The Pittsburgh Penguins are currently trapped in the NHL's version of a mid-life crisis. It's that weird, uncomfortable space where they're too good to tank but not quite consistent enough to be considered a true "wagon" in the Eastern Conference. With the 2026 Winter Olympics in Milano-Cortina looming, the trade market is about to get very weird, very fast.
Honestly, if you're tracking hockey trade rumors Pittsburgh Penguins fans are already familiar with, you know the usual names. But this year isn't business as usual. We’re staring down a February roster freeze that basically turns late January into the "real" trade deadline. If Kyle Dubas wants to move a veteran or snag a young defender like Bo Byram, he has to do it before the Olympic break starts on February 4.
The Bo Byram Smoke and the Blue Line Problem
There is a lot of chatter lately about the Penguins "really wanting" Bo Byram from the Buffalo Sabres. It makes a ton of sense. The Penguins' identity is basically built on the backs of mobile, puck-moving defensemen. Think Sergei Gonchar, Kris Letang, and more recently, Erik Karlsson.
Byram is 23. He fits the "post-Crosby" timeline perfectly, but he can also help right now. The rumor mill suggests Buffalo might want a package involving Rickard Rakell and maybe a high-end prospect like William Horcoff.
🔗 Read more: Bubba Watson and the 2012 Masters: The Hook That Changed Everything
Whether Dubas is willing to part with Horcoff—who looked like a total stud for Team USA at the World Juniors—is the big question. Trading a blue-chip prospect for a young NHL-ready defender is a classic "retool on the fly" move. It’s exactly what this front office has been preaching since they started hoarding draft picks like they were prepping for an apocalypse.
Who’s Packing Their Bags?
Let’s talk about the guys who might actually be on their way out. The name Brett Kulak is everywhere right now. He’s 32, he’s a pending UFA, and he’s been playing steady minutes next to Kris Letang.
- Brett Kulak: He’s the definition of a "safe" trade. He doesn't have a no-trade clause. He’s got almost 100 games of playoff experience. Teams looking for a No. 4 or No. 5 defenseman for a deep run will pay a mid-round pick for him without blinking.
- Rickard Rakell: This one is trickier. He’s found his scoring touch again, and he’s signed beyond this season. That "term" makes him more valuable than a rental. If a team like Buffalo or even a contender out West wants a top-six winger who doesn't disrupt team structure, Rakell is the guy.
- Anthony Mantha: He's basically a deadline specialist at this point. Huge frame, decent hands, but streaky. If a team wants net-front presence for the power play, Mantha is an easy piece to move.
It’s worth noting that the Penguins' success under coach Dan Muse is making these decisions harder. If they keep winning, do you really want to trade Rakell? Probably not. But if you’re Kyle Dubas, you have to look at the fact that you have nearly $50 million in cap space coming up in the 2026 offseason. You can't just stand pat and watch assets walk for nothing.
The Olympic Freeze: A New Deadline
The 2026 Olympics are a massive factor in how these hockey trade rumors Pittsburgh Penguins fans see on social media will play out. The NHL mandates a roster freeze from Feb. 4 to Feb. 22.
📖 Related: Why the 1986 Penn State Football Season Still Feels Like a Miracle
Think about it from a GM’s perspective. If you wait until the March 6 deadline to trade for a guy, you only have two weeks after the Olympics to see if he's even healthy. What if Sidney Crosby or Erik Karlsson gets banged up in Italy? What if the player you're trading for suffers a season-ending injury while playing for their country?
The risk is sky-high. That’s why we expect a flurry of activity in the next two weeks. Teams want their acquisitions settled and in the building before the planes take off for Milan.
Recent Moves to Remember
Dubas hasn't been sitting on his hands. We've already seen some significant shuffling:
- Yegor Chinakhov coming in from Columbus for Danton Heinen. This was a clear move for speed and youth.
- Tristan Jarry headed to Edmonton in exchange for Stuart Skinner and Brett Kulak. That was a massive shakeup that addressed the goaltending "vibe" more than anything else.
- Egor Zamula arriving from Philly for Philip Tomasino.
The Penguins currently have a ridiculous number of picks in the first three rounds over the next few years. They are "asset rich" but "roster thin" in terms of elite young talent.
The Core: Crosby, Malkin, Letang
The elephant in the room is always the Big Three. Sidney Crosby isn't going anywhere. He’s still playing at an elite level, and he’s about to lead Canada into another Olympic tournament.
💡 You might also like: Minnesota State High School Hockey Tournament: Why It Still Matters
Evgeni Malkin is a different story, mostly because his contract is up at the end of this season. He’s 39. He’s dealt with injuries recently, missing a chunk of games in December and early January with an upper-body issue. But when he’s on? He’s still Geno. He’s still a point-per-game player.
The most likely scenario is another one-year extension for Malkin. The team has so much cap space that they could literally give him a massive "thank you" contract for one year just to hit the salary floor, and it wouldn't even hurt them. Kris Letang is also under contract for a while longer, and he just hit his 1,200th game with an OT winner. These guys want to finish together. Dubas knows that.
Actionable Insights for the Trade Deadline
If you’re trying to stay ahead of the news, watch the following indicators. They’ll tell you more than a random tweet ever will.
- Watch the Waiver Wire: If the Penguins start waiving depth players or moving "salary filler" types, they’re clearing room for a bigger acquisition.
- Monitor the Healthy Scratches: In the week leading up to February 4, pay close attention to who is sitting out for "trade-related reasons." If Brett Kulak or Anthony Mantha sits, the deal is likely done.
- Follow the Buffalo Connection: The Sabres and Penguins have been linked in multiple reports regarding Bo Byram. Keep an eye on Sabres scouts at PPG Paints Arena.
- Check the Cap Space: Use sites like PuckPedia to see how much daily cap space the Penguins are accruing. The more they save now, the bigger the "salary dump" they can take on later in exchange for even more draft picks.
The Pittsburgh Penguins are essentially playing a high-stakes game of "chicken" with the rest of the league. They want to give Crosby one last run, but they won't sacrifice the future to do it. It’s a delicate balance, and the next few weeks will define the franchise for the next decade.
Keep an eye on the injury reports for guys like Bryan Rust and Rutger McGroarty. Their health—or lack thereof—might be the final nudge Kyle Dubas needs to pull the trigger on a season-altering trade.
One thing is for sure: the quiet period of the NHL calendar is officially over. Whether it's a blockbuster for a young star or a series of small moves to bolster the blue line, the Penguins are going to be at the center of the conversation until the final buzzer sounds on the 2026 trade deadline.