Herodiana Puzzle 2 Chest: Why Most Players Miss the Best Loot

Look, we’ve all been there. You’re sprinting through the Astronomy Wing, trying to finish Sophronia Franklin’s quest so you can finally rock that sweet Herodiana Cape, and you hit a wall. Literally. The Hall of Herodiana isn't just a basic "push and pull" tutorial. By the time you reach the second chamber, the game stops holding your hand, and if you're just aiming for the exit, you are going to walk right past the Herodiana puzzle 2 chest.

It’s frustrating. You see the chest perched up on that high ledge near the entrance, but the blocks are all over the place. Honestly, the "standard" solution for the room just gets you to the exit door. If you want the extra loot—which, let's be real, is usually a decent piece of gear or a collection item—you have to think backward.

The Trick to Reaching the Herodiana Puzzle 2 Chest

Most people get stuck because they try to solve the exit first. Don't do that. The moment you step into the second room, you’ll see a single block and a double-cube block.

To grab the Herodiana puzzle 2 chest, you need to ignore the exit for a second. Turn around and look at the wall you just came through. There’s a high platform right above the entrance. That’s your target.

Step-by-Step to the Bonus Loot

First, you've gotta prep the blocks. Stand near the entrance and look toward the back of the room (the exit). Cast Accio on the double-block to pull it toward the right-hand wall. Now, move your eyes to that single block. Cast Depulso to shove it toward the entrance wall.

💡 You might also like: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026

Here is where it gets kinda specific. You need to combine them.

• Cast Accio on the double-block to pull it toward the entrance.
• It should now be sitting right next to (or under) the single block.
• Once they touch, they "snap" together into a triple-block staircase shape.

Now that you have your makeshift stairs, cast Accio one more time to pull the whole combined structure toward the entrance wall. It should stop right under the ledge with the chest. Just climb up, grab your rewards, and feel smug about not missing the "missable" content.

Moving from the Chest to the Exit

Okay, so you've got the loot. Now what? The room is a mess. The best thing you can do—and seriously, save yourself the headache—is to hit the reset switch. It’s that glowing golden orb on the wall. Just hit it with a basic cast. Everything goes back to zero.

To actually finish the room after getting the Herodiana puzzle 2 chest, follow this quick flow:

📖 Related: Grand Theft Auto Games Timeline: Why the Chronology is a Beautiful Mess

1. Accio the double-block to the right wall.
2. Depulso the single block to the back wall.
3. Accio the double-block toward the back wall so it joins the single block.
4. Now that they are a triple-block, Accio them to the left wall.
5. Finally, Accio them toward you (the entrance side) so they rest against the stone pillar in the middle.

You can now climb the blocks, jump to the middle stone platform, and then jump to the exit. It sounds like a lot, but once the blocks are joined, they move as one unit, which makes life way easier.

Common Mistakes and Glitches

People often complain that the blocks "get stuck" in the corners. If you shove a block into a corner where you can't get behind it for a Depulso or have a clear line for Accio, you're basically stuck. This is why the reset orb exists. Use it.

Also, watch your positioning. If you stand in the path of a moving block, the game will "squish" you. It doesn't kill you, but it teleports you back to the start of the puzzle and resets the blocks automatically. Sometimes, players actually use this as a "fast reset" if they're too lazy to aim at the golden orb. Kinda clever, honestly.

Why Bother with the Extra Chests?

You might be wondering if it's even worth the effort. The main quest rewards you with the Herodiana's Signature Outfit pieces (Cape, Attire, and Cap), but these side chests in the rooms usually drop random gear. In 2026, we know the loot tables for these are leveled to your character. If you're doing this quest late-game, you might pull a Legendary piece of gear that’s actually useful for your build.

👉 See also: Among Us Spider-Man: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With These Mods

Plus, if you're a completionist aiming for that 100% badge, you can't just skip these. The Hall of Herodiana is one of those spots where if you leave without the chests, you'll find yourself searching "how to go back" three weeks later when you're missing one last collection item.

Final Checklist for Puzzle 2

• Entrance Ledge: Always look up and behind you when you enter.
• Spells Needed: You absolutely must have Accio and Depulso equipped.
• The Reset Orb: Don't be afraid to use it if the blocks aren't behaving.
• Combination: The secret is making that "L" or staircase shape by slamming the blocks together.

Get that gear and move on to the third puzzle—which, fair warning, is significantly more annoying than this one.

Next Steps: Once you've cleared the second room, make sure you don't immediately run through the third. There is another optional chest in Puzzle 3 that requires you to use the reset orb mid-climb. You'll want to position the blocks, jump halfway, then hit the orb while standing on a safe ledge to reposition the blocks for the final stretch.