He was the bachelor who wouldn't settle. For two decades, Derek Jeter was the face of the New York Yankees and the most elusive prize in Manhattan's dating scene. Then came a quiet introduction in a New York restaurant in 2012, and everything shifted.
Most people assume Hannah Davis was just another name on a long list of A-list stars that included Mariah Carey and Minka Kelly. Honestly, they couldn't be more wrong. Hannah wasn't a fan. She didn't even know he was a legendary shortstop; she actually thought he was a pitcher when they first met. That lack of "superstar" baggage is basically the secret sauce that turned a casual introduction into a decade-long marriage.
The Meet-Cute Most People Miss
It wasn't a red carpet. It wasn't a high-stakes charity gala either. Derek and Hannah met through a mutual friend at a restaurant in NYC. Hannah was there with her mother, of all people. At the time, Derek was 39 and coming off a major breakup. Hannah was a 22-year-old model from St. Thomas who was much more interested in the beach than the box score.
Timing is everything.
They started dating in 2012, but they kept things incredibly low-key. You’ve got to remember that Jeter was the king of privacy. He had a "no phones" rule at his parties and rarely spoke about his personal life to the press. Hannah fit right into that world. She wasn't looking for the spotlight that came with "The Captain."
🔗 Read more: Neil deGrasse Tyson and Alice Young: Why Their Quiet Relationship Still Matters
Why Hannah Davis and Derek Jeter Keep It Private
In a world where every celebrity couple is fighting for engagement on Instagram, the Jeters are a total anomaly. Hannah has been very vocal about why she doesn't post photos of their kids' faces or share every intimate dinner. To her, when you love something that much, you protect it.
The couple got engaged in 2015. They didn't even make a big announcement; Derek just casually referred to her as his "fiancée" in a blog post on The Players’ Tribune about their dog, Kane. That's just how they roll. They tied the knot in July 2016 at the Meadowood Napa Valley Resort in California. It was intimate, elegant, and—true to form—very private.
The "Girl Dad" Era and a Surprise Addition
For years, Derek was the ultimate "girl dad." The couple has three daughters: Bella Raine (born 2017), Story Grey (born 2019), and River Rose (born 2021).
If you saw Derek on The Tonight Show a couple of years back, he joked about "controlled chaos." He’s gone from winning five World Series rings to getting his fingernails painted and wearing lipstick during tea parties. It’s a wild transformation for a guy who spent 20 years in the most high-pressure clubhouse in sports.
Then, in May 2023, they threw everyone a curveball. They welcomed their fourth child, a son named Kaius Green Jeter.
📖 Related: Bill Belichick Girlfriend: What Most People Get Wrong About Jordon Hudson
Life in 2026: Business and Balance
As of early 2026, the Jeter empire is bigger than ever, but the focus has shifted entirely to legacy and family. Derek has moved on from his executive role with the Miami Marlins, which ended in 2022, and is now leaning heavily into his broadcasting role with Fox Sports and his business ventures like Arena Club.
Hannah, while she has stepped back from the grueling schedule of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit days, is still a major force in the fashion and business world. The couple's combined net worth is estimated to be around $210 million.
What's really interesting is how they've handled the "post-fame" life. They aren't chasing the cameras. Instead, they’re raising four kids in Florida and New York, focusing on the Turn 2 Foundation, and occasionally showing up at the Met Gala looking like they haven't aged a day since 2012.
What Most People Get Wrong
People think it was a "trophy" situation. It wasn't.
Hannah’s upbringing in the U.S. Virgin Islands gave her a grounded perspective that Derek desperately needed after twenty years in the New York media meat grinder. She isn't just "the wife"; she’s the one who kept him human when he retired from the only life he ever knew.
If you’re looking for a blueprint on how to handle fame without letting it ruin your life, this is it.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out the Turn 2 Foundation: If you want to see what they actually care about, look at their philanthropic work helping youth avoid drug and alcohol addiction.
- Watch "The Captain" on ESPN/Disney+: For a real look at how their relationship began during his final years in pinstripes, the documentary offers rare footage of their early days.
- Follow The Players' Tribune: This remains the primary source for any actual news the family decides to share on their own terms.