You’re 5'8". In the world of fashion, that’s often the "standard" height, but in the world of health, it can feel like you’re stuck in a weird middle ground. You aren't short, but you aren't a "tall" outlier either. You’re tall enough that five pounds of water weight disappears into your frame, yet when the scale creeps up, you start wondering where the line actually sits. Finding the healthy weight for a 5 8 woman isn't just about hitting a magic number on a dusty bathroom scale; it’s about understanding how your frame, muscle mass, and even your age change the math.
Numbers are tricky. Honestly, they’re kinda annoying.
If you look at the standard Body Mass Index (BMI) charts—the ones doctors still use because they’re easy, even if they're flawed—the range for a woman of this height is surprisingly wide. We’re talking anywhere from 122 to 164 pounds. That’s a 42-pound gap. It’s huge. How can two women with the same height have a 40-pound difference and both be "healthy"? It’s because the scale doesn't know the difference between a gallon of water, a dense quad muscle, and visceral fat.
The BMI Trap and the 5'8" Reality
Let’s get real about the BMI. It was invented in the 1830s by a Belgian mathematician named Adolphe Quetelet. He wasn't even a doctor. He was a statistician trying to find the "average man." He never intended for it to be a diagnostic tool for individual health. For a woman who is 5'8", the BMI calculation is $weight / height^{2}$ (in metric).
If you weigh 140 pounds, your BMI is about 21.3. That’s dead center of "normal." But if you’ve been lifting weights for five years and you’re a lean 168 pounds, the BMI might flag you as "overweight." This is where the system breaks down. Muscle is roughly 15% denser than fat. You’ve probably seen those photos of 5-pound chunks of muscle versus 5-pound chunks of fat—the fat looks like a giant blob of yellow jello, while the muscle is a compact, sleek piece of steak.
When you’re taller, you have more room to carry that muscle. A 5'8" woman has a longer skeletal structure, longer tendons, and generally more surface area. This means the healthy weight for a 5 8 woman who is an athlete is going to look radically different from someone who works a desk job and doesn't exercise.
Think about it this way.
At 5'8", you have a presence.
Your bones are heavier.
Your blood volume is higher.
Even your internal organs are slightly larger than someone who is 5'1".
🔗 Read more: Images of the Mitochondria: Why Most Diagrams are Kinda Wrong
Dr. Nick Trefethen from Oxford University actually proposed a "New BMI" formula because he realized the old one punishes tall people. He argues that the traditional formula makes tall people think they are fatter than they are. Under his math, the healthy range for a 5'8" woman shifts slightly upward, giving you a bit more grace. It’s a more realistic look at how volume increases as height increases.
Why Body Composition Changes Everything
Weight is a liar.
I’ve talked to women who felt "fat" at 145 pounds because they had no muscle tone and felt "skinny fat." Then, they started hitting the gym, gained ten pounds, and suddenly their jeans fit better at 155. It sounds like a paradox, but it’s just physics.
You need to look at your Waist-to-Hip Ratio (WHR). This is often a way better predictor of health than the scale. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), a WHR of 0.85 or less is what you’re aiming for. For a woman of 5'8", having a "pear" or "hourglass" shape is often a sign of good metabolic health, even if the weight is a bit higher. The danger comes when the weight settles entirely in the midsection—that’s the visceral fat that crowds your organs and drives up inflammation.
- Small Frame: Narrow shoulders, thin wrists. You might feel best at the lower end of the range (125-135 lbs).
- Medium Frame: Most women fall here. 135-155 lbs is usually the sweet spot where energy levels are high and clothes fit comfortably.
- Large Frame: Broad shoulders, "big bones" (yes, it's a real thing). You might be 165 or 170 lbs and look incredibly fit and healthy.
If you can grab your wrist with your thumb and middle finger and they overlap significantly, you’re likely small-framed. If they just touch, you’re medium. If there’s a gap? Large frame. It’s a quick-and-dirty trick, but it’s surprisingly accurate for gauging where your baseline weight should sit.
The Age Factor: It Isn't Just "Slowing Metabolism"
We’ve all heard that your metabolism tanks after 30. That’s actually a bit of a myth. Recent studies, including a major one published in the journal Science in 2021, show that our metabolic rate stays pretty stable from age 20 all the way to 60.
💡 You might also like: How to Hit Rear Delts with Dumbbells: Why Your Back Is Stealing the Gains
So why do we gain weight?
Lifestyle creep.
Loss of muscle mass (sarcopenia).
Hormonal shifts.
For a 5'8" woman in her 40s or 50s, the "healthy weight" might naturally climb by 5 to 10 pounds. This isn't necessarily a bad thing. In fact, some research suggests that having a slightly higher BMI as you age (around 25 to 27) can actually protect against osteoporosis and provide a "reserve" if you get a serious illness. Being too thin at 5'8" as you age can make you look gaunt and increase your risk of fractures.
Estrogen is a major player here. As it drops during perimenopause, your body tries to hang onto fat because fat cells can actually produce a weak form of estrogen. Your body is basically trying to help you out, even if you hate the new "belly pooch."
The "Perfect" Number vs. Metabolic Health
Let’s stop obsessing over the 130s for a second. Instead, look at the markers that actually determine if you're going to live a long time.
- Blood Pressure: Is it under 120/80?
- Resting Heart Rate: Are you between 60 and 100 bpm? (Athletes are often lower).
- Blood Sugar: Is your A1C under 5.7?
- Energy Levels: Do you crash at 3 PM, or can you get through the day?
If those numbers are good, and you’re 160 pounds at 5'8", you are healthy. Period. You might be "overweight" by a 19th-century math equation, but in 2026, we know better.
📖 Related: How to get over a sore throat fast: What actually works when your neck feels like glass
Misconceptions about the healthy weight for a 5 8 woman usually stem from comparing ourselves to celebrities or runway models. Keep in mind that most of those women are professional outliers. They have chefs, trainers, and often, very restrictive diets that aren't sustainable for someone living a normal life. For most of us, "healthy" means being able to hike a trail, carry groceries, and not feel winded walking up two flights of stairs.
Practical Steps to Find Your Personal Baseline
Don't just jump on a diet. That’s the fastest way to mess up your hunger hormones (ghrelin and leptin). Instead, try a more nuanced approach.
Track your protein, not just calories. At 5'8", you have a lot of muscle to maintain. Aiming for 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of goal weight is a game changer. If you want to be 145 lbs, try eating 120-140 grams of protein. It keeps you full and protects your metabolism.
Ditch the "Regular" Scale. Get a smart scale that measures body composition. They aren't 100% accurate (DEXA scans are the gold standard for that), but they are great for tracking trends. If your weight is staying the same but your body fat percentage is dropping, you’re winning.
Focus on "The Big Three."
Sleep, stress, and strength. If you’re sleeping 5 hours a night and stressed at work, your cortisol is going to make you hold onto weight no matter what the "healthy" range says. Strength training is non-negotiable for a woman of your height. Because your limbs are longer, you have a mechanical disadvantage in some lifts, but you also have more room to build a powerful, functional physique.
Listen to your joints.
Being 5'8" means more leverage on your knees and ankles. If you’re carrying extra weight and your joints ache, your body is telling you that your current weight is too much for your frame. It’s not about aesthetics; it’s about mechanics.
The Realistic Check-In
Take a look at your lifestyle. Are you happy? Can you go out to dinner without panicking about the menu? If you’re 155 pounds and you feel strong and vibrant, that is your healthy weight for a 5 8 woman. If you’re 130 pounds but you’re cold all the time, losing hair, and obsessed with food, you are underweight for your specific biology, regardless of what the chart says.
Health is a feeling, not a static point on a graph.
Actionable Next Steps
- Measure your waist-to-hip ratio tomorrow morning. Use a soft tape measure. Divide your waist measurement by your hip measurement. Aim for 0.80 or lower for optimal metabolic health.
- Calculate your protein needs. Take your current weight and multiply it by 0.7. Start trying to hit that number in grams of protein every day for one week. See how your hunger levels change.
- Schedule a basic blood panel. Ask your doctor for fasting glucose, A1C, and a lipid profile. These "internal" numbers matter way more than the number on your scale.
- Audit your movement. If you aren't lifting weights at least twice a week, start. For a taller woman, maintaining bone density through resistance training is the single best thing you can do for your future self.