Finding a place to sleep in Florence is usually a headache. You’re basically choosing between a sterile, overpriced "international" hotel that looks like it belongs in an airport or a cramped Airbnb that smells like old laundry. But Hotel Machiavelli Palace Florence is different. It’s weird. It’s old. It’s actually authentic.
I’m talking about a building that started its life in the 1300s as a convent. Think about that. While the rest of the world was figuring out how to use a fork, people were walking these specific hallways. It’s located on Via Nazionale, which—honestly—is a bit of a chaotic street. It’s busy. There are leather shops everywhere and tourists dragging suitcases over cobblestones. But once you step inside the heavy doors of the Machiavelli Palace, the noise just... stops.
The Location Reality Check
Let’s be real about the location. You are three minutes away from the Santa Maria Novella train station. If you’ve ever hauled a 50-pound suitcase through the streets of Italy, you know that proximity to the station is a godsend. You don’t need a taxi. You just walk.
Most people worry that being near a train station means the neighborhood is sketchy. In some cities, sure. In Florence? It just means you’re close to everything. From the front door of the Hotel Machiavelli Palace Florence, you can hit the Mercato Centrale in five minutes. That’s where you go to eat actual food, not the tourist-trap pasta that costs 20 Euros. Go to the ground floor for the produce and the top floor for the artisan pizza and wine.
The Duomo is about a ten-minute stroll. It’s a straight shot. You turn a corner and suddenly that massive pink, white, and green marble facade is just looming over you. It never gets old.
What the Rooms are Actually Like
Don't expect IKEA furniture here. If you want minimalist gray walls and USB ports in every square inch of the headboard, go somewhere else. This place is unapologetically Florentine.
We’re talking about coffered wooden ceilings. Some rooms have frescoes. Real ones. Not stickers. The furniture is heavy, dark wood that looks like it’s seen a few centuries of history, because it probably has. The floors are often terracotta or parquet. It feels like staying in your wealthy Italian grandmother’s guest room, assuming your grandmother lives in a palace.
✨ Don't miss: How Long Ago Did the Titanic Sink? The Real Timeline of History's Most Famous Shipwreck
The bathrooms are modernized, thankfully. You get the marble, the bidet (standard Italian protocol), and decent water pressure. But the vibe remains historical. It’s worth noting that because this is an old building, the rooms aren't uniform. One might be massive with a vaulted ceiling, while the next is a bit tighter. That’s the "charm" of 14th-century architecture. You deal with the quirks to get the soul.
The Secret Weapon: The Roof Garden
Honestly, the best part of Hotel Machiavelli Palace Florence isn't the lobby or the breakfast room. It's the terrace.
Florence is a city of rooftops. When the sun starts to go down and the light hits the terracotta tiles of the surrounding buildings, the whole city turns gold. The hotel has a roof garden that overlooks the Medici Chapel. You can sit up there with a glass of Chianti and just watch the sky change colors.
It’s quiet.
It’s breezy.
It makes you realize why people have been obsessed with this city for seven hundred years. Most hotels in this price range don't have this kind of view. They just don't. You’re usually staring at a brick wall or another guest’s window. Here, you get the skyline.
🔗 Read more: Why the Newport Back Bay Science Center is the Best Kept Secret in Orange County
Navigating the "Palace" Quirkiness
You’ve got to understand that "Palace" in the name isn't just marketing fluff. This was the home of the Bartolini-Salimbeni family. These were big players in the Florentine silk trade. When you walk through the common areas, look at the stone carvings and the coats of arms.
One thing that surprises people is the elevator. It’s small. Like, "two people and a backpack" small. It’s a classic European lift. If you’re claustrophobic, you might prefer the stairs, which are wide and stone and will definitely give your calves a workout.
Breakfast is served in a room that feels like a medieval hall. It’s a standard European buffet—meats, cheeses, pastries, and some of the strongest coffee you’ll ever have. Don't expect a made-to-order omelet station. That’s not how they do things here. Eat your croissant, drink your espresso like a local, and get out into the city before the tour groups from the cruise ships arrive.
Why This Matters for Your Budget
Florence is expensive. Like, "why did I just pay 10 dollars for a Coke?" expensive. Hotel Machiavelli Palace Florence tends to sit in that sweet spot of "mid-range." You aren't paying Four Seasons prices, but you aren't staying in a hostel with eighteen roommates.
By staying here, you save money on transport because you can walk to the Uffizi, the Accademia (where David lives), and the Ponte Vecchio. You save money on food because the Mercato Centrale is right there.
Addressing the Noise Issue
Look, I’m being honest with you. This is the center of a living city. If you get a room facing Via Nazionale, you will hear the city. Vespas zip by. People talk. It’s the soundtrack of Italy. If you’re a light sleeper, ask for a room facing the internal courtyard. It’s much quieter. The hotel has done a decent job with double-glazing the windows, but 14th-century walls weren't exactly designed with modern traffic in mind.
💡 You might also like: Flights from San Diego to New Jersey: What Most People Get Wrong
Practical Tips for Staying Here
First, check the air conditioning. In the height of July, Florence is a furnace. The Machiavelli Palace has AC, but Italian AC is "gentle." It’s not the arctic blast you get in a New York Marriott. It’s designed to take the edge off.
Second, use the concierge. The guys at the front desk have been there forever. They know which restaurants are actually good and which ones are owned by corporations feeding frozen lasagna to tourists. Ask them where to find the best bistecca alla Fiorentina. They won't steer you wrong.
Third, if you’re driving—don't. Just don't. Florence is a ZTL zone (Limited Traffic Zone). If you drive into the center without a permit, the cameras will catch your plate and you’ll get a massive fine in the mail six months later. The hotel has an arrangement with a nearby garage, but it’s still a pain. Take the train. It’s easier.
The Verdict on the Experience
Is it perfect? No. The Wi-Fi can be spotty in the thickest parts of the building because, well, stone walls from the 1300s are better at blocking signals than lead. The carpets might look a little tired in some corners.
But you aren't in Florence to sit in a perfectly sterilized room. You’re there to feel the weight of history. When you wake up under a wooden beam that was carved before Columbus sailed, you feel a connection to the past that a modern hotel just can't give you. Hotel Machiavelli Palace Florence offers a specific kind of dignity.
It’s a place for people who want to feel like they’re actually in Italy, not just looking at it through a window.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Book Direct: Sometimes the hotel website offers "non-refundable" rates that are significantly cheaper than the big booking engines.
- Request a High Floor: The higher you go, the better the light and the less street noise you’ll deal with.
- The 5 PM Rule: Be on that roof terrace by 5:00 PM. Even if you don't drink alcohol, bring a book. It’s the most peaceful spot in the San Lorenzo district.
- Walking Map: Ignore Google Maps for a second and ask for the paper map at the desk. They usually have the "secret" backstreets marked that lead you to the Piazza della Signoria without the crowds.
- Luggage Storage: If your train leaves late, they have a secure room for bags. Use it. Don't spend your last day in Florence tethered to a suitcase.
Staying at the Machiavelli Palace is about embracing the old world. It’s about the creak of the floorboards and the smell of morning coffee in a stone hall. It’s the quintessential Florence experience, tucked away just steps from the train tracks.