If you’ve spent any amount of time in the weirder corners of the internet, you’ve probably seen the memes. It's usually a grainy image of a green hat behind bars or a clickbait headline screaming about a prison sentence for everyone's favorite younger brother. Honestly, it's a bit exhausting. People keep asking, has Luigi been convicted, as if the plumber is currently sitting in a cold cell in the Mushroom Kingdom awaiting trial for tax evasion or worse.
The short answer is no. Luigi is a fictional character owned by Nintendo. He doesn't have a social security number, he doesn't pay taxes, and he certainly hasn't stood before a judge.
👉 See also: Ohio Evening Pick 3: Why Most Players Keep Losing (and How to Fix It)
But why does this keep coming up? Where did the "Criminal Luigi" lore actually start? It’s a mix of bizarre internet creepypasta, accidental glitches, and a very specific brand of humor that loves to turn the most innocent characters into hardened felons. When you look at the sheer volume of search traffic around this topic, it’s clear that the line between "video game trivia" and "internet prank" has blurred for a lot of younger fans.
The "Luigi's Mansion" Theory and the Death Row Rumors
A huge chunk of the "convicted" rumors stems from a misunderstanding of the Luigi’s Mansion series. There was a long-standing urban legend—totally debunked by Nintendo, by the way—that the entire mansion was a purgatory or a prison. Some fans went so far as to suggest that Luigi was being punished for crimes committed in the "real world" before he arrived in the Mushroom Kingdom.
It’s dark. It’s weird. It’s also completely made up.
Then you have the 2014 "Luigi Death Stare" from Mario Kart 8. Remember that? When Luigi passes an opponent, he gives them this icy, murderous look that became a global sensation. It was funny because it was so out of character. However, the internet did what the internet does: it took a funny animation and built a criminal profile around it. Suddenly, people were making YouTube documentaries (parodies, obviously) about his "violent tendencies" and his "impending arrest."
If you're looking for a legal record, you won't find one. You’ll just find a lot of very creative Photoshop work.
Real-World Legal Scuffles Involving the Name Luigi
Sometimes, the confusion isn't about the pixelated guy in the green overalls at all. In the real world, there have been several high-profile legal cases involving people named Luigi.
Take, for example, Luigi "Baby Shacks" Manocchio. He was a high-ranking member of the Patriarca crime family in Rhode Island. He was actually convicted and sentenced to prison in 2012 for his role in an extortion plot involving strip clubs. If someone is scanning news headlines and sees "Luigi Convicted of Racketeering," they might—if they aren't paying close attention—let their brain jump to the Nintendo character.
There’s also the case of Luigi Di Maio, the Italian politician. While he hasn't been "convicted" in the way the memes suggest, he's been at the center of countless legal and political controversies in Italy. When you combine international news with the chaotic SEO of the 2020s, keywords get tangled. A search for "Luigi legal news" might bring up a mix of Italian politics, Rhode Island mob history, and Nintendo fan theories.
The Tax Evasion Meme: Why Luigi?
You've probably seen the "Yoshi Commits Tax Evasion" meme. It started on Tumblr and exploded on Twitter. For some reason, the internet decided that the Mario cast are all white-collar criminals. While Yoshi is the primary target of this joke, Luigi often gets dragged in as an accomplice.
The joke is basically: "He's too nice, he must be hiding something."
There is no "Tax Evasion" level in Super Mario World. There is no court transcript in Super Mario Odyssey. It is a 100% fabricated internet trope. Yet, because of how Google’s "People Also Ask" boxes work, the more people joke about it, the more the algorithm thinks it’s a legitimate question. This creates a feedback loop where people search has Luigi been convicted because they saw a meme, and then they see more memes because they searched for it.
The Role of Fan Games and "Creepypastas"
We have to talk about the "L is Real 2401" era. For decades, players were obsessed with the idea that Luigi was hidden in Super Mario 64. This obsession eventually morphed into a subculture of "haunted" Mario games.
In some of these fan-made horror games, Luigi is depicted as a villain or a fugitive. In L is Real or Corrupt Mario hacks, creators often write backstories where Luigi has snapped and committed crimes. These are often written so convincingly (in a creepy, "found footage" sort of way) that younger players mistake them for actual Nintendo lore.
- The "Shadow" Luigi: In Super Mario Galaxy, you have Cosmic Luigi, which some fans interpreted as a "dark" version of the hero.
- The Marriage Mystery: There were weird rumors about Luigi’s "illegal" marriage in certain regions, which were actually just mistranslations of Japanese manuals.
- The Mario Party Lawsuit: This is the only time "legal" and "Mario" actually met in a serious way. In the original Mario Party, the mini-games caused literal physical blisters on players' hands. Nintendo had to provide protective gloves as part of a settlement with the New York Attorney General. Luigi was on the box, but he wasn't the one on trial.
Sorting Fact from Fandom
When we look at the official Nintendo timeline, Luigi is a hero. He has saved Mario multiple times. He has a high-rise real estate portfolio (if you count the mansions he’s inherited/cleared of ghosts). He is a professional athlete in at least a dozen sports.
If you are looking for evidence of a conviction, it simply does not exist within the canon.
Even in the Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023), Luigi is portrayed as a nervous but hardworking plumber from Brooklyn. He gets detained by Bowser, sure, but that’s a kidnapping, not a legal arrest. Being a "prisoner of war" in the Dark Lands is significantly different from being convicted of a crime in a court of law.
Why Does This Matter for SEO and Fact-Checking?
We live in an era of "Deep Lore" and "Alternative Facts." When a search query like has Luigi been convicted gains traction, it highlights a flaw in how we consume information. We often prioritize the "fun" answer over the "true" one.
Expert gaming journalists from outlets like IGN or Kotaku have spent years debunking these kinds of myths, but they persist because they are entertaining. It’s way more fun to think Luigi is a secret fugitive than to accept he’s just a fictional guy who likes jumping.
Actionable Steps for Navigating Video Game Myths
If you're a parent or a fan trying to figure out what's real, here is how you can verify "facts" about fictional characters without getting sucked into a meme-hole:
Check the Official Source First Nintendo’s official character biographies are surprisingly detailed. If a character had a criminal record, it wouldn't be hidden in a random Reddit thread; it would be part of the game's marketing or instruction manual.
Look for the "Know Your Meme" Page If a story about a character sounds too weird to be true, it's probably a meme. Know Your Meme tracks the origin of these jokes. You’ll likely find that the "Luigi Conviction" story started on a Discord server or a 4chan board as a "shitpost."
Distinguish Between Lore and Creepypasta Lore is what the creators put in the game. Creepypasta is what fans write to be scary. If the "evidence" involves a blurry screenshot or a "friend of a friend who worked at Nintendo," it’s fake. Always.
Verify Real-World Names If you see a headline about "Luigi" being arrested, check the last name. As we saw with Luigi Manocchio, real people share names with fictional icons. Don't let a shared name fool you into thinking Mario's brother is heading to Sing Sing.
The reality is that Luigi is safe. He’s not in jail. He hasn't been convicted of anything. He’s likely just waiting for his next chance to outshine his brother in a game of tennis or a race around Rainbow Road. Stop worrying about his legal status and start worrying about his "A-button" timing. That’s where the real stakes are.