Ever walked into a room and felt someone’s judgment before they even opened their mouth? It’s a vibe. You’re just standing there, maybe wearing the "wrong" brand of shoes or mentioning you enjoyed a movie that isn’t "intellectual" enough, and suddenly, there it is. That look. The holier than thou meaning is basically summed up in that specific brand of smugness. It’s the unshakable belief that they are morally, intellectually, or spiritually superior to you. And honestly? It’s exhausting.
We’ve all been on both sides of it. Maybe you were the one rolling your eyes at a friend’s "poor" life choices, or maybe you were the one being lectured about your carbon footprint by someone who flies private. It’s a pervasive human behavior. But where does it actually come from? Is it just garden-variety arrogance, or is something deeper happening in the brain?
The Linguistic Roots of Being "Better"
The phrase didn’t just pop out of thin air. It has deep roots, specifically trailing back to the King James Bible, specifically the Book of Isaiah (65:5). The verse describes people who say, "Stand by thyself, come not near to me; for I am holier than thou." Even back then, thousands of years ago, people were dealing with the same "I’m better than you" energy.
It’s an idiom. A classic one.
In modern English, when we talk about the holier than thou meaning, we aren’t usually talking about actual holiness. We’re talking about sanctimoniousness. It’s the performance of virtue. Think of the "virtue signaling" we see on social media today. It’s the digital version of standing on a street corner and loudly proclaiming how much you fast or pray, just to make sure the neighbors see it.
Why Do We Do It? (The Psychology of Smugness)
Psychologically, this isn't just about being a jerk. It’s often a defense mechanism. According to research on Social Comparison Theory, pioneered by Leon Festinger in the 1950s, humans have an innate drive to evaluate themselves. When we feel insecure, one of the easiest ways to feel "up" is to push someone else "down."
If I can convince myself that your lifestyle is "sinful" or "uneducated," I automatically feel like I’m winning at life. It’s a cheap ego boost.
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson often discusses the idea of "low-resolution" morality. It’s easy to be holier than thou when you simplify the world into "good" and "bad." If I follow the rules and you don't, I'm the hero. This ignores the nuance of human experience. It ignores the fact that everyone is fighting a battle you know nothing about.
💡 You might also like: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
Real-World Examples of the Holier Than Thou Attitude
You see it everywhere. It’s the "crunchy" parent who judges someone for using formula. It’s the colleague who makes sure everyone knows they stayed until 9:00 PM while you left at 5:00 PM.
Consider the "Eco-Warrior" trope. We all want to save the planet. But there is a massive difference between someone quietly composting and someone who scolds a stranger in a grocery store for using a plastic bag. One is trying to help; the other is trying to feel superior.
Or look at the world of fitness.
The "CrossFit" or "Vegan" memes exist for a reason. When a lifestyle choice becomes a moral identity, the holier than thou meaning starts to bleed into every conversation. Suddenly, eating a burger isn’t just a dietary choice; it’s a moral failing in the eyes of the person across the table.
The Cancel Culture Connection
Modern digital spaces have amplified this. Cancel culture is often fueled by a collective holier than thou impulse. It’s a "moral panic" where people compete to see who can be the most outraged. By being the first to point the finger, you signal to the group that you are part of the "pure" inner circle.
The Downside: Why Everyone Hates It
Nobody likes being talked down to. Period.
When you adopt a sanctimonious tone, you kill influence. If you actually want someone to change their mind or their behavior, being holier than thou is the worst way to do it. Research in psychological reactance suggests that when people feel their freedom or self-worth is being threatened by a judgmental person, they tend to double down on the "bad" behavior just to spite them.
It creates a wall.
📖 Related: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
True authority comes from humility. Think of figures like Mr. Rogers or even certain stoic philosophers like Marcus Aurelius. They didn't lead by shouting about their virtues. They led by example. Aurelius famously wrote in his Meditations: "The best revenge is to be unlike him who performed the injury." He wasn't looking down on others; he was focused on his own character.
How to Spot the Signs in Yourself
It’s easy to see it in others. It’s much harder to see it in the mirror.
Are you constantly "correcting" people on minor facts? Do you feel a surge of pleasure when someone else fails? Do you find yourself saying things like "I would never..." or "How could they possibly..."?
If so, you might be slipping into that mindset. It happens to the best of us. We get passionate about something—politics, health, religion—and we start to think our way is the only way.
Moving Toward Radical Empathy
The antidote to a holier than thou attitude isn't "being bad." It's humility.
It’s recognizing that if you had been born in that person’s shoes, with their DNA, their parents, and their traumas, you’d likely be making the exact same "mistakes" they are. This is what psychologists call Cognitive Empathy.
Instead of judging, try curiosity.
👉 See also: Curtain Bangs on Fine Hair: Why Yours Probably Look Flat and How to Fix It
"I wonder why they feel that way?" is a much more powerful sentence than "They are wrong."
Actionable Steps to Kill the Judgment
If you realize you’ve been acting a bit superior, or if you’re dealing with someone who is, here is how to handle it:
1. Practice the "Mirror Check"
Next time you feel judgmental, find one thing you’ve done in the last week that was hypocritical. We all have something. Reminding yourself of your own flaws is the fastest way to drop the "holy" act.
2. Switch from "You" to "I"
If you must express a different opinion, keep it personal. Instead of "You shouldn't eat that," try "I’ve found that I feel much better when I avoid those foods." It removes the moral judgment from the other person's plate.
3. Set Boundaries with Smug People
If you’re the victim of a holier than thou tirade, don’t argue. You can't win against someone who believes they have the moral high ground. Simply say, "I appreciate your perspective, but I’m comfortable with my choice." Then, walk away.
4. Listen More, Talk Less
Sanctimonious people love the sound of their own voice. They are teachers, never students. Flip the script. Try to learn one thing from every person you meet, especially the ones you disagree with.
The holier than thou meaning ultimately describes a state of disconnection. It’s a way of separating yourself from the "messy" parts of humanity. But the mess is where the growth happens. By letting go of the need to be better than everyone else, you actually become a version of yourself that people actually want to be around.
Stop trying to be a saint. Just try to be a human. It’s much more useful in the long run.
Next Steps for Personal Growth:
- Audit your social media feed: Unfollow accounts that thrive on moral outrage or "dunking" on others.
- Engage in "Steel-manning": Try to argue the best possible version of an opponent’s argument to build intellectual humility.
- Practice anonymous service: Do something kind for someone this week and tell absolutely no one—not even on your "Close Friends" story.