Kevin Costner is obsessed. There’s really no other way to put it when you look at the sheer scale of Horizon: An American Saga Chapter 1. Most directors fight for a two-hour runtime. Costner? He decided to launch a four-part cinematic odyssey, mortgaging his own property to fund a vision that feels less like a modern blockbuster and more like a massive, dusty nineteenth-century novel brought to life. It’s bold. It’s also kinda polarizing.
People expected Yellowstone on the big screen. What they got instead was something far more patient and sprawling.
The Reality of Horizon: An American Saga Chapter 1
The film doesn’t just tell one story. It juggles about five. You’ve got the settlement of San Pedro being absolutely decimated in a brutal opening sequence. Then there’s the cavalry trying to keep a peace that’s already disintegrated. You have a wagon train moving across the plains, and a woman fleeing a violent past in a mining camp.
Costner doesn't even show up for the first hour. Seriously.
When his character, Hayes Ellison, finally rides into frame, he isn't some superhero. He’s just a guy trying to mind his own business who gets sucked into a deadly dispute. This slow-burn approach is exactly why Horizon: An American Saga Chapter 1 felt so jarring to audiences used to the "inciting incident within ten minutes" rule of Hollywood screenwriting.
The film covers the years 1859 to 1863. It’s the lead-up to the Civil War, but the war is mostly a distant rumble. The real conflict is the dirt, the lack of water, and the fundamental clash between those who lived on the land for generations and those who were sold a dream on a printed flyer.
Why the "Horizon" Flyer Matters
The central motif of the movie is a colorful piece of paper. It’s an advertisement for a town called "Horizon." In reality, the town barely exists. It’s a plot of land that is dangerous and contested. But for characters like Frances Kittredge (played by Sienna Miller), that flyer represents an escape.
This is where Costner hits on a real historical truth: the American West was built on a mix of courage and predatory marketing. People sold everything they owned based on a drawing. Then they arrived and realized the land wasn't empty. It was home to the Apache, who saw these settlers not as families, but as invaders.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The violence in the first act is genuinely difficult to watch. It isn't stylized like a Tarantino flick. It’s messy. It’s terrifying. It sets a tone that says, "This isn't a fun adventure; this is a survival story."
Breaking Down the Multiple Timelines
One of the biggest complaints from critics was the editing. The movie jumps between the San Pedro Valley in Arizona, the Montana Territory, and the Santa Fe Trail.
Honestly, it feels like a miniseries that was stitched together for a theatrical release.
But there’s a reason for this. Costner and his co-writer, Jon Baird, aren't interested in a "hero’s journey." They want to show a collective experience. In one thread, you follow a wagon train led by Luke Wilson’s character, Matthew Van Weyden. He’s trying to manage a group of people who have no idea how to survive in the wilderness. Some of the settlers are bringing fine china and heavy furniture across the desert. It’s absurd, yet it’s exactly what happened in the mid-1800s.
Then you have the storyline involving Jena Malone’s character, Ellen/Lucy. She shoots a man in the opening minutes and flees north. This thread introduces the Sykes family, a group of outlaws who feel like they stepped right out of a Cormac McCarthy novel. They are menacing in a way that feels grounded. Jamie Campbell Bower plays Caleb Sykes with a twitchy, predatory energy that makes your skin crawl.
It's a lot to track. You really have to pay attention to the faces because the movie doesn't hold your hand.
The Financial Risk Most People Missed
Let’s talk about the money. Costner put up a significant chunk of his own fortune—rumored to be around $38 million of the $100 million budget for the first two chapters—to get this made.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Hollywood wouldn't touch this.
The industry has moved toward franchises with capes or established IP. A three-hour Western with a massive cast of character actors? That’s a "no" from the major studios. By funding it himself, Costner kept total creative control. That’s why the movie has these long, lingering shots of the Utah landscape (standing in for various Western locales). He wanted the scale of Dances with Wolves but with the grit of Open Range.
The cinematography by J. Michael Muro is stunning. If you see it on a small screen, you’re losing half the experience. The red rocks of Moab and the vastness of the plains are characters in themselves. They make the humans look small, which is exactly the point. The West doesn't care if you live or die.
The Indigenous Perspective
Often, older Westerns treated Native Americans as a monolithic "enemy." Horizon: An American Saga Chapter 1 tries to be more nuanced, though it still focuses primarily on the white settler experience.
We see the internal conflict within the Apache tribe. There’s a generational divide between the elders who see the futility of fighting a wave of settlers that never ends, and the younger warriors, led by Pionsenay (Owen Crow Shoe), who refuse to let their land be taken without a bloodbath.
It’s a tragic dynamic. There’s no "villain" in the traditional sense here—just two groups of people whose goals are fundamentally incompatible.
Managing Expectations for the "Ending"
Here is the thing you need to know: Horizon: An American Saga Chapter 1 doesn’t really have a climax.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
It just... stops.
Actually, it ends with a montage of what’s coming in Chapter 2. It’s basically a three-minute trailer for the next movie. For some, this was a slap in the face. After sitting for three hours, you want a resolution. But Costner is playing the long game. He’s building a 12-hour story.
Think of it like the first 200 pages of a 1000-page book. You’ve met the players, you understand the stakes, and the board is set. If you go in expecting a self-contained movie, you’re going to be frustrated. If you go in expecting a massive historical epic that takes its time, you’ll find a lot to love.
Key Takeaways for the Viewer
If you’re planning to dive into this saga, there are a few things that make the experience better.
First, don't try to "solve" the plot immediately. The disparate storylines don't converge in this first chapter. They are parallel tracks. The connection is the land itself and the concept of "Horizon."
Second, pay attention to the secondary characters. Danny Huston as the Union Colonel and Michael Rooker as the Sergeant provide the moral "middle ground." They are the ones who realize that the expansion is messy and probably doomed to be written in blood. Their conversations in the fort offer the most philosophical depth in the script.
Third, watch it on the biggest screen possible. The sound design—the wind, the creak of the wagons, the distant thunder—is vital to the immersion.
Actionable Insights for Movie Fans:
- Check the Cast List: Because there are so many characters, it helps to look up the main families (the Kittredges, the Sykes, the Van Weydens) before watching so you don't get lost in the first hour.
- Ignore the "Yellowstone" Comparison: This isn't a soap opera with horses. It’s a historical procedural. The pacing is much slower and more deliberate.
- Watch the Background: Costner fills the frame with period-accurate details. From the way the tents are pitched to the specific types of rifles used, the "material culture" of 1860 is the real star.
- Prepare for the Long Haul: This is a commitment. If you enjoyed the scale of Lonesome Dove or the grit of Unforgiven, you’re the target audience. If you want fast-paced action, this might feel like a chore.
The gamble Costner took is historic. Whether the full four-part saga ever gets completed in the way he envisioned remains to be seen, but Chapter 1 stands as a massive, flawed, and beautiful monument to a type of filmmaking that barely exists anymore. It’s a movie that demands your patience and rewards your attention with a world that feels lived-in and dangerously real.