You’re right in the middle of frosting a cake and you realize the pantry is empty. No blue bag of C&H. No organic store-brand confectioners' sugar. Just a half-empty bag of granulated sugar staring back at you. Honestly, it's a sinking feeling, but it shouldn't be. Most people don't realize that homemade powdered sugar is literally just regular sugar that’s been pulverized. That is it. There is no secret factory magic involved, and frankly, the stuff you make at home often tastes better because it hasn't been sitting on a grocery store shelf for nine months absorbing the smell of cardboard.
The Science of the Grind
Sugar is a crystal. When you buy granulated sugar, you’re looking at sucrose crystals that are roughly 0.5 millimeters in size. To get to that fluffy, cloud-like texture of "10X" sugar—the industry term for powdered sugar—you have to smash those crystals into a fine dust. We're talking particles smaller than 0.06 millimeters.
If you just blend sugar and throw it into a bowl, it stays fine for a minute, but then it starts to clump. It’s a moisture magnet. That’s why commercial brands add cornstarch. Most big brands like Domino or Imperial use about 3% cornstarch to keep the sugar "flowable." If you're making this at home to use immediately, you can skip the starch. If you're storing it, you need it.
Why the Blender Matters
Don't try this in a food processor unless you have no other choice. I've seen people try to use those big, old-school Cuisinarts, and you just end up with "gritty" sugar. It’s annoying. You need a high-speed blender. A Vitamix or a Blendtec is the gold standard here because the blades spin fast enough to create a literal vortex of dust. If you use a cheap blender, the sugar often just sits at the bottom while the blades spin uselessly above it.
How to Make Homemade Powdered Sugar Without Overheating It
Here is the thing nobody tells you: sugar creates friction. When you blend a pound of sugar at 30,000 RPMs, it gets hot. If it gets too hot, it starts to melt or "caramelize" slightly, and then you have a sticky, clumpy mess that will never become frosting.
- Start with exactly one cup of granulated sugar. Don't do more than two cups at a time.
- Add one tablespoon of cornstarch. If you're grain-free, use arrowroot powder. It works exactly the same way.
- Pulse first. Get the crystals moving.
- Crank it to high for about 45 to 60 seconds.
- Look for the "smoke." It’s not actually smoke; it’s just very fine sugar dust escaping the lid. That’s how you know you’ve hit the right micron level.
Wait. Seriously. Wait at least two minutes before opening the lid. If you open it immediately, a cloud of sugar will coat your entire kitchen. Your counters will be sticky for a week. Let the dust settle.
The Starch Debate: Corn vs. Arrowroot vs. Potato
Cornstarch is the default. It’s cheap. It works. But it has a very slight "raw" taste if you aren't cooking the frosting. Some high-end pastry chefs, like those following the techniques of Stella Parks (author of BraveTart), suggest that organic powdered sugars often use tapioca starch instead of cornstarch. Tapioca starch has a lower gelatinization temperature and a more neutral flavor profile.
If you’re making a Swiss Meringue Buttercream, the starch type matters less because you're dissolving the sugar anyway. But for a standard American Buttercream—the kind that’s just butter and sugar whipped together—the grit-factor is everything. Homemade powdered sugar needs to be sifted. Even if you have a $600 blender, sift it through a fine-mesh strainer. You will almost always find a few stubborn granules that didn't get pulverized. Those granules are the difference between a professional-looking cake and something that feels like eating sand.
Is It Actually Cheaper?
Probably not. Let's be real. A 4lb bag of granulated sugar is usually around $3.00. A 2lb bag of powdered sugar is often around $2.00. The price difference is negligible when you factor in the wear and tear on your blender blades. Sugar is abrasive. It will eventually dull your blades if you do this every single day.
The real value isn't the cost. It's the quality. Commercial powdered sugar is often made from beets. Many bakers swear that cane sugar performs better in delicate macarons or royal icing. By making your own, you control the source. You can use organic cane sugar, coconut sugar (which makes a brown, caramel-tasting powdered sugar), or even monk fruit sweetener if you're doing the keto thing.
Using Alternative Sugars
You can actually "powder" almost any crystalline sweetener.
- Coconut Sugar: Makes a dark, earthy powdered sugar. Great for chocolate frosting.
- Monk Fruit: Very finicky. It gets "cool" on the tongue, but it powders well.
- Maple Sugar: Incredible for fall baking. It’s expensive, so powdering it yourself ensures you don't waste any.
Pro Tips for the Perfect Batch
If your sugar feels gritty after 60 seconds, stop. Let the motor cool down. If you keep going, you'll burn out the bearings in your blender. Some people suggest adding a tiny pinch of salt to the blender to help break down the crystals, but honestly, that's a myth. The salt is just for flavor.
Another weird trick? Vanilla beans. If you have an old, dried-out vanilla bean, throw a half-inch piece in with the sugar and starch. The blender will pulverize the bean too. You’ll end up with vanilla-flecked homemade powdered sugar that smells better than anything you can buy in a store. It looks beautiful in a white glaze over lemon bundt cake.
👉 See also: French Nicknames for Boyfriend: What Most People Get Wrong
Common Mistakes Everyone Makes
The biggest mistake is ignoring the humidity. If it’s a rainy day, don't even bother making a huge batch to store. Sugar is hygroscopic. It pulls water from the air. On a humid day, your homemade dust will turn into a brick within 24 hours regardless of how much cornstarch you use.
Also, don't use a NutriBullet if you're doing more than a half-cup. Those small motors aren't vented well enough for the sustained high-speed run required to get sugar truly fine. You'll smell plastic burning before the sugar is done.
Moving Forward With Your Baking
Once you've mastered the grind, start experimenting with ratios. If you want a "thicker" feel for royal icing, bump the starch up to 4%. If you hate the chalky taste of store-bought sugar, drop it to 1.5% and just use it immediately.
The most important thing to remember is the sifting. Sift before you measure, and sift as you add it to your butter or egg whites. Homemade powdered sugar is a lifesaver when you're in a pinch, but it's also a legitimate way to level up the flavor of your desserts by choosing higher-quality base sugars.
Keep your blender dry. Any moisture in the jar before you start will ruin the entire batch. Dry the jar with a paper towel, then let it air dry for another ten minutes just to be sure. Now, go make that frosting.
Actionable Next Steps
Check your blender's wattage. You really want something over 1000 watts for the best results. Grab a small bag of organic cane sugar and try a "test batch" of one cup. Sift it immediately through your finest sieve to see how your specific blender handles the crystal breakdown. If you see too many large grains, increase your blend time by 15 seconds next time, but always allow the motor to cool between pulses to avoid scorching the sucrose.