Honestly, making a sequel to a cult classic is a gamble that rarely pays off. Most people remember the first Hot Tub Time Machine as this weirdly charming, R-rated surprise that hit theaters in 2010. It had John Cusack, a lot of heart, and a ridiculous premise that actually worked. Then 2015 rolled around. Hot Tub Time Machine 2 arrived without its lead actor and with a much darker, meaner sense of humor.
It was a total pivot.
While the first film was a nostalgic trip back to the 80s, the sequel decided to look forward. Or, well, sideways. It catapulted the remaining trio—Rob Corddry, Craig Robinson, and Clark Duke—into a bizarre version of 2025. Looking at the movie now, from the actual year 2026, the "future" it predicted is both hilarious and spectacularly wrong. But that’s sort of the point of these movies, right? They aren't trying to be Interstellar. They’re trying to see how many dick jokes they can fit into a 93-minute runtime.
The Cusack-Sized Hole in the Plot
The biggest question everyone asked back in 2015 was: where is Adam? John Cusack was the grounded center of the original. Without him, the dynamic shifted entirely. Hot Tub Time Machine 2 tries to fill that void with Adam Junior, played by Adam Scott. Scott is a phenomenal comedic actor—think Parks and Rec or Severance—but the script essentially turns him into a punching bag for the other three.
It’s a different vibe.
Without Cusack, the movie feels less like a group of friends trying to fix their lives and more like a chaotic road trip through a fever dream. Rob Corddry’s character, Lou, becomes the "Father of the Internet," having used his knowledge of the future to steal every major tech idea from our timeline. He’s rich, he’s arrogant, and he’s the reason someone tries to murder him, kicking off the whole "who shot Lou?" mystery that drives the plot.
📖 Related: Jared Leto in Chapter 27: The Role That Changed His Body and Career Forever
Why the Humor Polarized Fans
If you liked the sweetness of the first movie, the sequel probably felt like a slap in the face. It’s aggressive. It’s cynical. Director Steve Pink returned for the second installment, but the script by Josh Heald (who later went on to huge success with Cobra Kai) leaned heavily into the "mean-spirited" comedy trend of the mid-2010s.
Critics weren't kind. The film holds a pretty dismal 14% on Rotten Tomatoes.
But there’s a weirdly loyal fan base for this movie. Why? Because the chemistry between Robinson, Corddry, and Duke is undeniable. They talk over each other, riff constantly, and seem to be having a better time than the audience. There's a specific scene involving a virtual reality game show called "Choozy Doozy" that is peak absurdist comedy. It’s uncomfortable, long, and totally ridiculous. Some people find it unwatchable; others think it’s the funniest thing in the film.
The "Future" of 2025 vs. Real Life
In the world of Hot Tub Time Machine 2, the year 2025 is filled with:
- Self-driving cars that are actively trying to kill you.
- Smart houses with snarky AI personalities.
- A version of the internet that is basically a physical place.
- The hit TV show Where the Fck is My Smartphone?*
It’s funny to look back at this now. We have the AI and the self-driving tech, but it’s a lot less "neon and chrome" than the movie suggested. The film’s version of 2025 felt like a caricature of what people in 2015 feared the future would become—total sensory overload and a complete lack of privacy.
The Production Reality
Let’s talk numbers because the business side of this is actually quite interesting. The first film was a modest hit, making about $64 million domestically on a $36 million budget. It really found its legs on home video and streaming. MGM and Paramount thought they could catch lightning in a bottle twice, but they slashed the budget for the sequel to around $14 million.
You can see it on screen.
The visual effects are intentionally (and sometimes unintentionally) cheesy. By losing Cusack and tightening the belt, the studio was clearly hoping for a high-margin comedy hit. Instead, it grossed only $13 million in the US. It barely made its production budget back, and that’s before you count marketing costs. It was, by most industry standards, a theatrical dud.
Yet, it persists on streaming platforms.
A Different Kind of Time Travel Logic
Most time travel movies spend ages explaining the "rules." Hot Tub Time Machine 2 basically says "the water is magical, don't worry about it." It plays with the idea of "The Butterfly Effect" in the most irresponsible way possible. Lou isn't just living in the past; he’s actively ruining the future for everyone else by being a "patriot of the present."
There is a moment toward the end where they travel even further—to the American Revolution. It’s a brief gag, but it shows where the franchise could have gone if it had more gas in the tank. They weren't interested in the paradoxes of physics; they were interested in the paradoxes of being a middle-aged guy who suddenly has everything he ever wanted but is still miserable.
Why It’s Worth a Rewatch (Maybe)
If you go into this movie expecting the heart of the original, you’ll be disappointed. But if you treat it as a standalone, weird, sci-fi experimental comedy, it has its moments. Craig Robinson singing "Webber Strut" is worth the price of admission alone. His comedic timing is surgical. He can make a simple reaction shot funnier than a three-page monologue.
Also, Adam Scott’s "tripping" scene in the future nightclub is a masterclass in physical comedy. It’s one of the few times the sequel feels like it’s breaking new ground instead of just retreading the first movie’s jokes.
The Legacy of the Tub
Is there going to be a Hot Tub Time Machine 3? Honestly, probably not. At least not in the way we expect. The era of the mid-budget R-rated theatrical comedy is mostly over. These movies have migrated to streaming services where they don't have to worry about opening weekend box office numbers.
The cast has moved on to massive projects. Clark Duke has been directing, Robinson is a comedy staple, and Corddry is everywhere. But Hot Tub Time Machine 2 remains this weird time capsule of 2015’s sense of humor. It’s a relic of a time when studios were willing to spend $14 million on a movie where the main plot point is a magical jacuzzi.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Buffs
If you're planning to revisit this or watch it for the first time, here is how to actually enjoy the experience without feeling like you wasted two hours:
- Manage your expectations: It’s a raunchy, cynical comedy. Forget the "heart" of the first film. This is a different beast entirely.
- Watch the Unrated Version: If you're going to dive in, go all the way. The theatrical cut feels a bit neutered in places where the jokes clearly wanted to go further.
- Look for the cameos: There are some great blink-and-you’ll-miss-it appearances that add to the "everything is chaos" vibe.
- Pay attention to the background: The "future" world-building in the background of the 2025 scenes is actually pretty clever, featuring fake ads and products that satirize modern consumerism.
- Don't overthink the logic: If you start wondering why the time travel doesn't make sense, you've already lost. Just follow the "glitch in the multiverse" explanation and move on.
The film is currently available on various streaming platforms like Paramount+ or for rent on Amazon. It’s the perfect "it’s 11 PM on a Saturday and I want to turn my brain off" movie. Just don't expect it to change your life, unless you’ve also found a glowing blue chemical to pour into your bathtub.
To get the most out of the franchise, watch the first film to understand the characters, then wait at least a week before watching the sequel. This helps bridge the jarring shift in tone. If you're a fan of the Cobra Kai writing style, you'll likely appreciate the fast-paced dialogue and the way Heald handles the ensemble's bickering. For those interested in the technical side, pay attention to the cinematography by Declan Quinn; he manages to make a low-budget comedy look surprisingly cinematic, especially during the futuristic sequences in "Lougle" headquarters.