If you ask a casual fan about Gonzalo Higuain Real Madrid years, they’ll probably talk about the misses. They remember the Lyon game in 2010 or the 2014 World Cup final. It’s kinda tragic, actually. Because if you look at the raw numbers, the guy was a monster in a white shirt.
Imagine scoring 27 league goals in a single season—more than Cristiano Ronaldo that same year—and then watching your club go out and buy Karim Benzema and Kaka. That’s basically what happened to "Pipa" in 2009. He spent seven years at the Bernabéu fighting an uphill battle against the "Galactico" philosophy, yet he still walked away with 121 goals.
The €13 Million Gamble That Paid Off
Madrid signed Higuain from River Plate in January 2007. He was only 19. At the time, the club was a bit of a mess. They were desperate for fresh blood under Fabio Capello. People forget he wasn't even a pure "nine" back then; he played more like a winger or a second striker.
His first big moment? A last-minute winner against Espanyol in May 2007. It was a chaotic 4-3 comeback. That goal basically won Madrid the league title. Honestly, if he hadn't poked that ball home, the "Juntos Podemos" era might never have happened. He had this knack for being in the right place during the most stressful minutes of a game.
👉 See also: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
Why the Benzema vs. Higuain Debate Divided Madrid
For four years, the Bernabéu was split. You were either Team Higuain or Team Benzema.
Higuain was the worker. He was tenacious, loud, and clinical in La Liga. Between 2008 and 2013, he was putting up numbers that most strikers today would dream of. In the 2009-10 season, he bagged 27 goals in just 32 league matches. That is a ridiculous strike rate.
But there was a catch.
✨ Don't miss: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
- The European "Curse": While he was a king in Spain, his Champions League form was... shaky. He only managed 8 goals in 48 UCL appearances for Madrid.
- The Aesthetics: Benzema was elegant. Florentino Pérez loved Benzema's link-up play with Ronaldo. Higuain was more of a traditional "get the ball and shoot" type.
- The Politics: Higuain was a signing from the previous regime (Ramón Calderón). In the world of Real Madrid, that matters.
By the time Jose Mourinho arrived, the rotation became a headache for everyone. Higuain would score a hat-trick one week and then sit on the bench for the El Clásico the next. You could see the frustration growing.
The Back Injury and the Exit
In 2011, Higuain suffered a herniated disc. It was serious. Some doctors thought he might not return to the same level. He proved them wrong by scoring 22 goals in the 2011-12 "League of Records" season, but the writing was on the wall.
He finally left for Napoli in 2013 for about €40 million. In his final game against Osasuna, he wore the captain's armband and scored. He was crying. The fans were chanting his name. It was one of those rare moments where the Bernabéu showed him the love he’d been craving for years.
🔗 Read more: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
What We Get Wrong About Pipa
Most people label him a "choker" because of the high-profile misses later in his career with Argentina. But at Real Madrid, he was arguably one of the most efficient finishers in the club's history.
He didn't need 10 chances to score. He needed one.
He won three La Liga titles, a Copa del Rey, and two Spanish Super Cups. He outscored legendary names and kept a world-class talent like Benzema on the bench for long stretches. If he played in the social media era of today, his 2009 stats would have made him a global icon overnight.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
To truly appreciate what Higuain did, stop looking at YouTube "fail" compilations. Instead, look at the 2008-2012 La Liga goal-per-minute ratios. You'll find him sitting right next to Messi and Ronaldo.
- Check the 2009-10 Stats: Compare his 27 goals (zero penalties) to other top European strikers that year. It’s eye-opening.
- Watch the "La Liga de las Remontadas": Find full highlights of the 2006-07 season. His energy was the catalyst for that title.
- Re-evaluate the "Choker" Label: Separate his domestic club form from his international final performances. They are two different stories.
The reality is that Gonzalo Higuain Real Madrid career was a success by every objective measure. He arrived as a kid and left as the club's 14th all-time leading scorer. Not bad for a guy who was "never quite good enough" for the boardroom.