If you walked into a sportsbook in August 2024 and told the clerk you wanted to put money on a two-way player from a 4-8 team to win the Heisman, they probably would’ve checked your temperature. Travis Hunter was sitting at +7500. He was an afterthought. A highlight-reel guy on a "fun" team that nobody expected to actually win anything.
Then the season happened.
Watching the heisman betting odds 2024 move was like riding a wooden roller coaster in a thunderstorm. One week you’re certain it’s a quarterback’s award—because it basically always is—and the next, a running back from Boise is threatening to break a Barry Sanders record that everyone thought was untouchable. Honestly, the 2024 race was the most chaotic stretch of betting history we’ve seen in a decade.
The Quarterback Fallacy and the Rise of the "One-of-Ones"
For years, the Heisman has basically been the "Best Quarterback on a Top 5 Team" trophy. That’s why Carson Beck and Quinn Ewers opened as the favorites. People saw those +750 and +800 numbers and jumped. It’s the safe bet.
But safe is boring, and 2024 wasn’t boring.
By mid-September, the market started to sniff out something weird. Cam Ward at Miami was putting up video-game numbers. He became the "sharp" favorite for a minute. Then there was Dillon Gabriel at Oregon. Gabriel was the model of efficiency, leading the Ducks to a #1 ranking. If you were betting on heisman betting odds 2024 in October, you probably had a ticket for one of those two.
Then Ashton Jeanty entered the chat.
The Boise State running back didn't just run the ball; he pulverized defenses. He was on pace to eclipse 2,600 yards. At one point in late October, Jeanty actually became the betting favorite at +200. A Group of Five running back leading the Heisman race? It felt like a glitch in the simulation.
👉 See also: Fantasy Football WR Rankings Week 12: Why Your Lineup Is Kinda A Mess Right Now
Why the Odds Swung Wildly in November
- The Travis Hunter Effect: Hunter wasn't just playing both ways; he was playing every snap. 92 catches for 1,152 yards and 14 touchdowns. Oh, and four interceptions and 11 pass breakups on defense.
- The "Moment" Factor: When Hunter forced that game-winning fumble against Baylor, his odds cratered from +1500 to +270 in a single weekend.
- The QB Fade: Cam Ward had a few "human" moments late in the year, and Dillon Gabriel, despite being amazing, just didn't have that "Heisman Moment" that captures the voters' imaginations.
Heisman Betting Odds 2024: The Final Stretch
By the time the regular season wrapped up, the betting board looked nothing like the preseason. It was essentially a two-horse race between Hunter and Jeanty.
Hunter ended the season as a massive -2000 favorite. Think about that. You had to bet $2,000 just to win $100. It’s rare to see that kind of certainty in a race that felt so close on paper. Jeanty, despite finishing with 2,497 rushing yards (the 4th most in FBS history), was sitting at +800 or longer at most books.
The voters ultimately chose the "unicorn."
The final tally was the closest we've seen since 2009. Hunter finished with 2,231 points. Jeanty was right behind him with 2,017. If you had an early ticket on Hunter at +7500, you were sitting on a goldmine. If you bet on the "safe" quarterbacks? You were left holding a lot of worthless paper.
What the 2024 Race Teaches Us About Future Betting
Most people look at the Heisman through a very narrow lens. They look at stats. But the heisman betting odds 2024 showed us that "narrative" is worth more than a 2,000-yard season.
Voters get bored. They’ve seen great quarterbacks before. They’ve seen 2,000-yard rushers (though rarely). They hadn't seen a guy play 100 snaps a game and elite-level football on both sides of the ball since Charles Woodson in 1997.
The smart money in the future isn't on the "best" player. It’s on the player who is doing something we haven't seen in 25 years.
✨ Don't miss: South Africa Cricket Team Fixtures: The Proteas Schedule You Need to Know
Actionable Takeaways for Heisman Bettors
If you’re looking to get ahead of the market in future seasons, stop looking at the preseason favorites. The last few years have shown that the value is almost always in the +2000 to +5000 range.
- Look for the "Unicorn" early. If a player is doing something statistically impossible or playing multiple positions, grab those long odds before the national media catches on.
- Monitor the "Heisman Moment." These awards are won in October and November. A single play in a primetime game can move a player’s odds from +1000 to +200 in three hours.
- Don't ignore the Group of Five. Ashton Jeanty proved that if you're historic enough, the voters (and the oddsmakers) will find you, even if you aren't playing in the SEC.
The 2024 season was a masterclass in why betting on this award is so volatile. It’s not just about football; it’s about the story. And Travis Hunter had the best story in sports.
Next Steps for Your Betting Strategy: Before the next season kicks off, audit the "snap counts" of top athletes. Look for versatile players in high-volume offenses who might also contribute on special teams or defense. These are the "hidden" value plays that the public ignores until the odds have already moved.