You’ve just stepped off a Metro-North train. The gold clock is glowing, the ceiling is that iconic teal, and you’re surrounded by about ten thousand people who look like they’re in a much bigger hurry than you are. You need to get from Grand Central Station to Madison Square Garden, and you need to do it before the puck drops or the lights go down for the concert.
It sounds simple. They’re both in Midtown, right?
Well, yeah. But New York City blocks are deceptive. If you walk it, you’re looking at a solid fifteen to twenty minutes of dodging tourists and salmoning upstream against commuter traffic. If you take the subway, you’re at the mercy of the MTA’s weekend maintenance schedules. Honestly, the "best" way depends entirely on whether your knees hurt or if you’ve got five bucks to spare for a slice of pizza along the way.
The Walk: Why 42nd to 33rd is Better Than It Sounds
Most people assume the walk from Grand Central Station to Madison Square Garden is a slog. It’s about 0.8 miles. In New York terms, that’s nothing. You exit Grand Central onto 42nd Street, hang a left, and walk past Bryant Park. If it’s winter, you’ll see the skaters. If it’s summer, you’ll see people fighting over those little green bistro chairs.
Once you hit 7th Avenue, you turn left and head downtown.
The Garden—MSG, the World's Most Famous Arena—literally sits right on top of Penn Station. It’s a giant beige cylinder. You can't miss it. The walk is actually pretty great for people-watching. You’ll pass the flagship Macy’s at Herald Square. You'll see the Empire State Building looming over you at 34th Street. It’s the quintessential "I'm in New York" experience.
But here’s the thing. If it’s raining, or if it’s one of those August days where the humidity makes the air feel like warm soup, you’re going to hate every second of that walk.
The Subway Shortcut (The S Shuttle Secret)
There is no direct subway line that goes from the front door of Grand Central to the front door of MSG. This trips up everyone.
You have to take the S Shuttle or the 7 train over to Times Square first.
It’s one stop. It takes about two minutes. Once you’re at Times Square-42nd St, follow the red signs for the 1, 2, or 3 trains. Take any of those downtown just one stop to 34th Street-Penn Station.
👉 See also: Something is wrong with my world map: Why the Earth looks so weird on paper
Wait.
Check the signs. You want the "Uptown and The Bronx" or "Downtown and Brooklyn" side? You want Downtown. Don't end up in Harlem when your concert is in Midtown. Once you get off at 34th Street, follow the signs for Madison Square Garden. You'll go up a few escalators and suddenly, you're there. Total travel time? Maybe 12 minutes if the train timing is on your side.
What Most People Get Wrong About the "Station" Names
Let's get pedantic for a second because it actually matters for your GPS.
Locals will roll their eyes if you call it "Grand Central Station." Technically, the building is Grand Central Terminal. A station is where a train passes through; a terminal is where the lines end. Since the Metro-North tracks literally stop there, it’s a terminal.
Why does this matter?
Because if you type "Grand Central Station" into some older mapping apps, it might try to send you to the Post Office nearby or a specific subway entrance blocks away. Use "Grand Central Terminal" for the most accurate drop-off point.
Similarly, Madison Square Garden isn't in Madison Square. It used to be. Back in the 1800s, the original MSG was actually located at 26th Street and Madison Avenue (near where Eataly is now). The current Garden—the one you’re going to—is between 7th and 8th Avenues and 31st to 33rd Streets. It’s nowhere near the actual Madison Square Park.
If you tell a cab driver "Take me to Madison Square," you’re going to end up twenty blocks away from your event. Always specify "The Garden" or "Penn Station."
The Grand Central Madison Factor: A New Era
There is a massive curveball that was thrown into the mix recently: Grand Central Madison.
✨ Don't miss: Pic of Spain Flag: Why You Probably Have the Wrong One and What the Symbols Actually Mean
For decades, if you were coming in from Long Island on the LIRR, you went to Penn Station (directly under MSG). If you were coming from Westchester or Connecticut, you went to Grand Central.
Now, the LIRR goes to both.
If you are coming from Long Island and your goal is to get to Grand Central Station to Madison Square Garden, you might actually be doing it backward. Check your ticket. If your train is headed to Grand Central Madison, you are going to be deep—and I mean deep—underground. It takes about eight to ten minutes just to get from the new LIRR platforms up to the street level of Grand Central.
If your event is at MSG, try to find a train that goes directly to Penn Station. It saves you the entire cross-town headache.
The Secret Tunnel (Sorta)
There used to be a famous underground passage called the "Gimbels Pass" that connected Penn Station to the Herald Square subway station. It would have made the trip from the area near Grand Central much easier in bad weather.
It’s been closed for decades.
People on Reddit and old travel forums still talk about it like it’s a viable shortcut. It isn't. It’s a graveyard of old tile and locked gates. Don't go looking for it. Stay on the street or stay on the subway.
Where to Eat Between the Two
If you’re walking from Grand Central Station to Madison Square Garden, you’re going to get hungry.
Skip the tourist traps right on 42nd Street.
🔗 Read more: Seeing Universal Studios Orlando from Above: What the Maps Don't Tell You
- Keens Steakhouse: If you have time and a big budget, this is on 36th Street. It’s legendary. They have thousands of clay pipes hanging from the ceiling.
- Joe’s Pizza: On 1435 Broadway. It’s fast. It’s classic NY thin crust. It’s standing room only.
- The Pennsy: Well, actually, The Pennsy food hall closed, but the area around MSG is now flooded with "Moynihan Food Hall" options just across 8th Avenue.
If you want something quick and cheap, there are about a dozen halal carts on the corners of 7th Avenue. Look for the one with the longest line; that's usually the best indicator of fresh chicken and gyro meat.
Navigating the "Garden" Once You Arrive
The Garden is a vertical arena.
If your tickets say "200 Level" or "400 Level," give yourself an extra 15 minutes. The escalators at MSG are notoriously slow during peak entry times.
Also, security is tight. Don't bring a big backpack. They will make you check it, or worse, tell you that you can't bring it in at all. Most people don't realize that MSG has a very strict "no bag" policy for anything larger than a small purse.
Getting Back: The Post-Event Chaos
Leaving Madison Square Garden to get back to Grand Central Station at 11:00 PM is a different beast.
The subways will be packed.
If you’re taking the 1, 2, or 3 train back to Times Square to catch the Shuttle, be prepared to be squeezed in with a thousand other people wearing the same concert t-shirt.
Honestly? This is when the walk is actually the best move. The city cools down at night, the neon lights of Times Square are visible a few blocks north, and it’s often faster than waiting for a delayed late-night train.
Quick Reference for Your Trip
- The Walking Route: 42nd St to 7th Ave, then South to 33rd St.
- The Subway Route: S Shuttle to Times Square, then 1/2/3 Train South to 34th St-Penn Station.
- Estimated Uber/Lyft Cost: $15–$30 depending on surge pricing (and it will take longer than walking because of traffic).
- The LIRR Tip: Check if your train goes to Penn Station first; it’s literally under the arena.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit
To make this transition as smooth as possible, keep these specific tips in mind:
- Download the MYmta App: It’s the official app and much more accurate for real-time subway delays than Google Maps.
- Use the "North End" Exit: When arriving at Grand Central via Metro-North, use the North End passages to exit closer to 47th or 48th street if you want to avoid the main terminal crowd, though for MSG, the main 42nd St exit is more direct.
- Check the MSG Entry Gate: Your ticket will specify an entry gate (like Chase Square on 7th Ave). Don't just wander around the cylinder; look for your specific lettered gate to save time.
- Avoid 8th Avenue Construction: There’s almost always work being done near Penn Station. Stick to 7th Avenue for a clearer walking path.
- Pre-load your OMNY: You don't need a MetroCard anymore. Just tap your credit card or phone at the subway turnstile. It saves you from the nightmare of the vending machine lines.
The distance between these two landmarks is the heart of Midtown Manhattan. It’s loud, it’s busy, and it can be overwhelming. But if you know the difference between the Shuttle and the 1 train, or if you’re willing to hoof it past Bryant Park, you’ll handle it like a pro.