The world of rock and roll is rarely quiet. But in 2015, the noise surrounding Five Finger Death Punch frontman Ivan Moody had nothing to do with a new album or a world tour. It was a messy, public, and deeply confusing legal battle involving a woman named Holly Smith. If you were following the metal scene back then, you probably remember the headlines. They were everywhere. One day she was his wife filing for divorce; the next, the band was claiming he wasn't even married.
It was a total whirlwind of allegations that left fans picking sides in a story where the "facts" seemed to change every hour. Honestly, even years later, people still argue about what went down in that Las Vegas hotel room.
The Breaking Point in Las Vegas
Everything exploded in August 2015. TMZ dropped a bombshell reporting that Holly Smith had filed for divorce from Ivan Moody (whose legal name is Ivan Greening). The details were graphic. Smith alleged that she found texts from other women on Moody’s phone while they were staying at a Hilton Garden Inn in Las Vegas. According to her statement, she went to sleep and woke up to Moody having her in a "jiu-jitsu submission hold."
👉 See also: Shane Farley Net Worth: How This Daytime TV Powerhouse Really Built His Fortune
She claimed he punched her repeatedly and even tried to choke her with a blanket.
Police were called to the scene around 4:15 AM on April 21. When they arrived, they found Smith in the lobby. Her lip was swollen and bloody, and she had a cut on the roof of her mouth. The arrest report noted scratches at the back of her throat, which matched her story about the blanket. Moody was arrested for domestic battery by strangulation, but the charges were eventually dismissed in July 2015.
Why were they dropped? Usually, it's a lack of evidence or a witness refusing to testify, but the "why" didn't stop the media firestorm.
Was He Even Married?
This is where the story gets really weird. Shortly after the divorce news broke, Five Finger Death Punch guitarist Zoltan Bathory took to Twitter. He basically said, "Wait, Ivan isn't even married."
The band's manager, Allen Kovac, followed up with a blistering statement. He claimed that a search of county records turned up no marriage certificate for Ivan Moody and Holly Smith. He also alleged that Smith was lying about Moody being the father of her child. It was a total character assassination attempt in the press, meant to discredit every claim she had made.
"Ms. Smith has made statements alleging that Moody is the father of her child which has also been shown to be untrue," Kovac stated at the time.
But Smith wasn't backing down. She was seeking $66,000 a month in spousal support, claiming that was a fair share of his massive income with the band. The back-and-forth created a "he-said, she-said" dynamic that was exhausting to follow. Was she a "common-law" wife? Was there a secret ceremony? Or was it all a play for a settlement?
The Restraining Orders
While the band was busy denying the marriage, other documents surfaced that painted a darker picture of Moody's personal life. It wasn't just Holly Smith. TMZ uncovered that Moody’s sister, Sandra Dykes, had also sought a restraining order against him. She claimed he had a history of violence fueled by alcohol.
She even alleged that their mother and Moody’s own daughter were planning to file their own protective orders. It made the "nothing to see here" defense from the band's management look pretty thin. You can't just ignore a whole family claiming there’s a problem.
The 2026 Perspective: Where Are They Now?
Fast forward to today. Ivan Moody has been very open about his struggles with alcohol and his journey to sobriety. He eventually launched a CBD line and has seemingly tried to turn his life around, focusing on his health and his fans. The band is still massive, recently announcing their 2026 North American tour.
As for Holly Smith, she mostly disappeared from the limelight after the legal dust settled. There are other "Holly Smiths" in the news—like the Vice Mayor of Sanibel or the British equestrian—but the Holly Smith associated with Ivan Moody has kept a very low profile. That's probably for the best. Being at the center of a metal-world scandal isn't exactly a recipe for a quiet life.
Sorting Fact from Friction
If you're trying to make sense of the Holly Smith and Ivan Moody saga, keep these points in mind:
- The Arrest Was Real: Regardless of the "marriage" status, Ivan Moody was arrested in Las Vegas in April 2015 for domestic battery.
- Charges Dismissed: The legal system did not move forward with the case, which the band used as proof of his innocence.
- The Marriage Mystery: No public record of a marriage certificate was ever produced by the media, lending weight to the band's claim that they were never legally wed.
- Pattern of Behavior: The restraining orders from family members suggested that the issues in the hotel room weren't necessarily an isolated incident at that point in Moody's life.
It's a heavy story. It reminds us that the people we see on stage are often dealing with some very real, very messy demons behind the scenes.
If you or someone you know is dealing with domestic violence, you don't have to navigate it alone. Resources like the National Domestic Violence Hotline (800-799-7233) are available 24/7. Taking that first step to reach out can be the most important thing you do today.