If you walk into a bar in Titletown and mention the name "Randy Wright," you might get a polite nod or a blank stare. But mention Bart, Brett, or Aaron? You’ve just started a four-hour conversation. The Green Bay Packers quarterbacks all time list is essentially a VIP guest list for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, yet it’s also a graveyard of "what-ifs" and forgotten names that bridged the gaps between icons.
It's actually pretty wild. Most NFL franchises spend decades—sometimes half a century—praying to find one "guy." The Packers have essentially had three back-to-back-to-back, with a fourth currently auditioning for his bronze bust in Canton.
The Founding Fathers and the Pre-Lombardi Fog
Before the Super Bowl was even a twinkle in Pete Rozelle's eye, the Packers were already winning. People forget that. Arnie Herber and Cecil Isbell were the original "air raid" pioneers back when the football was shaped more like a watermelon than a modern pigskin.
Herber, a local kid from Green Bay, led the league in passing yards three times in the 1930s. He was basically the original gunslinger. He’d just hurl it deep to Don Hutson, and it worked. Then came Isbell, who only played five years but was so dominant he became the first player to throw for over 2,000 yards in a season (1942). Then he just... retired to go coach. Talk about leaving at your peak.
After those two? Honestly, things got kinda grim for a while.
The 1950s were mostly a blur of Tobin Rote. Rote was actually incredible—a dual-threat QB before that was a term—but the team around him was mostly a disaster. He led the Packers in both passing and rushing in 1951, which is usually a sign that your roster is in trouble.
Bart Starr: The Ice Bowl and the Five Rings
When Vince Lombardi showed up in 1959, he didn't even like Bart Starr at first. He thought Starr was too polite. Too quiet.
Starr proved him wrong by becoming the most efficient surgeon in football history. He wasn't going to blow you away with 400-yard games because he didn't have to. With Jim Taylor and Paul Hornung in the backfield, Starr just needed to be perfect on third down. And he was.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
Check out these post-season numbers:
- 9-1 record as a starter.
- 15 touchdowns and only 3 interceptions.
- A 104.8 passer rating in an era where defenders could basically clothesline receivers.
His sneak in the 1967 Ice Bowl against Dallas is the stuff of legend, but his real legacy is the five NFL championships in seven years. Nobody else has done that. Not Brady, not Montana.
The Dark Ages: 1968 to 1991
This is the part of the Green Bay Packers quarterbacks all time history that younger fans skip. It’s the "70s and 80s" hole. Between Starr and Favre, the Packers tried everything.
They traded an absolute mountain of draft picks (five of them!) to the Rams for John Hadl in 1974. Hadl was 34 and his arm was basically cooked. It’s widely considered one of the worst trades in sports history.
Then there was Lynn Dickey. Man, could Dickey throw the ball. In 1983, he threw for 4,458 yards and 32 touchdowns. Those are modern-day MVP numbers! But the Packers defense at the time couldn't stop a high school team, so Dickey ended up with a lot of 48-47 losses.
We can’t forget the "Majik Man," Don Majkowski. For one glorious season in 1989, he led the "Cardiac Pack" to a 10-6 record and looked like the future. Then he hurt his rotator cuff, then his ankle, and then... some guy from Southern Miss stepped onto the field.
Brett Favre: The 297-Game Iron Man
When Ron Wolf traded a first-round pick for a backup Falcons QB who had more interceptions than completions, people thought he was crazy.
🔗 Read more: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
Then Brett Favre happened.
Favre was pure chaos. He’d throw a left-handed touchdown while being dragged to the ground, then throw three interceptions into triple coverage the next drive. You couldn't look away.
- The Streak: 297 consecutive starts (321 including playoffs). It’s the most unbreakable record in football.
- The MVPs: Three in a row (1995-1997). Nobody else has done that consecutively.
- The Stats: 61,655 yards and 442 touchdowns in Green and Gold.
He brought the Lombardi Trophy back to Green Bay in Super Bowl XXXI, ending a 29-year drought. But his style was a double-edged sword. He holds the NFL record for interceptions (336), and honestly, most Packers fans wouldn't trade a single one of them for a "safer" quarterback.
Aaron Rodgers: The King of Efficiency
If Favre was chaos, Aaron Rodgers was a laser-guided missile.
Watching Rodgers from 2011 to 2021 was like watching a master class. He didn't just win; he embarrassed people. His 2011 season is still arguably the greatest single season for any QB ever: 45 touchdowns, 6 interceptions, and a 122.5 passer rating.
He didn't turn the ball over. Ever.
Rodgers finished his Packers career with 475 touchdowns and just 105 interceptions. To put that in perspective, Favre had 105 interceptions by, like, his sixth year as a starter.
💡 You might also like: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
While the "only one Super Bowl" argument gets brought up by critics, Rodgers’ four MVP awards with the Packers speak for themselves. He changed the way the position was played, using the hard count and the "free play" as a weapon.
The Jordan Love Era and Beyond
Following a legend is hard. Following two? It should be impossible.
Jordan Love sat for three years, just like Rodgers did. When he finally took over in 2023, the first half of the season was rocky. People were calling him a bust by October. Then, something clicked.
Love finished that first year with 4,159 yards and 32 touchdowns, leading the youngest team in the league to a playoff demolition of the Dallas Cowboys. By 2024 and 2025, he’d already established himself as a top-tier starter, proving the Packers' "sit and develop" philosophy actually works in an era of instant gratification.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Historians
When looking back at this lineage, there are a few things you should actually do to appreciate the history:
- Watch the 1967 NFL Championship (The Ice Bowl): Don't just look at highlights. Find the full broadcast. Seeing the conditions Starr played in changes your perspective on "toughness."
- Check the TD-to-INT Ratios: If you want to see the evolution of the game, compare Bart Starr (152/138) to Aaron Rodgers (475/105). It’s the best way to see how much more protected QBs and WRs are today.
- Visit the Packers Hall of Fame: If you're ever in Green Bay, the QB exhibit at Lambeau is legitimately world-class. It’s the only place you can see Starr’s helmet and Favre’s jerseys in one spot.
- Don't ignore the "Bridge" QBs: To understand why the Packers are so successful now, you have to understand the pain of the 1970s and 80s. It’s why the fan base is so patient with guys like Love.
The Packers have a way of finding the right person at the right time. Whether it's through a trade (Favre), a draft slide (Rodgers), or a controversial trade-up (Love), the history of Green Bay quarterbacks is essentially a history of the NFL itself.