You're halfway through a run in the Haunted Caverns and your build feels like it's hitting a brick wall. The skeletons are closing in, your damage is falling off, and you're wondering if you just got bad RNG on your traits. But honestly? You probably just ignored the most powerful mechanic in the game. Most people see the Halls of Torment potions as a side quest or a minor buff system, but they are actually the difference between a failed run and a 30-minute slaughter where you're basically untouchable.
It’s easy to miss. The game doesn't hold your hand through the process of finding the Cupbearer or hunting down weird herbs in the dirt. But if you want to push into the higher Agony tiers or finally take down the Lord of Pain without sweating, you need to master the bottle.
Stop Ignoring the Cupbearer
Before you can even think about mixing a brew, you have to find the guy. He’s trapped in the Viaduct. If you haven't rescued him yet, that should be your only priority. Once he's back at the camp, he becomes your best friend. He’s the gatekeeper to your permanent power curve.
The system is deeper than just "click a button, get a buff." You have to find ingredients. These aren't just handed to you. You’re looking for things like Fire Fern, Copper Shards, and Dragon Nettle hidden in the various stages. Some players get frustrated because they can’t find a specific herb, but it’s usually because they aren't looking at the right time. Most of these ingredients have specific spawn conditions or locations within the maps.
Why Your Build Feels Weak
If you’re just picking traits randomly, you’re playing on hard mode. The real meta involves using the Strong Wine or the Reverberating Potion to force the game to give you what you actually need.
Think about it.
How many times have you been looking for a specific Weapon Proficiency or a certain Mastery trait, only for the game to offer you three things you don't want? That's where the Potion of Oblivion comes in. It doesn't just "skip" a choice; it permanently removes those junk traits from the pool for that entire run. By the end of the game, you’ve thinned the deck so much that every single level-up is a massive power spike. It's essentially card-counting for an ARPG.
📖 Related: Why Titanfall 2 Pilot Helmets Are Still the Gold Standard for Sci-Fi Design
The Most Important Halls of Torment Potions Explained
Let's get into the specifics. Not every bottle in your inventory is worth the effort, but there are a few that are absolutely non-negotiable for high-level play.
The Potion of Memories is the MVP here. Honestly, if you aren't using this, you're leaving damage on the table. It allows you to "lock in" a trait so you can pick it again later. This is how people end up with insane stacks of Multihit or Attack Speed that seem impossible. It lets you double down on your best traits. If you find a Tier IV trait that changes your entire build, you use a memory potion to ensure you can grab its subsequent upgrades without praying to the RNG gods.
Then there is the Potion of Reverberation. This one is a bit more nuanced. It doubles the effect of the trait you just picked. Use this on a flat damage increase? It’s okay. Use it on a percentage-based scaling trait like Cunning or Force? Now you’re talking about exponential growth. This is how you get those screen-clearing effects where the enemies die before they even enter the light radius.
Getting More Bottles
You start with almost nothing. It feels bad. You go into a run, you have one or two uses, and then you’re out. To fix this, you have to find the empty flasks hidden in the world.
- Go to the Frozen Wastelands.
- Look for the specific quest markers or environmental clues.
- Don't leave until you've checked the corners.
The more flasks you have, the more "cheating" you can do during a run. By the time you have 5 or 6 of each type, the game's difficulty basically evaporates. You're no longer at the mercy of the dice; you're the one in control of the deck.
The Herb Hunt: Where to Actually Look
Finding the ingredients for your Halls of Torment potions is where most players drop the ball. They run around in circles hoping to stumble onto a plant. Don't do that.
👉 See also: Sex Fallout New Vegas: Why Obsidian’s Writing Still Outshines Modern RPGs
For instance, the Saffron is usually tucked away in the Chamber of Dissonance. You’re looking for a small, yellowish sprout. The Fly Agaric? That’s in the Haunted Caverns. It’s a red mushroom. It sounds simple, but when you have five thousand skeletons trying to eat your face, it’s easy to run right past a legendary crafting ingredient.
You need to keep an eye on the edges of the screen. The herbs have a slight glow or a distinct sprite that sets them apart from the background rubble. Once you pick them up, they’re gone from the map for that run, but they get added to your permanent stash at the Cupbearer. You only need to find them once to unlock the recipe, but you need to keep finding them to replenish your stock if you're burning through potions every run.
The Math of the Brew
Let’s talk about the Potion of Oblivion again because it’s the most misunderstood tool in the shed. People think it’s a waste because you aren't "gaining" a stat.
Mathematically, that’s wrong.
By removing a weak trait—let's say a basic health regen trait when you're running a glass cannon build—you increase the statistical probability of the game rolling a Tier IV damage trait on your next level. In a game that lasts 30 minutes, you might get 60 to 100 level-ups. If you use 5 Oblivion potions early, you’ve filtered out 5 "bad" options from every single subsequent roll. That is hundreds of "better" rolls over the course of a single session.
Advanced Strategies for Potion Buffs
If you really want to min-max, you have to look at the Strong Wine. This isn't just for a quick heal. It interacts with your health pool in ways that can trigger certain items or character abilities.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026
Some characters, like the Barbarian or the Shield Maiden, have mechanics that scale with their current health or their missing health. Using a potion at the wrong time can actually lower your DPS if you aren't careful. On the flip side, using a Potion of Transformation (if you've unlocked the more exotic recipes) can completely shift your defensive stats into offensive ones for a short window.
Common Mistakes
- Using Potions Too Early: Don't burn your Potion of Memories on a Tier I trait. Wait for the big ones.
- Hoarding: Don't finish a run with a full belt of potions. If you're about to fight the boss and you have three Oblivion charges left, use them on any junk that pops up to ensure your final levels are pure power.
- Ignoring the Map: If you see a green leaf icon on your mini-map (if you have the right items equipped), stop what you are doing and go get it. Those herbs are more valuable than the gold you're farming.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Meta
The biggest misconception is that potions are "extra." They aren't. In the current patch of Halls of Torment, the developers have balanced the late-game Agony levels under the assumption that the player is using every tool available.
If you try to beat the higher difficulties without using your Halls of Torment potions, you aren't just playing a challenge mode; you're ignoring a core pillar of the character progression. It’s like trying to play a classic RPG without ever putting on armor. Sure, you can do it, but why would you make it that hard on yourself?
The Cupbearer’s Quests
Pay attention to the specific tasks the Cupbearer gives you. Sometimes he wants you to find a specific item or reach a certain milestone. Completing these usually rewards you with better efficiency—meaning you get more "bang for your buck" out of every herb you bring back.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Run
To get the most out of your alchemy setup right now, follow this sequence. It works regardless of your character choice.
- Prioritize the Viaduct: If the Cupbearer isn't in your camp, go get him. Now. He’s usually found in the northern sections of the map, guarded by a specific encounter.
- Equip the Gatherer’s Charm: If you have it, this item makes finding herbs significantly easier. It’s a game-changer for filling out your recipe book quickly.
- Focus on Oblivion First: When starting a run, use your first few potions to delete the traits you know you don't want. This cleans up the RNG for the rest of the 30 minutes.
- Save Memories for Tier IV: Only use your Potion of Memories on the highest tier of a trait or on a weapon evolution that is core to your build.
- Check the Stash: Before you head into a map, check which herbs you’re low on. Target the specific map that spawns those herbs. If you need Fire Fern, go to the Ember Grounds. It’s that simple.
Stop treating the potion system like a luxury. It’s the engine that drives the mid-to-late game. Once you start aggressively thinning your trait pool and doubling your best buffs, those "impossible" boss fights become total victory laps.