Everyone wanted to see him. For years, the legend of Herobrine has been the ultimate "what if" for any potential Minecraft project. So when A Minecraft Movie finally hit theaters in April 2025, fans were scouring every frame of the Overworld for those iconic, glowing white eyes.
Did he show up? Well, it depends on who you ask and how much you trust the official story coming out of Mojang.
The short answer is that Herobrine isn't a "character" in the traditional sense within the film. He doesn't have lines. He isn't the surprise villain hiding behind the Piglin Queen. But there is a specific moment—a glitch, an Easter egg, or perhaps something more "supernatural"—that has the entire community arguing on social media.
The Woodland Mansion Incident
If you’ve seen the movie, you know the scene. Henry, played by Sebastian Hansen, gets separated from the group and finds himself face-to-face with an Enderman inside a Woodland Mansion. It’s a tense, eerie sequence that leans more into the game's "unsettling" side than the rest of the film's slapstick humor.
The Enderman puts Henry into a trance-like state.
Suddenly, Henry starts seeing nightmare visions of his friends and family. This includes Steve, played by Jack Black, who starts berating the kid. It’s a classic psychological horror trope. But here’s the kicker: while everyone else in the vision has glowing purple eyes to match the Enderman’s magic, Jack Black’s Steve has blank white eyes.
It is unmistakable. It is Herobrine.
👉 See also: GTA Vice City Cheat Switch: How to Make the Definitive Edition Actually Fun
"Just a Glitch" or a Genius Marketing Move?
The fallout on X (formerly Twitter) was immediate. Fans were convinced this was the big reveal, the confirmation that Herobrine is real in the cinematic universe. However, Torfi Frans Ólafsson, a producer on the film and a Senior Creative Director at Mojang, threw cold water on the theory almost immediately.
According to Ólafsson, the white eyes were a rendering error.
He claimed the VFX team simply ran out of time to fix the frames before the final cut was due. "It’s super strange," he posted. "All of their eyes were supposed to be purple, but one character's eyes kept coming out white." He basically told the world that the most famous creepypasta in history made it into a multi-million dollar blockbuster because of a deadline.
Honestly? Most fans aren't buying it.
Minecraft's patch notes have included the line "Removed Herobrine" for over a decade. It’s the longest-running inside joke in gaming. For a major studio to claim they "tried to fix it" but he "kept coming back" sounds exactly like the kind of meta-lore Mojang loves to play with. Whether it was a genuine accident or a very clever nod to the fans, Herobrine's presence in the movie is now part of the myth.
Why Herobrine Matters to the Movie’s Legacy
You have to understand that Herobrine is a community creation. He was never "official." Back in 2010, an anonymous 4chan post and a subsequent Brocraft stream birthed the idea of a ghost in the machine—a version of Steve with dead eyes who builds random pyramids and tunnels.
✨ Don't miss: Gothic Romance Outfit Dress to Impress: Why Everyone is Obsessed With This Vibe Right Now
Including him officially would be a massive shift for Mojang.
For the movie, director Jared Hess clearly wanted to stick to the established, "brand-safe" mobs. We got the Piglins, the Ghasts, and even a very sweet tribute to the late YouTuber Technoblade in the form of a crowned pig. Going full horror with a dead brother story probably didn't fit the family-friendly vibe they were going for.
Breaking Down the "Evidence"
- The Vision: Steve is the only character with white eyes in the trance.
- The Reaction: Jack Black himself has been cagey in interviews, giving "we don't know" answers accompanied by suspicious blinking.
- The Context: The movie deals with an "Orb of Dominance," an artifact that corrupts. It wouldn't be a stretch for a sequel to suggest the Orb could create a corrupted version of a "Crafter."
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of casual viewers thought Jason Momoa’s character, Garrett "The Garbage Man" Garrison, was going to become Herobrine. There were tons of theories suggesting he was a "failed" Steve from a previous world.
That didn't happen.
Garrett has his own arc involving a vintage video game championship and learning to embrace the blocky world. There’s no "villain origin story" there. If Herobrine exists in this world, he’s a phantom, an anomaly, or a byproduct of the Enderman's mental manipulation.
What Happens Next?
The movie has been a massive box office hit despite mixed reviews from critics. A sequel is almost a certainty at this point. If you watched the post-credits scene with Matt Berry’s Villager, you know they are leaning into the weirder parts of the game’s lore.
🔗 Read more: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
Will the sequel go full Herobrine?
The "glitch" in the first movie has effectively set the stage. If the producers want to bring him back, they can say the glitch was a "glimpse into the code" or some other meta-narrative. It gives them an out. They can keep him as a spooky background detail or elevate him to a primary threat.
For now, keep your eyes peeled on the home release and streaming versions. There is a lot of chatter about whether the VFX team will "fix" the eyes for the digital version or if they'll leave the legend intact.
If you're looking for Herobrine in the movie, don't expect a boss fight. Look for the small stuff. Look for the things that shouldn't be there. That's always been how he operates.
Keep an eye on the background of the Extreme Hills scenes during the second act. Some players swear they’ve seen a distant figure without a name tag, but that might just be the community doing what it does best: seeing ghosts in the blocks.
Check your world files. Look for the white eyes. And maybe, just maybe, don't dig straight down.
Next Steps for Fans
To get the full picture of the Herobrine lore before the sequel rumors heat up, you should:
- Watch the Woodland Mansion scene frame-by-frame on the digital release to see the eye-color transition.
- Follow Torfi Frans Ólafsson on X for the inevitable "Removed Herobrine" jokes in the next production update.
- Explore the Minecraft Wiki's "A Minecraft Movie" page to see the full list of verified Easter eggs, including the Technoblade tribute and the DanTDM cameo.