Walk into any neighborhood that boasts a "Gusto," and you’ll immediately smell that specific, yeasty perfume of dough hitting a high-heat oven. It’s intoxicating. Honestly, the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu has become a bit of a local legend in various cities, but navigating it isn't always as simple as picking the first thing you see. You've probably been there—staring at a chalkboard or a thick paper menu, wondering if the "handcrafted" tag is just marketing fluff or if there’s a genuine nonna in the back actually rolling out pappardelle by hand.
The truth is a bit more nuanced.
Most people flock to Gusto because they want something that feels a step above the fast-casual chains but doesn't require a suit and tie. It's that middle ground. It's the "I want a decent glass of Chianti and a pizza that doesn't have a stuffed crust" vibe. But if you don't know which sections of the menu to prioritize, you might end up with a standard margherita when you could have had something life-changing.
What’s Really Going on with the Dough?
The backbone of the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu is, unsurprisingly, the flour.
If you talk to the chefs—or just watch them through the open kitchen windows—you'll notice they aren't just slapping dough around. They typically use a long-fermentation process. This isn't just some culinary buzzword. When dough sits for 24 to 48 hours, the yeast has time to break down the starches. This makes the crust lighter. It makes it airier. It also makes it a lot easier on your stomach, which is why you can eat a whole pizza and not feel like you need a three-hour nap immediately afterward.
The "leopard spotting" on the crust? That’s the goal. Those little charred bubbles are a sign of a high-temperature stone oven, usually cranking at 700 degrees or more. If your pizza comes out looking like a uniform, golden-brown cracker, someone messed up. You want that contrast of crunch and chew.
The Pasta Situation: Fresh vs. Dry
There’s a common misconception that fresh pasta is always better than dry. That’s just wrong.
In a real Italian kitchen, and certainly on the Gusto menu, different sauces require different vessels. Their handcrafted fettuccine or taglioni is usually made with egg and high-protein flour, giving it a silky, rich mouthfeel that’s perfect for cream-based sauces or a simple sage and butter prep. However, if you’re looking at a spicy Arrabbiata or a hearty Putanesca, you actually want a high-quality dry pasta—specifically one extruded through bronze dies. Bronze dies leave the surface of the pasta rough and porous. That roughness is what grabs the sauce. Without it, the sauce just slides off and pools at the bottom of the bowl.
👉 See also: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
When you scan the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu, look for the specific mention of "house-made." Usually, the pappardelle and the gnocchi are the stars of the "made-from-scratch" show. The gnocchi, in particular, should be pillows. If they feel like rubber balls, they’ve been overworked.
Navigating the Pizza Variations
You basically have two camps at Gusto: the Traditionalists and the Adventurers.
The Traditionalists: These are the folks who judge a place solely on their Margherita. It’s a fair test. You can’t hide behind toppings. At Gusto, the Margherita usually features San Marzano tomatoes. These aren't your grocery store tomatoes. They grow in volcanic soil near Mount Vesuvius, which gives them a specific acidity and sweetness that you can't replicate. If the menu lists "D.O.P." next to the ingredients, pay attention. It means the ingredients are certified as authentic.
The Adventurers: This is where the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu gets weird in a good way. You’ll see things like pistachios on pizza. Or honey. Hot honey has had a massive "moment" lately, and Gusto usually leans into it with a spicy salami or soppressata pie. The salt from the meat and the heat from the honey creates a profile that’s hard to beat.
Don't ignore the white pizzas (Pizza Bianca). Without the acidity of the tomato sauce, you really get to taste the quality of the olive oil and the cheese. A mushroom and truffle oil white pizza is a heavy hitter here, though some purists think truffle oil is a scam. To be fair, most "truffle oil" is synthetic, but when mixed with roasted cremini or porcini mushrooms, it provides that earthy punch people crave.
The "Secret" to the Toppings
Ever notice how some pizzas are soggy in the middle?
That "soupy" center usually happens when a kitchen uses fresh mozzarella (fior di latte) that hasn't been properly drained. Fresh mozz has a high water content. At Gusto, they generally try to balance this by slicing it thin or using a drier "low-moisture" mozzarella for the base and topping with fresh buffalo mozzarella after the bake. If you’re sensitive to a floppy slice, maybe skip the veggie-heavy options, as mushrooms and peppers release even more water during the cooking process.
✨ Don't miss: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
Why the "Handcrafted" Label Actually Matters
Words like "handcrafted" get thrown around so much they’ve almost lost all meaning.
But here, it refers to the lack of mechanization. When you see a machine-pressed pizza crust, it’s uniform. It’s boring. It’s dead. A handcrafted crust has personality. It has uneven edges. It has soul.
The same goes for the pasta. Machine-extruded pasta is fine for high-volume feeding, but "hand-cut" pasta has slight variations in thickness. This means every bite is a little different. Some bits are slightly more al dente than others. That texture is what separates a $12 bowl of noodles from a $22 culinary experience.
Small Plates and the "Gusto" Experience
You can't just dive into the carbs. Well, you can, but you shouldn't.
The appetizers (or Antipasti) on the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu are designed to prime your palate. Honestly, the burrata is usually the safest and most satisfying bet. It’s essentially a mozzarella shell filled with cream and cheese curds. When you break it open, it creates its own sauce for whatever crostini they serve it with.
Also, look for the meatballs. A good test of any Italian-leaning menu is the meatball. It should be a mix of beef, pork, and sometimes veal, held together with enough breadcrumbs and milk (panade) to keep it tender. If it's as hard as a golf ball, leave.
Common Misconceptions About Gusto
One big mistake people make is thinking Gusto is a "fast food" pizza joint because of the open kitchen. It’s not.
🔗 Read more: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
If you're in a rush, don't order the lasagna. Handcrafted lasagna takes time to layer, and if it's finished in a wood-fired oven, it needs those extra minutes to get the crispy edges everyone fights over.
Another thing: the menu changes. Seasonality is a big deal for a place that prides itself on "handcrafted" goods. In the summer, expect heirloom tomatoes and light, citrusy pastas. In the winter, the Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu usually shifts toward heavier ragus, braised meats, and root vegetables. If you’re looking for a specific dish you had six months ago, it might be gone. That’s a sign of a good kitchen, not a disorganized one.
The Beverage Pairing Strategy
You’ve got the food sorted. Now, what are you drinking?
- For Red Sauces: Go with a Sangiovese or a Barbera. The acidity in the wine matches the acidity in the tomatoes.
- For Creamy Pastas: A crisp white like a Pinot Grigio or even a Vermentino cuts through the fat.
- For Spicy Pizzas: Avoid high-alcohol reds. They make the spice feel like a chemical burn. Instead, try a slightly chilled Lambrusco. It’s a sparkling red that sounds fancy but is actually just a fun, fizzy way to wash down pepperoni.
What to Look for Next Time You Visit
When you sit down and open that Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu, do a quick scan for the "Specials" section first. That’s usually where the chef is experimenting with the freshest ingredients of the week.
Check the "Pasta" section for the phrase "extruded in-house." If they’re making their own rigatoni or fusilli, that’s a massive labor of love that usually translates to a better meal.
Finally, look at the "Dolce." Most people are too stuffed for dessert, but if they have a house-made tiramisu, it’s usually worth the extra calories. A real tiramisu shouldn't be a soggy mess; it should be a structured balance of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and light mascarpone cream.
Actionable Tips for the Best Experience
To get the most out of your visit to Gusto, keep these points in mind:
- Check the Oven: If you don’t see a wood or stone hearth oven, the pizza won't have that signature char.
- Ask About the Daily Batch: Ask the server which pasta was made fresh that morning. Not every shape is made every day.
- The "Napolitana" Rule: If you’re ordering a traditional Neapolitan-style pizza, eat it immediately. Those pizzas have a "shelf life" of about ten minutes before the thin center starts to get soggy from the steam.
- Share Everything: The portions are usually generous. The best way to experience the menu is to order one pasta and one pizza for every two people and swap halfway through.
The Gusto handcrafted pasta & pizza menu isn't just a list of food; it's a reflection of a specific style of cooking that values technique over speed. Whether you're there for a quick lunch or a long dinner, paying attention to these small details—the flour, the fermentation, and the pasta extrusion—will drastically change how much you enjoy your meal. Focus on the house-made specialties and don't be afraid of the more "experimental" toppings; that’s usually where the kitchen's talent really shines through.