Ever stood in that quiet, darkened room in Canton, Ohio, surrounded by those bronze busts? It’s heavy. You can almost smell the grass and the sweat. But if you're looking at a hall of fame qbs list, you'll notice something pretty quickly. It’s a lot shorter than you'd expect.
As of early 2026, the gatekeeping is real. There are only about 30 or so "pure" modern-era quarterbacks with a bust in that building. Think about that. Over a century of football, thousands of guys under center, and only a tiny handful make the cut.
We’re currently in a weird, transitional era for the Hall. The "Class of 2026" talk is heating up, and honestly, the names on the ballot right now—Drew Brees and Eli Manning—are sparking some of the loudest debates we've seen in years. It’s not just about the stats anymore. It’s about the "vibe," the rings, and whether you can tell the story of the NFL without them.
The Current State of the Hall of Fame QBs List
Getting into the Pro Football Hall of Fame is a brutal process. It’s not like baseball where you just need a certain percentage of the writers' vote over a decade. In football, you've got a selection committee that meets in a room and basically argues until smoke comes out of the chimney.
Right now, the list of primary quarterbacks in the Hall includes legends like:
✨ Don't miss: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
- The 1963 Inaugural Class: Sammy Baugh and Dutch Clark.
- The Golden Era: Joe Montana, Terry Bradshaw, Roger Staubach.
- The Stat Kings: Dan Marino, Dan Fouts, Peyton Manning.
- The Recent Inductees: Peyton Manning (2021) and the late Ken Stabler (2016).
But here’s the thing. The hall of fame qbs list isn't just a list of the "best" players. It's a list of the most impactful ones. Look at Joe Namath. His career stats? Kind of mediocre by today's standards. More interceptions than touchdowns. But he’s in. Why? Because you can’t write the history of the league without the guarantee and Super Bowl III.
Why the 2026 Class is Breaking the Internet
We are currently looking at the Class of 2026 finalists, and the quarterback room is crowded. Drew Brees is a lock. He’s first-year eligible, and with over 80,000 passing yards and a Super Bowl ring, nobody is saying no to him. He basically rebuilt New Orleans.
Then there’s Eli Manning.
People love to argue about Eli. He’s a finalist for the second time now. His regular-season record is exactly .500. He led the league in interceptions three different times. But then you look at those two rings. You look at the fact that he took down the undefeated Patriots. Twice. In the Hall of Fame world, those moments carry more weight than a random Week 4 loss to the Jaguars in 2012.
🔗 Read more: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
What Most Fans Get Wrong About the Selection
Most fans think if you have the stats, you’re in. Wrong.
If it were just about stats, Philip Rivers would be a first-ballot guy. He’s also on the 2026 ballot, but his path is way harder than Brees’. Why? No rings. No "iconic" January moments. It’s a tough pill to swallow for Chargers fans, but the committee tends to favor the guys who hoisted the Lombardi.
The hall of fame qbs list also excludes a lot of "dual-threat" pioneers who are just now getting their flowers. We’re seeing a shift where the committee is looking back at guys like Ken Anderson (a 2026 Senior finalist). For years, Anderson was the "forgotten" great QB of the 70s and 80s. He had the highest passer rating in the league when nobody knew what passer rating was.
The "Senior" Savior
For the older generation, the "Senior" category is the only way left to get on the hall of fame qbs list. This is for players who have been retired for at least 25 years. This year, Ken Anderson is the name everyone is watching. If he gets in, it proves that the Hall is finally willing to look past the lack of a Super Bowl ring if the efficiency and era-adjusted stats are high enough.
💡 You might also like: NL Rookie of the Year 2025: Why Drake Baldwin Actually Deserved the Hardware
The Metrics That Actually Matter
If you’re trying to predict who’s next on the hall of fame qbs list, don’t just look at passing yards. Look at these three things:
- All-Pro Selections: This is the big one. Being a "Pro Bowler" is a popularity contest. Being an "All-Pro" means you were the best in the league that year.
- The "Eye Test" of an Era: Were you ever the "best" QB in the league for a 3-year stretch? If you played at the same time as Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Aaron Rodgers, that’s a hard "yes" to get.
- Postseason Heroics: The Hall is in Canton, but it’s built on January football.
Honestly, the bar is getting higher. With the league becoming so pass-heavy, throwing for 4,000 yards is basically the bare minimum now. In the 70s, that was god-tier. This "stat inflation" is making it harder for the committee to distinguish between a "Great" QB and a "Hall of Fame" QB.
Actionable Insights: How to Track the Next Legends
If you want to stay ahead of the curve on who's joining the hall of fame qbs list, keep an eye on these specific markers over the next few seasons:
- Watch the Senior Committee: Every August, they announce their nominees. If a name like Ken Anderson or Roman Gabriel pops up, pay attention. They are the "correction" picks for the Hall's past mistakes.
- The "Five Year" Clock: A player must be retired for five full seasons before they can be considered. Tom Brady retired (for real) after the 2022 season, which puts his first year of eligibility in 2028. Mark your calendars; that’ll be the biggest induction in history.
- Ignore the "Volume" Stats: Don't get distracted by a guy who has 50,000 yards but zero All-Pros and zero rings. They might make the "Hall of Very Good," but they won't get a bust in Canton.
- Check the Finalists in January: The Pro Football Hall of Fame usually announces the modern-era finalists in early January. This is when the real debate happens. For 2026, the finalists include Brees and Manning—expect the announcement of the actual class during the "NFL Honors" show in February.
The hall of fame qbs list is a living, breathing thing. It's not just a dusty record book. It’s a reflection of how we value the most important position in sports. Whether you think Eli Manning belongs or you're pulling for a senior legend like Ken Anderson, the debate is half the fun.
If you’re planning a trip to Canton, do it during Induction Weekend in August. Seeing the new class give those speeches—often in tears, surrounded by their peers—reminds you that while we argue about stats, for them, it’s the culmination of a lifetime of work.