You're standing in the backyard. It’s drizzling. You’ve said "sit" fourteen times, and your Beagle is just... staring at a blade of grass. Or maybe he’s tracking a scent from a squirrel that was there three days ago. You start wondering if he’s deaf. He’s not. He just doesn’t see the point in sitting when there are smells to be smelled.
Let's be real. Calling them the hardest dogs to train is kind of a misnomer. Most of these breeds are actually geniuses. The problem isn't their IQ; it’s their motivation. They aren't like Golden Retrievers who live for your approval. These dogs have their own agendas. They're independent. Sometimes, they're just plain bored with your repetitive drills.
Training a dog is basically a negotiation. With some breeds, you’re negotiating with a partner who wants to please you. With others, you’re negotiating with a high-powered defense attorney who wants to see the contract, the bonus structure, and the exit clause before they even think about "shaking a paw."
The "What's In It For Me?" Brigade
Some dogs were bred to work miles away from humans. Think about a Great Pyrenees. This dog was literally designed to sit on a mountain in the middle of the night, alone, and decide whether a wolf is a threat. If you tell a Pyrenees to "down" while he’s busy scanning the perimeter for coyotes, he’s going to ignore you. Why? Because in his mind, his job is more important than your trick.
It’s about independence.
Stanley Coren, a professor of canine psychology at the University of British Columbia, famously ranked breeds by "working intelligence." His 1994 book The Intelligence of Dogs is still the gold standard, even if it makes some owners pretty salty. He found that breeds like the Afghan Hound and the Basenji required more than 80 to 100 repetitions to even start understanding a new command. Compare that to a Border Collie that gets it in five.
The Afghan Hound: The Cat in a Dog Suit
If you want a dog that acts like a dog, don't get an Afghan. They are breathtakingly beautiful and incredibly aloof. Honestly, they’re more like supermodels who don't do "manual labor." Because they are sighthounds, they are hardwired to chase anything that moves. Once that instinct kicks in, your voice becomes background noise. You’re basically yelling at a Ferrari while it's doing 60 mph.
The Basenji: The "Barkless" Rebel
Basenjis are fascinating because they don't bark—they yodel. They’re also famously difficult to train because they are intensely curious and easily distracted. They have a cat-like grooming habit and a cat-like attitude toward authority. If a Basenji decides they don't want to do something, they simply won't. No amount of yelling helps; it actually makes them tune you out faster.
💡 You might also like: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like
Why Hounds Give Trainers Nightmares
Bloodhounds, Beagles, and Basset Hounds. The "nose" breeds.
When a Bloodhound hits a scent trail, the rest of the world ceases to exist. Their ears actually help sweep scents toward their nose. It’s a physical immersion. This makes them some of the hardest dogs to train in a traditional sense because you are competing with millions of years of evolutionary programming.
You can have the best steak in the world in your hand. If that Basset Hound smells a rabbit that crossed the driveway an hour ago, that steak is invisible.
Training these dogs requires a massive shift in perspective. You can’t fight the nose. You have to work with it. Short sessions are key. Like, really short. Five minutes. Then let them sniff. If you try to do a 30-minute obedience class in a park with these guys, you’re going to leave crying, and the dog is going to leave with a very clear understanding of every squirrel's GPS coordinates in a three-block radius.
The Primitive Breed Problem
Then you have the "primitive" types. Huskies, Malamutes, Chow Chows.
Siberian Huskies are a classic example of a dog that people buy because they look cool in Game of Thrones and then surrender to a shelter six months later because the dog ate a couch. Huskies are pack-oriented but incredibly independent. They were bred to run for hundreds of miles. They have "opinions." If you tell a Husky to do something, they often talk back. Literally. They howl and "woo-woo" at you because they’re debating the command.
They are also escape artists. A Husky doesn't see a six-foot fence as a boundary; they see it as a challenge. Training them isn't just about "sit" and "stay"; it’s about providing enough mental and physical exhaustion that they don't have the energy to reinvent the layout of your living room.
📖 Related: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
The Chow Chow: The One-Person Wall
Chows are dignified. They’re also suspicious. Unlike a Lab that wants to be everyone’s best friend, a Chow is naturally wary of strangers. This makes socialization—a key part of training—extremely difficult. If you don't get it right in the first four months, you’ll have a dog that is incredibly hard to manage in public. They aren't "bad"; they’re protective and discerning. But that looks like "stubbornness" to the average owner.
It's Not Them, It's the Method
Most people fail with the hardest dogs to train because they use "one size fits all" methods.
Force doesn't work with these breeds. If you try to bully an Akita or a Bulldog into submission, they will either shut down or push back. Bulldogs, for instance, are actually quite sensitive. They might look like tough little tanks, but if you’re too harsh, they’ll just sit down and refuse to budge. Good luck moving 50 pounds of solid, uncooperative muscle.
Positive reinforcement is the only way, but even then, you have to be smarter than the dog.
You have to find their "currency." For some, it’s a specific high-value treat (we’re talking liver or stinky cheese, not dry biscuits). For others, it’s a toy. For the sighthounds, the reward might actually be getting to go for a "zoomie" after doing a task.
The Role of Genetics in Frustration
We have to talk about the "Terrier Temperament."
Jack Russells and Bull Terriers were bred to go into holes and fight things. That requires a level of tenacity that borders on insanity. When a Terrier is focused on a "prey" item—even if that item is your socks—they are in a zone. Training a Terrier involves managing their high arousal levels. They get "over-excited" easily. When a dog's brain is vibrating with excitement, they literally cannot process the word "stay."
👉 See also: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
It’s like trying to teach someone calculus while they’re riding a roller coaster.
Akitas and the "Quiet Force"
Akitas are Japanese treasures, but they are not for the faint of heart. They are incredibly loyal to their family but can be dominant and aggressive toward other dogs. Training an Akita is a lifelong commitment. You don't "finish" training them. You maintain a relationship of mutual respect. If that respect slips, the dog takes over the household.
Surprising Entry: The Chihuahua?
People laugh when I say Chihuahuas are among the hardest dogs to train.
The issue here is "Small Dog Syndrome." Because they’re tiny, owners let them get away with murder. They growl, they snap, they guard the sofa, and people think it’s cute. But Chihuahuas are feisty and incredibly smart. They learn very quickly that if they act out, the human will stop bothering them. This "rewards" the bad behavior.
They’re also notoriously hard to housebreak. Their bladders are the size of a walnut, and if it’s raining outside, they’d much rather pee behind your curtains than get their paws wet. That’s not a lack of intelligence; that’s a very logical preference for comfort.
How to Actually Succeed with "Difficult" Breeds
If you own one of these breeds, stop looking for "obedience." Start looking for "cooperation."
- Ditch the boredom. If you’re training a Poodle, you can do ten reps of "sit." If you’re training a Borzoi, do two. If they do it well, throw a party and move on. If you keep asking, they’ll get bored and wander off.
- Management is half the battle. If your dog is a scent hound, don't train them in a field full of clover and rabbits. Start in your hallway. Then the garage. Then the driveway. You have to build up to the distractions.
- Professional help is okay. Sometimes you need a trainer who specializes in "primitive" or "independent" breeds. A trainer who only works with Shepherds might not understand the nuances of a Shiba Inu.
- Accept the personality. You bought an independent dog. Don't be mad when they act independent. Embrace the quirks. A Beagle who follows a scent is just being a "good" Beagle.
Actionable Steps for the "Un-trainable" Dog
Stop thinking of your dog as "bad" or "dumb." They are likely just specialized.
- Audit your treats: If you’re using standard store-bought treats, you're losing the negotiation. Try boiled chicken, salmon skin, or freeze-dried tripe.
- Shorten the clock: Limit formal training to three minutes at a time, several times a day.
- Identify the trigger: Is your dog failing because they don't know the command, or because they're scared/distracted/bored? You can't train through fear.
- Check the exercise levels: A tired dog is a teachable dog. This is especially true for Huskies and Terriers. If they haven't burned off that physical edge, their brain is too busy to listen to you.
- Use a long line: For breeds with high prey drive (Akitas, Huskies, Hounds), never trust "off-leash" recall training in an un-fenced area. Use a 30-foot training lead so they have freedom but you have safety.
Training a "difficult" dog is ultimately a masterclass in patience and human psychology. It forces you to become a better communicator. When that "stubborn" dog finally looks you in the eye and decides to follow your lead, it’s a much more rewarding feeling than any easy win with a "perfect" breed. It’s a partnership built on earned respect, not just blind following.