Lacey Chabert is basically the queen of Christmas. We all know it. So, when Hallmark announced a sequel to one of its most chaotic, over-the-top holiday comedies, people were understandably a bit skeptical. Usually, Christmas sequels feel like leftovers you've microwaved one too many times. But Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up actually managed to lean into the absurdity of suburban homeowners' associations in a way that felt fresh, weird, and surprisingly self-aware.
It’s funny. Most people expect these movies to be quiet, cozy stories about a baker falling for a woodworker. This isn't that. It’s loud. It’s competitive. It’s got a lot of inflatable reindeer.
What Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up Gets Right About Neighborhood Feuds
The first movie introduced us to Emily and Jared. Emily, played by Chabert, returns to her parents' house only to find herself trapped in a neighborhood with more holiday rules than a federal prison. In Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up, the stakes are different. They aren't fighting the HOA anymore; they are the HOA. Or at least, they're the ones trying to keep the peace when a "Christmas royalty" family moves in down the street.
The Jolly Johnsons. That's the name of the new family. They are the antagonists, if you can call someone with that much glitter an antagonist. They represent that specific type of neighbor we all have—the one who treats outdoor decorating like a high-stakes Olympic sport.
Wes Brown returns as Jared, and his chemistry with Chabert is the anchor here. Without them, the whole thing might have flown off the rails into pure slapstick. Because the movie is basically a series of escalating pranks and light-bulb-count battles, you need actors who can play the "straight man" to the surrounding madness. It’s a delicate balance.
The Weird Reality of HOA Holiday Decorations
Did you know there are actual, real-life neighborhoods in places like Florida and Texas where you can be fined $50 a day if your lights aren't the right shade of "warm white"? It's true. While the movie exaggerates this for comedy, the core of the conflict in Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up is rooted in the very real tension of suburban conformity.
Ellen Travolta (yes, John’s sister) and Peter Jacobson bring a lot of the veteran comedic chops to the supporting cast. They play the established neighbors who treat the "Evergreen Lane" reputation as a sacred trust. It's ridiculous. It's meant to be. But for anyone who has ever argued with a neighbor over where a fence starts or how long a trash can can sit on the curb, the "lit up" rivalry hits surprisingly close to home.
💡 You might also like: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
Why This Sequel Broke the Traditional Hallmark Mold
Most Hallmark movies follow a rigid "Hero's Journey" involving a dead spouse, a struggling small business, or a corporate promotion that requires moving to a big city. Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up ignores almost all of that.
It’s a comedy first.
Director Maclain Nelson seems to have given the cast permission to go broader than usual. Melissa Peterman, who plays Pamela, is a force of nature in this. She’s loud. She’s wearing sweaters that probably weigh 20 pounds. She’s exactly the kind of person who makes the holidays both exhausting and memorable.
The sequel also avoids the "will they, won't they" trope. Since Emily and Jared are already a couple, the conflict has to come from the outside. This is a much more mature way to handle a sequel. Instead of manufacturing a breakup over a misunderstanding—which we've all seen a million times—the movie focuses on how they handle stress together. It’s actually kinda sweet, amidst all the neon LEDs.
Production Details and the Utah Connection
Interestingly, this wasn't filmed in a snowy New England village. Like many Hallmark productions, it was filmed in Utah during the warmer months. If you look closely at the background of some scenes, you can tell the "snow" is mostly blankets and foam. This is a common industry secret, but for Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up, the artificiality almost adds to the charm. The neighborhood is supposed to look like a curated, artificial wonderland.
The costume department deserves a shoutout here. The sheer volume of Christmas finery is staggering. We aren't just talking about a couple of red scarves. We are talking about coordinated outfits, themed hats, and accessories that probably required their own trailer.
📖 Related: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
The Evolution of the Hallmark Cinematic Universe
We are seeing a shift. The network is leaning into "meta" humor. They know we know the tropes. By leaning into the absurdity of the "lit up" lifestyle, they are rewarding the long-time fans who have watched every Lacey Chabert movie since Party of Five.
Critics sometimes dismiss these films as "fluff," but there is a specific skill in creating something that is consistently comforting. Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up succeeds because it doesn't try to be Citizen Kane. It tries to be the visual equivalent of a peppermint mocha. It’s sweet, maybe a little too much sugar, but exactly what you asked for.
Breaking Down the Competition
In the film, the arrival of the Johnsons (played by Seth Morris and Jennifer Aspen) triggers a "decoration war." This is where the movie really finds its legs.
- The Scale: We're talking synchronized music, projection mapping, and enough electricity to dim the lights in the next county.
- The Strategy: Emily and Jared have to decide if they want to stoop to that level or maintain the "classy" standards of Evergreen Lane.
- The Result: Pure, unadulterated holiday chaos.
Honestly, the movie is a bit of a satire on American consumerism, even if it doesn't mean to be. The obsession with having the best house on the block is a very specific kind of middle-class anxiety.
How to Watch and What to Look For
If you're planning a watch party, you should pay attention to the background gags. The production designers hid a lot of small details in the various yards. There are nods to the first film and hidden "Easter eggs" that eagle-eyed fans will appreciate.
Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up is currently available through the Hallmark Channel and their streaming service, Hallmark Movies Now. It’s often part of the "Countdown to Christmas" rotation, which basically runs on a loop from October to January.
👉 See also: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
Is it better than the first one? Honestly, it’s just different. The first one was about belonging; the second one is about defending your turf. Both have their merits.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Own Holiday Decorating
Watching the rivalry in the movie might actually give you some ideas (or warnings) for your own home. If you want to get "lit up" without starting a war with your neighbors, consider these steps:
- Check Local Ordinances Early: Don't wait until you've hung 10,000 lights to find out your city has a "light pollution" statute. It happens more often than you'd think.
- Use LED Everything: The movie shows massive displays, but in the real world, the power bill for old-school incandescent bulbs would be astronomical. LEDs stay cool and save money.
- Coordinate with Neighbors: Instead of a "war," try a "theme." Some of the best-looking streets are the ones where everyone agrees on a color palette or a style of wreath.
- Timers are Essential: Don't be the person whose lights are still screaming at 3:00 AM. Use smart plugs or mechanical timers to shut everything down by midnight.
- Focus on "Safe" Scale: If you don't have a professional crew (like the Jolly Johnsons), keep your displays manageable. Falling off a ladder is a very un-Hallmark way to spend your December.
The real takeaway from Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up isn't about the lights at all. It's about community. Even when the neighbors are annoying, and even when the HOA rules are stifling, there’s something valuable about being part of a group that cares about something—even if that something is just making sure the plastic reindeer are all facing the same direction.
Next time you see a house that looks like it can be seen from space, don't just roll your eyes. Think about the effort, the tape, the tangled wires, and the sheer enthusiasm that went into it. That's the spirit the movie captures. It’s messy, it’s bright, and it’s a little bit crazy.
For those looking to dive deeper into the world of Evergreen Lane, watching the two films back-to-back is the way to go. You can really see the character arc for Emily as she goes from a Christmas skeptic to the primary defender of the neighborhood's festive honor. It’s a journey we can all relate to, even if our own decorations are just a single string of lights and a tired-looking wreath on the front door.
Stay festive. Stay lit. Just don't let the HOA catch you with unapproved lawn ornaments.
Next Steps for Hallmark Fans
To truly appreciate the evolution of the "Haul Out the Holly" franchise, start by re-watching the original 2022 film to catch all the recurring character jokes. Then, check the current Hallmark Channel schedule for "Lit Up" airings, as they often host "double feature" nights during the winter season. Finally, if you're feeling inspired, look up "synchronized holiday light controllers" to see how the technology used in the movie actually works in a residential setting—it's more accessible than you might think.