You’re probably thinking about Old Man’s Cave. Everyone is. If you search for hiking in Hocking Hills, that’s the first thing that pops up, usually accompanied by a photo of the Upper Falls looking like a postcard from the Pacific Northwest. But here’s the thing: if you show up at 11:00 AM on a Saturday in October, you aren't going to feel like an intrepid explorer. You’re going to feel like you’re waiting in line at a grocery store, except everyone is wearing Patagonia and carrying trekking poles.
I’ve spent years navigating these sandstone gorges. Southeast Ohio is weird in the best way possible. You’re driving through rolling farmland and suddenly the earth just drops away into these massive Black Hand sandstone outcroppings. It’s a geological fluke. It’s also a place where you can have a spiritual experience in a hemlock forest or get stuck behind a tour group of forty people if you don't time it right.
The Real Story on Old Man’s Cave and the One-Way System
Let’s address the elephant in the gorge. Old Man’s Cave is the heart of Hocking Hills State Park for a reason. The scale is massive. The history—named after Richard Rowe, a hermit who lived in the cave back in the 1790s—is legitimate. But ever since the pandemic, the park shifted to a one-way trail system for many of the high-traffic areas.
This changed the vibe.
Basically, you can't just wander back and forth. If you start the loop at the Visitor Center, you're committed. This is actually a good thing for flow, but it means you need to be prepared. If you want to see the "Greatest Hits," you’re taking the Blue Trail (the Grandma Gatewood Trail, which is part of the much longer Buckeye Trail) through the gorge. You’ll hit Upper Falls, then the cave itself, and eventually Lower Falls.
Honesty time: the best part isn't the cave. It's the Sphinx Head rock formation and the way the light hits the moss on the walls of the gorge. If you want to avoid the "Disney World of Hiking" feel, you have to be at the trailhead by 7:30 AM. No later. By noon, the parking lot is a battlefield.
💡 You might also like: Where to Stay in Seoul: What Most People Get Wrong
Why Conkle’s Hollow is Actually Better (Don't Tell Everyone)
If you ask a local where they go when they actually want to go hiking in Hocking Hills without the chaos, they’ll usually point you toward Conkle’s Hollow State Nature Preserve. It’s technically not part of the State Park, which is a distinction that matters because the rules are stricter. No pets allowed here. That keeps the noise down significantly.
The Rim Trail at Conkle’s Hollow is spectacular. It’s a 2.5-mile loop that takes you 200 feet above the gorge floor. It’s not for people with vertigo. There are sections where the trail is about three feet wide with a sheer drop on one side. No railings. Just you and the wind.
The view from the West Rim at sunset? Incredible. You look across the valley and see the tops of the white pines and hemlocks. It feels prehistoric. Down in the gorge trail—which is paved and accessible—it stays about 10 degrees cooler than the parking lot because the walls are so high and close together. It’s a microclimate. You'll see plants there that normally only grow in Canada.
Cedar Falls and the Ash Cave Connection
Most people treat Cedar Falls as a quick photo op. They park, walk down the steps, see the waterfall (which, fun fact, was misnamed by early settlers who mistook the hemlock trees for cedars), and leave.
That’s a mistake.
📖 Related: Red Bank Battlefield Park: Why This Small Jersey Bluff Actually Changed the Revolution
Instead, park at Cedar Falls and hike the trail toward Ash Cave. It’s about a 6-mile round trip. This stretch of the trail is where you find the real peace. You’re follows Queer Creek, and the terrain is rugged. You’ll be stepping over roots and navigating sandstone steps.
Ash Cave is the largest recessed cave in the state. It’s shaped like a massive horseshoe. It’s so big that it was once used for camp meetings where a minister would stand on a rock called the "Pulpit Rock" and hundreds of people would sit in the natural amphitheater. Standing under the dripline of the waterfall there—especially in winter when it freezes into a massive ice pillar—is something you don't forget.
What Most People Get Wrong About Gear
I see it every weekend. People trying to navigate the steep, muddy stairs at Rock House in flip-flops. Don't be that person. The sandstone in Hocking Hills is notoriously slippery when wet, and it is almost always wet.
You need shoes with actual lugs. Vibram soles or something similar.
Also, cell service is non-existent in the gorges. Forget about Google Maps once you leave the town of Logan or Laurelville. Download your maps offline or, better yet, go to the Visitor Center and grab a paper map. It’s old school, but it works when your iPhone is searching for a signal that isn't coming.
👉 See also: Why the Map of Colorado USA Is Way More Complicated Than a Simple Rectangle
The Secret of Rock House and Cantwell Cliffs
If you really want to get away, head north. Cantwell Cliffs is the most remote section of the park. It’s also the most difficult. The "Fat Man’s Squeeze" is a narrow crack in the rocks you have to shimmy through. The trails here are eroded, steep, and will absolutely kick your butt. But because it's a 20-minute drive from the main park area, it sees a fraction of the visitors.
Then there’s Rock House. It’s a true cave, halfway up a cliff. It has "windows" created by erosion. It looks like a Gothic fortress. Inside, it’s dark, cool, and smells like damp earth. Legend says it was a hideout for bandits. Whether that’s 100% true or just local lore, standing inside and looking out at the forest canopy makes you feel like you've stepped back two centuries.
Seasonal Reality Check
Hiking here in the summer is humid. Deeply, overwhelmingly humid. The mosquitoes in the gorge can be relentless.
October is the "peak." The fall foliage against the tan sandstone is legendary. But honestly? Winter is the best-kept secret. When the waterfalls freeze and the crowds vanish, the park becomes silent. You can hear the crack of the ice and the wind in the pines. Just bring yaktrax for your boots because those stone steps become ice skating rinks.
Spring is for the waterfalls. If it hasn't rained in two weeks, the falls will be a trickle. If you go 24 hours after a heavy spring rain, places like Upper Falls and Cedar Falls turn into thundering monsters. That’s when the "hills" really show off.
Practical Steps for Your Trip
Don't just wing it. If you're planning on hiking in Hocking Hills, follow this workflow to actually enjoy yourself:
- Book your cabin or campsite six months out. If you're looking for a weekend in October, you might even need to book a year in advance. State Park sites are cheaper, but private cabins like those at Cherry Ridge or various Airbnb spots offer the hot tubs everyone wants after a long hike.
- Start at Cantwell Cliffs or Rock House in the afternoon. Most people hit Old Man's Cave first thing and then clog up the other sites later. Reverse the order.
- Pack a real lunch. There isn't a McDonald's around the corner once you're in the park. The Hocking Hills Dining Lodge is great, but it can be packed. Bring a cooler with high-protein snacks and plenty of water.
- Check the water levels. Use the USGS water gauges for nearby creeks if you’re a photographer. If the "Hocking River at Enterprise" is low, the waterfalls might be disappointing.
- Visit the John Glenn Astronomy Park at night. It’s right near Old Man’s Cave. Since there’s very little light pollution in the Hocking Hills, the stargazing is some of the best in the Midwest. They have a massive telescope and programs on Friday and Saturday nights.
The magic of this place isn't in the gift shop or the paved paths. It’s in the quiet moments between the landmarks. It’s finding a small, unnamed hollow where the water drips off a fern and the world feels very, very old. Respect the trail, leave no trace, and for the love of everything, wear decent boots.