You remember the chaos. The Duncan house was already a zoo with PJ’s cooking disasters, Teddy’s constant video diary monologues, and Gabe’s endless pranks on Mrs. Dabney. Just when things felt "settled," the writers threw a curveball that nobody—not even the cast, apparently—saw coming. Enter Good Luck Charlie Toby Duncan, the fifth and final addition to the Denver-based family.
Toby wasn't just another baby. His arrival marked a massive shift for the Disney Channel sitcom, which had spent years focusing on how the older kids adjusted to Charlie. Suddenly, the "new" baby was no longer the baby. Honestly, a lot of fans still argue about whether Toby’s introduction was a "jump the shark" moment or a genius move to keep the show from getting stale as Mia Talerico (Charlie) grew into a toddler.
The Mystery of the Two Tobys
Wait, two Tobys? Yeah, if you weren't paying close attention to the credits in 2012, you might have missed the swap.
When Toby first made his grand entrance in the Season 3 episode "Special Delivery," he was played by a baby named Jake Cinoa. He was born right in the middle of a frantic ice cream truck ride—classic Duncan luck—on the same day as Charlie’s birthday. Jake stayed on for the remainder of the third season, mostly being "the baby" who didn't have much to do other than look cute and facilitate Gabe's new "clean-up boy" duties.
Then Season 4 rolled around, and suddenly Toby had grown up. Fast.
👉 See also: Nothing to Lose: Why the Martin Lawrence and Tim Robbins Movie is Still a 90s Classic
Disney decided to "re-cast" the role with Logan Moreau. Why the change? It's a common Hollywood move. Producers often swap out infants for slightly older toddlers who can handle "acting" (aka following simple directions and not crying during a take). Logan Moreau brought a lot of personality to the role, including that adorable, mischievous energy that made him feel like a true Duncan.
Toby Wan Kenobi Duncan: A Name Chosen by the Internet
One of the coolest bits of trivia about Good Luck Charlie Toby Duncan is how he got his name. Disney didn't just pick it out of a hat. They actually ran a "Name the Baby" poll on their website, and fans went absolutely wild. Over 25 million votes were cast.
While the poll resulted in the name "Toby" for a boy (or "Sydney" if it had been a girl), Gabe Duncan—played by Bradley Steven Perry—gave him the legendary middle name: Wan Kenobi.
Bob and Amy Duncan might have been exhausted, but they let it slide.
✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
Where is Logan Moreau Now?
Since the show wrapped in 2014, people have been dying to know what happened to the kid who played Toby. Logan Moreau was only about a year old when he started on the show. Today, in 2026, he’s a teenager.
Unlike Bridgit Mendler, who basically became a tech CEO and a space lawyer (seriously, look it up), Logan has lived a much more private life. After Good Luck Charlie, he did a few more spots on TV, including a guest role on the show Bones and an appearance in Jessie.
But honestly? He mostly stepped away from the spotlight to just be a normal kid. It’s a path a lot of Disney toddlers take. You get your start before you can even talk, and by the time you're in middle school, you realize you'd rather play soccer or video games than sit in a trailer on a studio lot.
Was Toby Necessary? The Great Fan Debate
If you spend five minutes on Reddit or Disney nostalgia forums, you’ll see the same debate over and over. Was Toby Duncan a mistake?
🔗 Read more: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Some fans feel like the show lost its "identity" once Toby arrived. The whole premise was Good Luck Charlie—Teddy giving advice to Charlie. By adding Toby, the focus shifted. However, the writers clearly felt they needed a "reset." As Mia Talerico got older, she became a character with her own dialogue and plotlines. They needed a new infant to recreate that "overwhelmed parents" dynamic that made the first two seasons so relatable to families.
Key Facts About Toby Duncan:
- Birth Date: June 24 (Same as Charlie!).
- Birthplace: An ice cream truck (Dan's Treetop Treats).
- Middle Name: Wan Kenobi.
- Actors: Jake Cinoa (Season 3), Logan Moreau (Season 4).
The Reality of Being a Duncan
Growing up as the fifth kid meant Toby was destined for a weird life. By the time he was born, the video diary tradition was already a decade deep. While Teddy was the primary creator of the diaries, there’s always been a fan theory that Gabe eventually took over the camera to record advice for Toby.
It makes sense. Gabe and Toby had a similar age gap to Teddy and Charlie. Seeing Gabe—the resident troublemaker—give advice on how to navigate Amy’s "Mama Bird" segments and Bob’s pest control business would have been the perfect spin-off.
If you're looking to revisit the Toby era, the best place to start is the "Special Delivery" hour-long event. It’s peak Disney Channel chaos. You get to see the family desperately trying to get to the hospital, Amy Duncan being her typical dramatic self, and the moment the family officially became a group of seven.
To keep up with what the rest of the cast is doing today, check out Mia Talerico’s social media, where she occasionally posts throwbacks. While Logan Moreau isn't active on public platforms, the legacy of the "littlest Duncan" lives on in every rewatch of those final episodes.