You’ve probably heard it a thousand times. Maybe you’ve even muttered it under your breath when a coworker who never does their dishes finally gets written up. "They had it coming." It’s a heavy phrase. It feels definitive. But the had it coming meaning isn't just about simple cause and effect; it's a deep-seated psychological reflex about justice, karma, and sometimes, our own lack of empathy.
Basically, when we say someone "had it coming," we’re saying their current misfortune is a direct, deserved consequence of their past actions. It's the verbal equivalent of a shrug.
Words matter. Language shapes how we view the world, and this specific idiom carries a lot of baggage. It suggests that the universe has a balance sheet. If you put enough "bad" into the world, the world is eventually going to hand you a bill. But who decides when the bill is due? That's where things get complicated.
The Linguistic Roots of Deservedness
If you look at the had it coming meaning through a linguistic lens, it’s essentially a shortened version of "they had a punishment coming to them." It implies motion. Like a train traveling down a track, the consequence was already in motion the moment the bad behavior started. The collision was inevitable.
Etymologically, "coming" suggests a future event that is already scheduled. In the early 20th century, you’d see similar phrasing in noir novels and hardboiled detective stories. It’s the language of the streets and the courtroom. It’s cynical. It assumes that nobody is truly innocent and that everyone’s "tab" eventually gets collected.
We see this everywhere in pop culture. Think about the song "Cell Block Tango" from the musical Chicago. The repetitive refrain "He had it coming" is used by women who have murdered their partners. In their minds, the murder wasn't a crime; it was an inevitability. It was the only logical conclusion to the victim's "bad" behavior.
The Dark Side of "Just World" Theory
Psychologists have a name for the urge to use this phrase: The Just World Hypothesis. Melvin Lerner, a social psychologist, pioneered this research in the 1960s. He noticed that people have a desperate need to believe the world is fair.
🔗 Read more: Why the shaggy hairstyles fringe layered bob for fine hair over 50 is the only cut you actually need
We want to believe that good things happen to good people and bad things happen to bad people. Why? Because if the world is random, then something terrible could happen to us at any moment for no reason. That’s a terrifying thought. So, we look at someone else’s misfortune and find a way to blame them for it.
"They had it coming" becomes a shield.
If a person gets scammed and we say they "had it coming" because they were greedy, we feel safe. We aren't greedy, so we won't get scammed. It's a mental trick. But it's also dangerous. This is where victim-blaming starts. When we use the had it coming meaning to justify someone else's pain, we often gloss over systemic issues or genuine accidents.
When the Phrase is Actually True
Of course, sometimes people actually do have it coming.
Take a professional athlete who skips every practice, ignores their coach, and trashes their teammates in the press. When they get cut from the team, "they had it coming" is a fair assessment. It’s a logical outcome. In this context, the phrase is about accountability.
There's a difference between a natural consequence and a cruel twist of fate.
- Natural Consequence: You don't study, you fail the test.
- Twist of Fate: You study hard, but you get a flat tire on the way to the exam.
The first one fits the had it coming meaning. The second one is just bad luck. Mixing the two up is where we lose our humanity.
Why We Love "Had It Coming" in Movies
We are obsessed with "had it coming" moments in cinema. We call it "catharsis." When the villain who has been tormenting the hero for two hours finally falls off a building, the audience cheers.
Why? Because in real life, justice is slow. Sometimes it never happens at all.
Movies give us the tidy resolution we crave. In the world of fiction, the had it coming meaning is always clear-cut. The bad guy is 100% bad, and the punishment is 100% deserved. Real life is grayer. Real life is messy. People are rarely all good or all bad, which makes "having it coming" a much harder call to make.
The Social Media "Cancel Culture" Connection
In 2026, the digital landscape has changed how we use this phrase. Social media is a giant "had it coming" machine. When a celebrity is caught in a scandal, the internet descends. The phrase is used to justify dogpiling.
The problem is that the "consequence" often far outweighs the "action." If someone makes a dumb joke ten years ago and loses their entire livelihood today, did they "have it coming"? Some say yes, others say no. The definition of what constitutes "deserving" misfortune has shifted and become more aggressive.
We’ve moved from individual accountability to a sort of collective tribal punishment.
Navigating the Meaning in Your Daily Life
How should you handle this phrase when it pops into your head? Honestly, it’s worth pausing.
Next time you think someone "had it coming," ask yourself if you’re just trying to make yourself feel more secure. Are you using their failure to validate your own choices? It’s a tough question to answer honestly.
There’s a certain arrogance in the phrase. It assumes we know everything about the other person's life and the context of their mistakes.
Actionable Steps for Using the Phrase Responsibly
Instead of leaning on the "had it coming" trope, try these shifts in perspective:
- Check for bias. Are you saying it because you dislike the person? If your best friend did the same thing, would you say they "had it coming," or would you call it "a tough break"?
- Differentiate between "Deserved" and "Inevitable." Sometimes a result is inevitable due to physics or logic, but that doesn't mean the person "deserved" the emotional pain associated with it.
- Focus on the lesson, not the smugness. If a coworker fails, you can acknowledge the cause (missed deadlines) without the "told-you-so" attitude.
- Practice radical empathy. Try to see the series of events from their side. Did they have the tools to succeed? Was there a factor you didn't see?
The had it coming meaning is ultimately a tool for summarizing complex human interactions into a simple sentence. It’s convenient. It’s punchy. But it’s rarely the whole story. By looking closer at why we want people to suffer the consequences of their actions, we learn more about our own values than we do about theirs.
Understanding this idiom is about more than just vocabulary; it’s about recognizing the human urge for balance and the sometimes-cruel ways we try to find it. Use it sparingly. Use it carefully. And remember that one day, you might be the one on the other side of the phrase.