Nobody sets out to make the worst movie of all time. But in 2018, that’s exactly what happened when the Gotti movie with John Travolta finally hit theaters. It didn’t just fail; it cratered. We’re talking about a rare 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. That's a special kind of achievement. Usually, even the most miserable films have one critic who finds something nice to say about the lighting or the craft services. Not this one.
It’s been years, but people still talk about it. Why? Because the behind-the-scenes drama was arguably more interesting than the film itself. The movie spent nearly a decade in "development hell," swapping directors like trading cards. Names like Nick Cassavetes, Barry Levinson, and Joe Johnston were all attached at various points. They even had Al Pacino and Lindsay Lohan rumored for roles. Instead, we got Kevin Connolly—best known as "E" from Entourage—directing a script that felt like it was trying to be Goodfellas but ended up sounding like a parody.
The Marketing War: Critics vs. Audiences
Things got weird when the movie actually came out. The marketing team knew the critics were sharpening their knives, so they went on the offensive. They released ads basically calling critics "trolls" and asking audiences, "Who would you trust? A critic or yourself?" It was a bold move. Maybe too bold.
The Gotti movie with John Travolta then became the center of a weird conspiracy theory involving MoviePass. If you remember MoviePass, it was that subscription service that let you see a movie a day for ten bucks until they inevitably ran out of money. Well, MoviePass Ventures actually co-produced Gotti. Suddenly, the movie had a massive audience score on Rotten Tomatoes while the critical score stayed at zero. People noticed that thousands of new accounts were created just to give Gotti a five-star review. Rotten Tomatoes insisted everything was legit, but the internet wasn't buying it.
Honestly, the whole "critics put out a hit" narrative backfired. It just made more people curious about how bad the movie actually was.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Why the Gotti Movie with John Travolta Failed the Critics
You've got to wonder how a movie with John Travolta—a guy who can genuinely act when he wants to—became such a punchline. Travolta actually loved the role. He wore John Gotti’s real clothes. He used the real jewelry. He spent time with the Gotti family. He was all in.
But the movie felt... off.
- The Narrative Structure: It jumps around in time so much you practically need a map. One minute we're in 1973, then 1992, then back to the 80s. It never settles into a rhythm.
- The Soundtrack: This might be the most baffling part. You’re watching a gritty New York mob story and suddenly Pitbull starts rapping. No disrespect to Mr. 305, but "Timber" doesn't exactly scream Gambino crime family.
- The Tone: It feels like a fan film. Because it was based on John Gotti Jr.’s book and produced with the family's blessing, it portrays Gotti less like a ruthless killer and more like a misunderstood neighborhood hero.
The film opens with Travolta, as Gotti, speaking directly to the camera from some sort of afterlife. "New York is the greatest city in the world," he tells us. It’s a bit much. It feels like a high school play with a $10 million budget.
Fact-Checking the "Teflon Don" Portrayal
The movie tries hard to lean into the legend of the "Teflon Don." For those who aren't mob history buffs, Gotti earned that nickname by beating federal charges three times in the 80s. The film celebrates these wins as triumphs of the "street" over the "suits."
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
However, it glosses over the reality of what Gotti was doing. While the movie shows him as a family man who cared about his community, the FBI's tapes from the Ravenite Social Club told a different story. They heard a man who was paranoid, ego-driven, and perfectly willing to order hits on his own friends. By focusing so much on the "myth" provided by the Gotti family, the filmmakers lost the complexity that made the real story interesting.
The Tragedy of Kelly Preston
One of the few things people generally agree on is that Kelly Preston—Travolta's real-life wife—put in a solid effort as Victoria Gotti. It was one of her final roles before she passed away in 2020. There’s a scene where she confronts John in prison about their son's death that actually feels human. It’s a rare moment of genuine emotion in a movie that mostly feels like a collection of guys in suits shouting in Italian accents.
Watching it now, those scenes are bittersweet. You can see the chemistry between them, which makes sense because they were married for nearly 30 years. It’s just a shame it was in this movie.
What Can We Learn from the Gotti Disaster?
If you're a filmmaker or just a fan of cinema, the Gotti movie with John Travolta is a masterclass in what happens when a "passion project" loses its perspective. Travolta wanted this to be his Godfather. Instead, it became a cautionary tale about why you probably shouldn't let the subject of a biopic have creative control over the script.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
If you’re planning to watch it, here’s how to handle it:
- Watch it as a "so bad it's good" flick: If you go in expecting a masterpiece, you'll be miserable. If you go in with friends and a couple of pizzas, it’s a hilarious watch.
- Compare it to the 1996 HBO version: If you want to see a good Gotti movie, find the one starring Armand Assante. It’s night and day. Assante captures the menace that Travolta trades for caricature.
- Research the real history: Read Gotti: Rise and Fall by Jerry Capeci. It gives you the actual facts that the movie skips over to make Gotti look like a saint.
The legacy of the Gotti movie with John Travolta isn't its box office or its awards (it got six Razzie nominations, by the way). Its legacy is the meme. It’s the "critics put out the hit" line. It’s the image of Travolta in a silver wig, gesturing wildly at a rear-projected Brooklyn Bridge. Sometimes, a movie is so spectacular in its failure that it achieves a weird kind of immortality.
Check out the real FBI surveillance tapes on YouTube if you want to hear what the man actually sounded like. It's a lot less cinematic and a lot more chilling than anything captured on film.