Christmas movies are usually about the cookies. Or the snow. Or that one specific scene where the protagonist realizes they've been dating a corporate jerk and should instead be with the guy who owns the local hardware store. But Five Gold Rings—one of the standout titles from Hallmark’s 2024 "Miracle of Christmas" lineup on Hallmark Mystery—takes a slightly different path. It's less about the tinsel and more about the heavy lifting of grief.
If you’ve spent any time on the Hallmark Channel, you know the drill. However, this specific film, starring Jodie Sweetin and Holland Roden, hit a chord that most holiday fluff misses. It’s a scavenger hunt. Literally.
When Audrey (played by Roden) returns home to fulfill her late grandmother’s final wish, she’s tasked with returning five mysterious gold rings to their rightful owners before Christmas Eve. It sounds like a standard plot device. It isn’t. Or well, it is, but the way it’s executed feels more like a real conversation about legacy than a scripted commercial for ornaments.
Why Five Gold Rings Stuck With Audiences
People search for this movie because of the mystery, sure. But honestly? They stay for the sisters. The dynamic between Audrey and Kendra (Sweetin) isn't that perfect, "we never fought as children" trope that makes you want to roll your eyes. It feels lived-in.
The movie deals with the specific, sharp pain of the first holiday after a major loss. That’s a real thing. Psychologists often talk about the "anniversary effect," where grief spikes during milestones. By centering the plot of Five Gold Rings on a dead grandmother’s unfinished business, Hallmark actually tapped into a very human reality: we use tasks to avoid feeling the void. Audrey isn’t just looking for jewelry. She’s looking for a way to say goodbye without having to actually say the words.
The Scavenger Hunt as a Narrative Engine
Structure matters. Most holiday films are linear. Boy meets girl, they hate each other, they bake a pie, they kiss under mistletoe.
Five Gold Rings uses a quest.
✨ Don't miss: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
This isn't just a gimmick. Each ring represents a different facet of her grandmother’s life that the sisters didn't know about. It’s a clever way to build a world without doing a massive "info dump" at the beginning of the film. We learn about the grandmother as they do. We see the impact she had on her community through the eyes of the people receiving the rings.
One of the owners is a local shopkeeper. Another is a distant relative. Each encounter adds a layer of complexity to the family history. It’s about the "small-town interconnectedness" that Hallmark loves, but it’s grounded in the idea that we never truly know our parents or grandparents as full people—only as the roles they played for us.
The Cast and the Chemistry
Jodie Sweetin is a veteran here. You know her from Full House, obviously, but she’s become a cornerstone of the Hallmark ecosystem because she feels accessible. She doesn't have that "plastic" energy. Holland Roden, coming over from Teen Wolf fame, brings a slightly more guarded, intellectual vibe to Audrey.
The contrast works.
And then there’s the leading man, Nolan Gerard Funk. He plays Finn, the local private investigator (because of course there’s a PI). The romance is there, but it’s secondary to the family mystery. That’s a pivot Hallmark has been making lately—focusing on E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) in their storytelling. They want stories that feel like they come from a place of real emotional experience.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Hallmark Five Gold Rings Plot
There is a common misconception that these movies are written by robots. People think it’s just a Mad Libs style "City Girl + Country Boy + Christmas Tree = Profit."
🔗 Read more: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
But look at the specifics.
The film was directed by Maclain Nelson and written by a team that clearly understood the "quest" archetype. It’s not just about the rings. It’s about the reasons they were gone in the first place. Without spoiling the ending for those who missed the 2024 premiere, the "mystery" isn't some grand conspiracy. It’s a series of small, human errors and quiet sacrifices.
That’s the secret sauce.
In a world of high-stakes streaming thrillers, there is something deeply settling about a movie where the biggest conflict is whether or not a ring can be returned to a woman who lost it forty years ago. It’s low-stakes for the world, but high-stakes for the heart.
Real-World Locations and the "Vibe"
If you're wondering where they filmed it—because Hallmark fans always want to know if they can visit the town—it was largely shot in British Columbia, Canada. Specifically around the Vancouver and Maple Ridge areas.
These locations are used because they have that "anytime, anywhere" North American aesthetic. But the production design in Five Gold Rings deserves a nod. They avoided the neon-red and bright-green overload. The palette is muted. It’s cozy. It looks like a place where people actually live, not a set decorated by a professional elf.
💡 You might also like: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
The Evolution of the Hallmark Mystery Brand
Five Gold Rings falls under the "Hallmark Mystery" umbrella (formerly Hallmark Movies & Mysteries). This is an important distinction. The "Mystery" side of the brand tends to be a bit more somber. The lighting is different. The stakes involve puzzles.
This film represents the "New Hallmark."
Since the leadership changes a few years ago, the network has been pushing for more diverse stories and more complex emotional arcs. They aren't just selling a fantasy anymore; they’re trying to reflect the actual holiday experience—which, for many, includes a fair amount of "blue Christmas" energy.
The film addresses the "empty chair" at the table. It doesn't pretend that a new boyfriend fixes the fact that your grandmother is gone. It suggests that honoring a legacy is a way to bridge that gap.
Actionable Takeaways for the Holiday Season
You don’t have to have a dead grandmother with a secret jewelry collection to take something away from this film.
- Audit your heirlooms. Most of us have boxes of stuff that "meant something" to someone. Take an afternoon to actually write down the stories behind them.
- The 24-hour rule. In the movie, the deadline is Christmas Eve. If you have a difficult conversation you’ve been putting off or a "thank you" you haven't said, set a deadline. The urgency helps.
- Embrace the quest. If the holidays feel stagnant, create a mission. It could be finding the best hot chocolate in a 20-mile radius or visiting every local bookstore. Movement cures malaise.
- Watch for the details. Next time you watch a Hallmark Mystery, look at the background characters. The network has started planting "easter eggs" and recurring themes across their movies to reward loyal viewers.
The legacy of Five Gold Rings isn't going to be that it redefined cinema. It’s a Hallmark movie. But it might be the movie that makes someone pick up the phone and call a sister they haven't talked to in a year. Or it might just be the thing you put on while you're wrapping gifts and feeling a little bit lonely. Both are valid. Both are why these movies continue to dominate the ratings every December.
To get the most out of the experience, watch it as a double feature with The Nine Kittens of Christmas or Three Wise Men and a Baby to see the full spectrum of Hallmark's modern tone. Pay attention to the way the mystery unfolds—it's tighter than you'd expect for a holiday flick.
Next Steps for Your Holiday Binge:
- Check the Hallmark Checklist App: This is the easiest way to see when Five Gold Rings is re-airing, as they cycle these movies frequently through January.
- Look for the Soundtrack: The music in these mystery-leaning films is often more atmospheric; many of the featured acoustic tracks are available on streaming platforms.
- Research the "Miracle of Christmas" Archives: If you liked the tone of this film, look for other titles directed by Maclain Nelson, who has a knack for balancing humor with genuine sentiment.