It sounds like a dream. You finally land the job with the corner office, marry the person you spent three years pining over, and your bank account finally has enough commas to make you feel safe. You’ve arrived. But then, about three weeks into this new reality, a weird, unsettling coldness creeps in. You’re sitting in the middle of your "perfect" life, staring at the wall, wondering why you don't feel different. Honestly, it’s a bit of a crisis.
People rarely talk about the psychological comedown of success. We are conditioned to be strivers. From the moment we get our first gold star in kindergarten, the "more" is the goal. But have you ever gotten everything you ever wanted only to realize your brain didn't get the memo that it was supposed to stop being anxious? It’s a real phenomenon. Psychologists call it the "arrival fallacy."
Tal Ben-Shahar, a Harvard professor and author who basically pioneered the study of happiness, coined that term. He noticed that people spend their whole lives thinking, "I'll be happy when..." and then they get there, and the happiness evaporates within days. It’s a glitch in the human operating system. We are wired for the hunt, not the feast.
The Biology of Why Winning Feels Like Losing
Our brains aren't designed to keep us happy. They are designed to keep us alive. Dopamine, the chemical we usually associate with pleasure, isn't actually about the reward itself. It’s about the anticipation of the reward.
When you’re working toward a goal, your brain is pumping out dopamine. You’re excited. You’re focused. You’re alive. But the moment you achieve the goal? The dopamine spikes and then craters. You’re left with a baseline that feels incredibly boring by comparison. This is why lottery winners often end up depressed or why Olympic athletes fall into "post-Olympic blues" the second the closing ceremony ends.
Have you ever gotten everything you ever wanted and felt like you were grieving? That’s not you being ungrateful. It’s your neurochemistry struggling to find a new equilibrium. You’ve lost your "why." Without a mountain to climb, the climber feels useless.
Real Stories of the "Perfect" Life Trap
Look at someone like Jim Carrey. He famously said, "I think everybody should get rich and famous and do everything they ever dreamed of so they can see that it's not the answer." He isn't being a jerk. He’s speaking from the peak of a mountain that turned out to be made of clouds.
Then there’s the case of professional "success" in the corporate world. I once knew a consultant named Sarah—this is an illustrative example, but it’s a story I’ve seen play out a dozen times. She spent ten years trying to make partner at her firm. She sacrificed sleep, relationships, and her health. The day she got the promotion, she went home, ordered a pizza, and cried because she realized she still had to wake up at 6:00 AM the next day and keep doing the same work, just with a bigger title and more liability.
The goal was a mirage.
We also see this in "Lifestyle Creep." You want a better car. You get it. For a week, you love the smell of the leather and the way the engine purrs. By month two, it’s just the thing that gets you to the grocery store. You’ve hedged your happiness against a moving target. This is the Hedonic Treadmill. You run and run, but your level of satisfaction stays exactly where it started because you just keep adjusting your expectations upward.
Why the "Everything" Includes the Bad Stuff Too
One thing nobody tells you is that when you get "everything," you also get the baggage that comes with it.
- The big house? It comes with higher taxes and more things that break.
- The high-level job? It comes with politics and the constant fear of being replaced.
- The "perfect" partner? They are still a human being with annoying habits and bad moods.
We tend to imagine our goals in 2D. We see the snapshot of the finish line, but we don't see the 24/7 reality of living past that finish line. It’s a form of cognitive bias. We filter out the costs.
Dealing With the "Now What?" Phase
So, what happens if you actually find yourself in this position? If you’ve checked all the boxes and you’re still miserable?
💡 You might also like: Cadillac Memorial Gardens East: What Most People Get Wrong
First, stop blaming yourself for not being "happy enough." Gratitude is great, but you can’t force a chemical reaction in your brain just by telling yourself you’re lucky.
You need to shift from Achievement-Based Happiness to Process-Based Happiness.
Achievement is a point in time. Process is a way of existing. If you hate the daily grind of your life, no amount of "success" will fix that. If you love the act of writing, it doesn't matter if you sell a million books or ten. The joy is in the typing. If you only care about the bestseller list, you’re going to be miserable even if you make it, because you’ll immediately start worrying about the next book.
The Problem With Modern Perfection
Social media has made this ten times worse. We see people who seem to have "gotten everything" and they look radiant in their curated photos. What you don't see is the existential dread they feel at 2:00 AM.
We are comparing our messy interiors with their polished exteriors. This creates a false narrative that if we just reached that same milestone, our internal mess would disappear. It won’t. Your "inner roommate"—that voice in your head that critiques everything—is coming with you to the mansion. It doesn't stay behind in the apartment.
Shifting the Goalposts (In a Good Way)
Instead of asking "Have you ever gotten everything you ever wanted?" maybe the better question is "Have you ever wanted the right things?"
Viktor Frankl, a psychiatrist and Holocaust survivor, wrote about this in Man’s Search for Meaning. He argued that humans aren't actually looking for "happiness" or "pleasure." We are looking for meaning.
Meaning is messy. It involves struggle. It involves being needed by other people. Often, getting "everything you want" is a very selfish, internal goal. It’s about your status, your comfort, your bank account. Meaning usually happens when you look outward.
If you’re feeling empty at the top, it’s probably because you’ve focused on "attaining" rather than "contributing." It sounds cheesy, but the data backs it up. Acts of service and deep community connections provide a much more stable floor for your mental health than a new Rolex ever could.
How to Handle Success Without Crashing
If you are currently on the path to getting everything you want, or if you’re already there and feeling the slump, there are specific things you can do to stay grounded.
- Practice Negative Visualization. This is an old Stoic trick. Occasionally imagine losing the things you’ve worked so hard for. Not to be morbid, but to remind your brain that they are valuable. It resets your baseline.
- Diversify Your Identity. Don't be "The CEO" or "The Influencer." Be a gardener, a friend, a mediocre guitar player, and a volunteer. If one part of your life reaches its peak and feels stagnant, the other parts keep you moving.
- Focus on Micro-Wins. Big goals are dangerous because they end. Small, recurring habits—like a daily walk or a weekly dinner with friends—don't "end." They just provide a consistent rhythm to your life.
- Lower the Stakes. Realize that no single achievement is going to "fix" you. Once you accept that success won't make you 100% happy forever, you can actually start to enjoy it for what it is: a nice bonus, not a life-saving surgery.
Actionable Steps for the "Post-Success" Funk
If you’ve hit your goals and feel nothing, do these three things this week:
- Change your environment. Literally. Go somewhere where nobody knows your "status" or what you’ve achieved. It forces you to interact with the world as a human being again, not as a collection of accomplishments.
- Audit your "Whys." Look at your next goal. Are you doing it because you actually enjoy the work, or because you’re afraid of what happens if you stop? If it’s the latter, pivot.
- Invest in "Useless" Hobbies. Do something you are objectively bad at and have no intention of monetizing. It kills the "striver" mindset and reminds you how to play.
Success is a tool, not a destination. Use it to build a life that feels good on the inside, not one that just looks good from the street.