinner, you’re walking to Broad Ripple Ave.
The biggest "gotcha" here? Staffing. They don't always have someone at the front desk after 5:00 PM or 6:00 PM. If you're arriving late, you need to coordinate your check-in ahead of time or you might be standing on the porch wondering where your key is. It’s a very "un-hotel" experience that locals love but business travelers sometimes find jarring.
When Broad Ripple Hotels Are Full: The Keystone Backup
Since the Village only has one dedicated hotel, it fills up fast, especially during Butler’s move-in weekend or the Broad Ripple Art Fair. When that happens, most people default to the Keystone Crossing area.
Ironworks Hotel Indy is the heavy hitter here. It’s about 3 miles north of Broad Ripple. If you’re into that industrial-chic vibe—think exposed brick, leather, and heavy metal fixtures—this is your spot. It’s home to Provision and Cunningham Restaurant Group’s high-end spots, so the food is spectacular.
👉 See also: Magnolia Fort Worth Texas: Why This Street Still Defines the Near Southside
But here is the reality check: you are not walking from Ironworks to Broad Ripple.
You’re driving or Ubering down Keystone Ave or College Ave. It’s a 10-minute trip on a good day, but on a Friday night when everyone is heading to the Village? It’s a crawl.
If you want something more standard and less "industrial vibe," the Sheraton Indianapolis Hotel at Keystone Crossing is right there too. It’s connected to the Fashion Mall. It’s fine. It’s a Sheraton. You know exactly what the carpet looks like before you walk in. It’s a safe bet if you have Marriott points to burn, but you lose that Broad Ripple soul.
The Airbnb and Rental Reality
Because of the lack of traditional hotels in Broad Ripple, the short-term rental market is massive. You’ll find tons of "Ripplebnbs" or bungalows tucked into the streets between College and the river.
Staying in a rental gives you a much better feel for why people actually live here. You get the front porch life. You see people walking their dogs to the park.
✨ Don't miss: Why Molly Butler Lodge & Restaurant is Still the Heart of Greer After a Century
A few tips if you go this route:
- Check the parking situation. Many of the bungalows only have street parking. Broad Ripple street parking is a nightmare on weekends. Look for listings that specifically mention a driveway or a "parking pad."
- Noise levels. If you book a place within two blocks of Broad Ripple Ave, you are going to hear the bass from the bars until 3:00 AM. If you’re here to party, great. If you’re here for a quiet weekend, stay south of 62nd Street or north of the canal.
- The "Nora" trap. Some listings say "Broad Ripple area" but they are actually in Nora or near 86th Street. Check the map. If it’s north of 75th Street, you aren't walking to the bars.
Butler University Parents: Where to Pivot
If you are a Butler parent and Hotel Broad Ripple is booked, don't just look north. Look south into Meridian-Kessler. There aren't many hotels there either, but there are high-end guest suites like the CozySuites at Meridian Kessler on College Ave.
The Bottleworks Hotel on Mass Ave is also a popular pivot. It’s about 15-20 minutes away, but the Red Line (Indy’s rapid transit bus) runs straight from Mass Ave up to Broad Ripple. It’s a gorgeous hotel—an old Coca-Cola bottling plant—and it’s worth the drive if you want a "wow" factor that the neighborhood rentals can't quite match.
Practical Insights for Your Stay
Broad Ripple isn't a place where you stay in your room. It’s a neighborhood built for movement.
- Rent a bike. If your accommodation doesn't have them, find a Pacers Bikeshare station. The Monon Trail is the highway of Broad Ripple. You can get from 52nd Street (The Jazz Kitchen) to 86th Street (Big Lug Canteen) without ever fighting traffic.
- The Red Line is your friend. It runs every 15-20 minutes. If you stay at a hotel further south or even downtown, you can skip the $25 Uber and ride the bus for a few bucks. It drops you off right at the corner of College and Broad Ripple Ave.
- Breakfast isn't optional. If you stay at a rental, walk to Biscuits for Mexican-style breakfast or Garden Table if you want to feel healthy before the beer starts flowing later.
- The "North Crows Nest" misconception. You might see luxury rentals listed in Crows Nest or North Crows Nest. These are beautiful, wooded estates. They are also incredibly isolated. You will feel like you’re in the middle of a forest, but you’ll be calling a car for every single thing you need.
Basically, if you want the "true" experience, fight for a room at Hotel Broad Ripple. If you can't get that, find a bungalow with a driveway. Anything else is just a commute.
Next Steps for Your Trip
Check the schedule at The Vogue or the Broad Ripple Farmers Market (Saturday mornings) before you lock in your dates. If there’s a major festival, hotel prices in the entire Northside corridor will spike 40% overnight. Book your spot at least three weeks out if you're aiming for a weekend stay.