Hims and hers health stock: Why Most Investors Are Getting it Wrong

Hims and hers health stock: Why Most Investors Are Getting it Wrong

Honestly, the way people talk about hims and hers health stock usually falls into two camps. You’ve got the die-hard believers who think it’s the next Amazon of healthcare, and then there are the skeptics who swear the whole thing is just a glorified pharmacy with a pretty font.

The truth? It's messy.

By mid-January 2026, HIMS has become one of those stocks that makes your head spin if you look at the charts too long. It’s a rollercoaster. Just last week, the stock was hovering around $32, which is a massive leap from where it sat a few years ago, but it’s still nursing some bruises from recent analyst downgrades. Bank of America and Citi haven't been shy about their "Sell" or "Underperform" ratings lately, mostly because they’re worried that 2026 is going to be a "big investment year" that eats into profits.

But if you’re only looking at the daily price tickers, you’re missing the actual drama happening behind the scenes.

The GLP-1 Elephant in the Room

Let's talk about the weight loss drugs. Everyone is obsessed with them. Hims & Hers made a huge splash by offering compounded semaglutide—basically a custom-mixed version of the active ingredient in Wegovy—at a fraction of the branded price.

It worked. Like, really well.

In the third quarter of 2025, the company pulled in nearly $600 million in revenue, which was up 49% from the year before. A huge chunk of that came from people wanting those weight loss shots without paying $1,000 a month. But here is where it gets tricky for the hims and hers health stock outlook: the FDA is playing referee.

When the branded drug shortages for Wegovy and Ozempic were officially declared "resolved," it put a ticking clock on the compounding business. If the big pharma giants like Novo Nordisk can actually keep the shelves stocked, the legal loophole that allows Hims to sell compounded versions starts to shrink.

Novo Nordisk's CEO, Mike Doustdar, recently mentioned that up to 1.5 million Americans are using these "off-brand" versions. He knows Hims is eating his lunch. Now, Novo is pushing their own oral Wegovy pill and dropping prices to as low as $149 for some people. That’s a direct shot at Hims’ business model.

More Than Just Blue Pills and Hair Serums

If you think this company is just about erectile dysfunction and hair loss, you’re living in 2019. They’ve branched out. Fast.

📖 Related: Egyptian Pound to US Dollar: Why the Rates Aren't What You Think

  • Menopause Care: They’re betting big on aging millennials.
  • Testosterone Therapy: A newer category that’s gaining steam.
  • At-Home Diagnostics: They bought a company called YourBio Health that does "virtually painless" blood sampling.
  • International Growth: They are officially moving into Canada this year.

The strategy is basically to become a "lifestyle health" hub. They want you to get your lab work done through them, get your diagnosis via their app, and then have your personalized meds show up at your door in a box that doesn't look like a prescription.

It’s vertical integration. They aren't just a middleman anymore; they own the pharmacies and the compounding centers. This is why the bulls like the stock. They see a company that is building its own ecosystem, making it really hard for customers to leave once they’re in.

The Financial Tug-of-War

Financials are where the "expert" opinions start to clash. On one hand, you have a company that grew its subscriber base to about 2.5 million people by late 2025. That’s a lot of recurring revenue.

On the other hand, the net income is... volatile. In Q3 2025, they reported about $16 million in net income. That’s a profit, sure, but it was a huge drop from the year before when they had a massive one-time tax benefit.

Wall Street hates uncertainty.

👉 See also: ¿A cómo está el dólar en pesos mexicanos? Por qué el tipo de cambio te está mintiendo

The bears, like the folks at BofA, think the 2026 revenue targets are way too optimistic. They see Amazon Pharmacy looming in the background and wonder if Hims can keep its margins high while everyone else is slashing prices.

Wait, what about the valuation?
Simply Wall St recently ran a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis suggesting the "fair value" of the stock might actually be closer to $63. If you believe that, the current price in the low $30s looks like a steal. But—and this is a big but—another model they ran suggested the stock is overvalued based on its P/E ratio of around 55x.

So, is it a bargain or a bubble? Honestly, it depends on whether you think they can survive the "Weight Loss War" of 2026.

What Most People Get Wrong

The biggest misconception about hims and hers health stock is that it’s a "telehealth" company. It’s not. Not really.

Companies like Teladoc are struggling because they’re essentially just a Zoom call with a doctor. Hims is a consumer brand. They sell a feeling and a "personalized" experience. When you buy from them, you aren't just buying a chemical; you're buying a subscription to a version of yourself that has more hair or weighs less.

That brand loyalty is expensive to build. CEO Andrew Dudum has been clear that 2026 is about spending money to make money. They are leaning into AI-driven care and "platform-led access."

But the "Big Investment Year" tag is a double-edged sword. It means more innovation, but it also means the bottom line might look ugly for a few quarters. If you’re a short-term trader, that’s terrifying. If you’re looking at 2030, it might just be the cost of doing business.

The Verdict on 2026

If you’re watching the hims and hers health stock, you have to keep your eyes on the legal filings. The lawsuits between compounders and Big Pharma are going to dictate the price action more than any earnings report will.

The company has about $630 million in cash. They aren't going broke anytime soon. They’ve also got nearly $900 million in convertible notes they issued in 2025, which gives them a massive war chest for acquisitions.

Actionable Insights for Your Watchlist:

  1. Watch the FDA Shortage List: The second "Semaglutide" or "Tirzepatide" completely disappears from the shortage list, Hims has to pivot its weight loss strategy or face a massive revenue cliff.
  2. Monitor "Revenue per Subscriber": This climbed to about $80 recently. If this number keeps going up, it means their "personalization" strategy—selling you two or three things instead of one—is working.
  3. Check the Competitor Pricing: If Amazon or Eli Lilly drops the "out-of-pocket" price of branded drugs below $200, the Hims advantage evaporates.
  4. Insider Selling: Keep an eye on the C-suite. Executives like Andrew Dudum and the CFO have been selling shares throughout late 2025 and early 2026. While often scheduled, heavy selling can signal they think the stock has hit a temporary ceiling.

The stock is currently a "Hold" for most of the big banks, and that feels right. There is too much noise in the weight loss sector to go "all in" right now, but the underlying business—the one that doesn't rely on miracle shots—is still growing at a clip most companies would kill for.