You probably saw the headlines or maybe a frantic post in a Facebook group. One day you’re sipping your nightly brew to wind down, and the next, there’s talk of a Herbalife relaxation tea recall. It’s the kind of news that makes you sprint to the pantry to check lot numbers. Honestly, it’s stressful. The irony of a "relaxation" product causing a minor panic isn't lost on anyone.
But here’s the thing: facts get messy fast on the internet. People start speculating about "toxic chemicals" or "secret ingredients" when the reality is usually much more mundane, though still serious for those affected. If you’re looking for the breakdown of what actually went down with the 2017 peppermint tea situation—which is the primary event people refer to—I’ve got the receipts.
The 2017 Incident: Not a "Total" Recall
First off, let's clear up a massive misconception. There wasn't a global, company-wide ban on all relaxation teas. In 2017, Herbalife had to pull a specific batch of their Herbalife24 Apple Peppermint and the standard Relaxation Tea Peppermint flavor in certain markets, most notably in parts of Europe like the UK and Ireland.
Why? It wasn't because the tea was "poison." It was a contamination issue.
Specifically, the company found traces of atropine and scopolamine. Those names might sound like something out of a chemistry textbook, but they are naturally occurring alkaloids found in certain weeds, like Datura (Jimson weed). These weeds sometimes grow right alongside peppermint crops. If the harvesting process isn't perfect, a few of these "accidental" leaves get ground up with the mint.
It’s a farm-to-table problem, not a lab-grown conspiracy.
What These Alkaloids Actually Do to You
You might be wondering if a tiny bit of weed contamination is a big deal. For most people, it's a "call your doctor" situation, not a "head to the ER" one, but it's definitely not fun. Atropine and scopolamine can mess with your nervous system.
If someone drank the contaminated batch, they might have experienced:
- A strangely dry mouth (more than just "thirsty").
- Blurry vision that makes reading your phone impossible.
- A heart rate that feels like you just ran a 5k while sitting on the couch.
- Dizziness or a weird, "out of it" feeling.
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) is incredibly strict about these levels. Even a tiny deviation triggers a massive response. Herbalife acted quickly because, frankly, the liability of a "hallucinogenic" tea is a nightmare for a multi-billion dollar wellness brand. They issued the withdrawal as a "precautionary measure."
Why Does This Keep Coming Up?
The internet has a long memory. Even though this specific Herbalife relaxation tea recall happened years ago, people still search for it every time they feel a bit jittery after a cup of tea. It's the "WebMD effect." You feel a symptom, you Google the brand, and an old recall pops up.
Also, Herbalife is a polarizing company. Because it operates on a multi-level marketing (MLM) model, it's always under a microscope. Critics love to point to past recalls as evidence of poor quality control, while distributors often downplay them. The truth sits right in the middle: large-scale botanical sourcing is inherently risky. Whether it's Herbalife, Lipton, or a boutique organic brand, if you're sourcing tons of herbs from fields, nature sometimes sneaks in.
How to Tell if Your Current Tea is Safe
If you have a container of relaxation tea in your cupboard right now, you’re almost certainly fine. Recalls are targeted. They apply to specific "Lot Numbers" and "Best Before" dates.
- Look at the bottom of your canister.
- Find the batch code.
- Check it against the official Herbalife "Product Advisory" page or the FDA/FSA databases.
Unless you've been hoarding tea since the Obama administration, your peppermint tea is likely from a completely different harvest and a different facility. The 2017 issue was resolved, and the contaminated lots were long ago pulled from shelves and destroyed.
The Nuance of "Natural" Products
We tend to think "natural" means "perfectly safe," but botanical supplements are complex. According to Dr. Pieter Cohen, an associate professor at Harvard Medical School who often studies the supplement industry, botanical products are frequently subject to cross-contamination.
It’s not just weeds. Sometimes it’s heavy metals from the soil or pesticides from a neighboring farm. This is why "third-party testing" is a term you’ll hear experts scream from the rooftops. You want to know that a lab not owned by the company verified that what's on the label is in the bottle—and nothing else.
Herbalife claims to use a "Seed to Feed" strategy to prevent this. They’ve invested millions in DNA barcoding for their plants to ensure they are actually processing peppermint and not a look-alike weed. The 2017 recall was a failure of that system, but it also forced them to tighten those protocols significantly.
Other "Recalls" You Might Be Confusing This With
Sometimes people search for the relaxation tea recall but they are actually thinking about the 2020 or 2022 warnings regarding different products. For instance, there have been various "safety alerts" over the years regarding liver health concerns associated with some Herbalife products, though these are often debated in medical literature.
A famous study published in the Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hepatology raised concerns about Herbalife products in India, but the company vehemently contested the findings, citing flaws in the study's methodology. It’s important to distinguish between a voluntary recall (like the peppermint tea) and a scientific controversy (like the liver health debates). One is a clear-cut logistical error; the other is a complex medical discussion.
What You Should Do Now
If you're a regular user of the relaxation tea, don't throw it out in a panic. But do be a smart consumer.
Check your source. Are you buying from a reputable distributor or a weird third-party site that might be selling "gray market" or expired goods?
Listen to your body. If a tea that's supposed to make you sleepy makes your heart race, stop drinking it. It doesn't matter if there's an official recall or not—your body is giving you a data point.
Keep records. Take a photo of the batch number when you buy a new supplement. If a recall is announced three months from now, you won't have to wonder if you already finished the "bad" bottle.
Diversify. Don't rely on a single supplement for "relaxation." Mix it up with magnesium, L-theanine from other sources, or just good old-fashioned chamomile.
📖 Related: Kybella Stomach Before and After: What Really Happens When You Inject Belly Fat
The Herbalife relaxation tea recall serves as a reminder that the supplement industry is still a bit of a Wild West. Even the giants of the industry have bad days at the farm. Stay informed, check your lot numbers, and maybe keep a closer eye on that "natural" label.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Verify your product's batch number on the official Herbalife distributor portal if you have concerns about older stock.
- Cross-reference any suspicious symptoms with the FDA’s Safety Reporting Portal.
- Switch to a product that features the NSF Certified for Sport or USP seal if you want the highest level of third-party verification against contamination.