The water is cold. It’s early morning, maybe 7:00 AM, and you’re sitting on your surfboard off the coast of Gansbaai or perhaps somewhere near the Farallon Islands. You see a shadow. Most people think this is the moment where a calculated, bloodthirsty predator decides to hunt a human. But the reality of a great white shark attack is rarely about hunger. Honestly, if these animals actually wanted to eat us, the statistics would be terrifyingly higher. Instead, we see about 70 to 100 unprovoked attacks globally per year across all shark species. That's it. For a predator that has survived five mass extinctions, they are surprisingly uninterested in people.
We have a weird relationship with Carcharodon carcharias. We’re obsessed.
The Myth of the "Man-Eater"
Let’s be real: Peter Benchley’s Jaws ruined the reputation of the great white for generations. Benchley himself actually spent the latter half of his life as a massive shark advocate because he felt guilty about the stigma he created. When a great white shark attack occurs, it’s almost always a case of mistaken identity or investigative biting.
Sharks don’t have hands. They use their mouths to figure out what things are.
Dr. R. Aidan Martin and other researchers have noted that many "attacks" are actually "test bites." A white shark will strike, realize the object is mostly bone and neoprene (not a fatty seal), and then swim away. This is why many victims survive. The shark isn't coming back for seconds. It realized you tasted like a rubber suit and a fiberglass board. Of course, when a 2,000-pound animal "tests" you with several hundred serrated teeth, the damage is catastrophic. But the intent matters for understanding how to stay safe.
📖 Related: Half Dome: What Most People Get Wrong About Yosemite’s Most Famous Landmark
Sensory Overload and the "Bite"
Great whites are sensory powerhouses. They have these tiny pores on their snouts called the Ampullae of Lorenzini. They can literally feel the electrical pulse of your heartbeat.
Imagine you're a shark. You're swimming in murky water near a river mouth. Suddenly, you detect a rhythmic electrical vibration and a splashing silhouette above you. It looks like a Cape fur seal. You hit it from below with a massive burst of speed. This is "breaching," a behavior most famously documented in False Bay, South Africa. If a shark hits a surfer this way, it’s a high-energy mistake.
Where the Risks Are Actually Highest
You can't just find a great white anywhere. They like specific "cafeterias."
- Dyer Island, South Africa: A major hub for seals and, consequently, sharks.
- Neptune Islands, Australia: Famous for massive bulls and aggressive feeding behavior.
- California’s "Red Triangle": This stretch from Monterey Bay up to Bodega Bay is a hotspot for adult whites hunting elephant seals.
- Guadalupe Island, Mexico: Known for incredibly clear water, though it's recently been closed to shark cage diving by the Mexican government to protect the animals.
If you are swimming in these areas during peak seal migration, you’re basically walking through a forest during hunting season wearing a deer suit. It’s not that the shark is "evil." You're just in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Does Color Matter?
Divers often talk about "Yum Yum Yellow." There’s some evidence that high-contrast colors might attract a shark’s attention. They don't see color the way we do, but contrast? They’re masters of it. If you’re wearing a bright neon wetsuit with silver fins that flash like fish scales, you’re basically a blinking neon sign.
What Science Says About Recent Spikes
People often ask if a great white shark attack is becoming more common.
The numbers say yes, but the context says no.
There are more people in the water than ever before. In the 1950s, surfing was a niche hobby for a few hundred people. Today, millions of people are in the surf every single day. When you adjust for the human population explosion, the rate of attacks has actually stayed pretty flat or even dipped in some regions.
Also, we have better tech now. Everyone has a smartphone. A shark sighting in 1980 was a story you told at a bar. A shark sighting in 2026 is a viral TikTok video within ten minutes. This creates a "perception bias." It feels like they are everywhere because we see them everywhere on our screens.
Climate Change and Shifting Borders
Water temperatures are changing. This is a fact. Great whites are endothermic poikilotherms, which is just a fancy way of saying they can keep their bodies warmer than the surrounding water. This allows them to hunt in cold depths. However, as the oceans warm, juvenile great whites are being seen further north than ever before. We’re seeing "nurseries" pop up in places like Monterey Bay where they didn't used to be. This brings young, inexperienced sharks into closer contact with popular swimming beaches.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Real Mount Sinai: Why the Map of Mt Sinai is More Contentious Than You Think
Young sharks are like teenagers—they're curious, they're learning, and they make mistakes.
Surprising Survival Tactics
If you ever find yourself staring down a white shark, don't play dead. That works for bears (sometimes), but for sharks, "dead" just means "easy snack."
- Maintain Eye Contact: Sharks are ambush predators. They want to hit you when you aren't looking. If you keep your body facing them and track their movement, you break the element of surprise.
- Don't Splash: Thrashing looks like a wounded fish. Smooth, rhythmic strokes are better.
- Fight Back: If it bites, go for the sensitive spots. The nose is okay, but the eyes and the gills are the real weak points.
- The "Shield": Use your surfboard or your camera as a barrier. Put something between your "soft bits" and those teeth.
The International Shark Attack File (ISAF), based at the University of Florida, emphasizes that the "bump" often precedes the bite. If a shark bumps you, it's checking your "hardness." This is your window to get out of the water immediately.
The Reality of the Risk
Statistically, you are more likely to be killed by a vending machine, a toaster, or a cow than by a great white shark attack.
We lose about 100 million sharks a year to finning and bycatch. Who is the real predator here? When we enter the ocean, we are entering a wild wilderness. We’ve become so used to manicured parks and safe swimming pools that we forget the ocean is one of the few places left on Earth where humans aren't at the top of the food chain.
Respecting that boundary is key.
Actionable Safety Steps for Your Next Trip
If you’re heading to a known shark hotspot, don’t cancel your trip. Just be smarter than the average tourist.
👉 See also: Thinking of a New York to LA drive? Here is what most people get wrong
- Avoid River Mouths: Heavy rain washes dead organic matter and silt into the ocean. This attracts baitfish, which attract sharks. The visibility is also terrible, increasing the chance of a "mistake" bite.
- Ditch the Jewelry: That gold chain or silver watch reflects light exactly like the scales of a menhaden or a mackerel.
- Time Your Swim: Stay out of the water at dawn and dusk. This is "low light" hunting time when sharks have the visual advantage.
- Watch the Birds: If you see seabirds diving frantically, there is a bait ball. If there is a bait ball, there are predators. Stay away.
- Check the News: Local lifesavers usually know if a "landlord" (local slang for a big shark) has been hanging around a particular beach.
The ocean is their home. We’re just visiting. Understanding the biology and the actual behavior of the great white shark doesn't just make you safer—it makes you realize that these "attacks" are rare, tragic accidents between two species that were never meant to cross paths in the first place.