Honestly, if you were a wealthy merchant in the 16th century, you probably spent a massive chunk of your fortune on a lie. You wanted a horn of the unicorn. You needed it. Because back then, the world was a terrifying place full of poisons and plagues, and everyone "knew" that the spiraled ivory of a unicorn could neutralize any toxin in a cup of wine.
It's wild. People genuinely believed this stuff.
They weren't looking at a mythical horse's forehead, though. They were looking at the tooth of a whale. Specifically, the narwhal (Monodon monoceros). For hundreds of years, the narwhal tusk was sold across Europe and the Middle East as the genuine horn of the unicorn, commanding prices that would make a modern billionaire flinch. We’re talking ten times the weight of the object in gold. Elizabeth I of England reportedly owned one valued at £10,000 in the 1500s—enough to buy a massive estate at the time.
Why the horn of the unicorn was the ultimate status symbol
It wasn't just about the "magic." It was about staying alive. Royalty lived in constant fear of being poisoned by rivals. If you dipped a piece of the horn of the unicorn into your drink and it bubbled, or changed color, or sweated, you knew your wine was laced with arsenic. Or so the legend went.
This belief created a frantic, high-stakes market.
Vikings and Norse traders were the ones who really capitalized on this. They found narwhals in the icy waters around Greenland and realized that the long, spiraled tusk looked exactly like what people imagined a unicorn's horn should be. They kept the source a secret for centuries. Think about that. A whole industry built on a geographic secret. If a buyer knew it came from a "sea unicorn" or a whale, the price would have cratered.
The aesthetic was also key. Unlike a rhino horn, which is made of keratin (like your fingernails) and looks a bit dull, the narwhal tusk is dense, heavy ivory with a distinct left-handed spiral. It looked divine. It looked like it belonged on a celestial creature.
📖 Related: Finding the Perfect Color Door for Yellow House Styles That Actually Work
The science behind the "magic" (and why it failed)
We have to talk about the testing methods. People weren't just taking the seller's word for it. They had "scientific" tests to prove a horn of the unicorn was real. One popular method involved placing the horn in a glass of water with a live spider. If the spider died or couldn't escape, the horn was "real."
Spoilers: The spider usually just drowned or got stuck.
Ambrosé Paré, a massive figure in the history of surgery and a personal doctor to French kings, was one of the first guys to actually call BS on this. In his 1582 work Discours d'un licorne, he argued that if unicorns didn't exist, their horns couldn't have medicinal properties. He even tried to prove that the "horn" didn't actually neutralize poison in controlled settings. He was basically the MythBusters of the Renaissance.
But people didn't want to listen.
When you've spent the equivalent of a small country's GDP on a stick of ivory, you really, really want it to work. It took the rise of modern taxonomy and better maritime exploration for the truth to leak out. Once people realized narwhals were the source, the "alicorn" (the technical name for the material) lost its medicinal luster and became a mere curiosity.
Where these artifacts are today
You can still see these things. They didn't just disappear when the myth died.
👉 See also: Finding Real Counts Kustoms Cars for Sale Without Getting Scammed
- The Throne of Denmark: Located at Rosenborg Castle, it’s literally made of narwhal tusks. They wanted the king to sit on a chair made of "unicorn" to symbolize his purity and power.
- The Hapsburg Treasury: In Vienna, there is a nearly eight-foot-long tusk that was considered so valuable it was designated an "inalienable heirloom" of the house.
- St. Mark’s Basilica: They have several fragments used as reliquaries.
Identifying the real thing vs. the fakes
Even back in the 1700s, there were knock-offs. Since narwhal tusks were so rare, people would carve walrus ivory or even use "fossilized" mammoth tusks to pass them off as a horn of the unicorn.
If you're ever looking at one in a museum or (if you're lucky) an auction, look at the spiral. A narwhal tusk almost always spirals to the left. It’s a biological quirk. If the spiral goes the other way or doesn't exist, it’s likely a carved piece of bone or a different animal entirely.
Also, the texture matters. Real ivory from these tusks has a specific grain. It's not smooth like plastic. It has a weight to it that feels "wrong" for its size—much heavier than you'd expect.
The legacy of the narwhal trade
It’s easy to laugh at people for believing a whale tooth was a magical horse horn. But honestly? We still do this. We buy "detox" teas and "healing" crystals without much more evidence than a 16th-century Duke had.
The story of the horn of the unicorn is really a story about human desire. We want to believe there is a simple cure for our fears. We want to believe that something rare and beautiful can protect us from the darkness of the world.
The narwhal, fortunately, is no longer hunted for "magic," though they are still protected under CITES (the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species). You can’t just go out and buy a new one today without a mountain of legal paperwork and proof that it was harvested legally by Indigenous groups in the Arctic who rely on the animal for subsistence.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Obituaries in Kalamazoo MI: Where to Look When the News Moves Online
How to approach unicorn history today
If you're fascinated by this, don't just look at fairy tales. Look at the auction records of Sotheby’s or Christie’s from the last twenty years. You’ll see that narwhal tusks—now labeled correctly—still sell for tens of thousands of dollars. The "magic" might be gone, but the obsession with the object's beauty remains.
To truly understand the history of the horn of the unicorn, you should:
- Visit a "Wunderkammer": Many European museums have "Cabinets of Curiosities" that display these tusks alongside other "mythical" objects like dried rays (made to look like dragons) or giant bird eggs.
- Study the Narwhal: Understand that the "horn" is actually a tooth that grows through the whale's lip. It’s a sensory organ, not a weapon. It can "feel" changes in water salinity and temperature.
- Read the primary sources: Look up the writings of Ole Worm, a Danish physician who, in 1638, finally proved to the public that these horns came from whales. His work Museum Wormianum is a masterpiece of early skeptical inquiry.
The world is plenty magical without the horses. The fact that a whale grows an eight-foot-long sensory tooth in the freezing Arctic is arguably cooler than a horse with a spike. We just took a few centuries to realize it.
Next Steps for the History Buff:
If you're looking to see a horn of the unicorn in person, check the inventory of your nearest major natural history museum or royal armory. In the U.S., the Metropolitan Museum of Art has several ivory carvings that illustrate the transition from myth to science. If you're in Europe, the Treasury in the Hofburg (Vienna) is the gold standard for seeing how these objects were displayed as sacred items. Always check the provenance; the most interesting pieces are the ones that were once owned by someone who genuinely believed they could survive a poisoned banquet because of them.