Going Back in Time: Why Physics Says You Probably Can't (But Some Still Try)

Going Back in Time: Why Physics Says You Probably Can't (But Some Still Try)

Time is a one-way street. At least, that’s how it feels when you’ve burnt your toast or sent a text you immediately regret. We all have that nagging desire to hit a cosmic undo button. But going back in time isn't just a trope for sci-fi writers like H.G. Wells or the creators of Back to the Future; it's a legitimate, albeit frustrating, corner of theoretical physics that keeps some of the world's smartest people awake at night. Honestly, if you ask a physicist like Kip Thorne or Ronald Mallett, they won't laugh you out of the room. They’ll just start talking about tensors and light cones.

It’s complicated.

Most people think of time travel as a mechanical problem—build a fast enough ship, find a glowing crystal, and boom, you’re in 1955. But the reality is tied to the very fabric of space. Einstein basically changed the game when he showed that time and space are woven together into a four-dimensional fabric called spacetime. Because of this, time isn't a constant. It’s flexible. It stretches. It slows down. If you’ve ever used a GPS to find a coffee shop, you’ve used a system that accounts for time dilation. The satellites in orbit are moving fast and are further from Earth’s gravity, so their clocks tick slightly faster than yours. They are, quite literally, living in a different "now" than you are.

The Einstein-Rosen Bridge and the Shortcut Problem

If you want to get serious about going back in time, you have to talk about wormholes. Officially known as Einstein-Rosen bridges, these are theoretical "tunnels" through the fabric of spacetime. Imagine a piece of paper. You're an ant at one end, and you want to get to the other. You can walk across the whole sheet, or you can fold the paper and poke a hole through it.

👉 See also: The iPod is officially discontinued: Why it still matters and what it changed forever

That’s the shortcut.

The math, first proposed by Albert Einstein and Nathan Rosen in 1935, says these tunnels could exist. But there's a massive, glaring catch. To keep a wormhole open long enough for anything—let alone a human in a DeLorean—to pass through, you’d need something called "exotic matter." This isn't just stuff you find in a lab. It’s matter with negative energy density. It literally pushes space outward. Without it, the wormhole collapses instantly into a black hole. We haven't found any exotic matter yet. We aren’t even sure it’s allowed to exist in large quantities.

Ronald Mallett and the Ring Laser Experiment

While most scientists look at the stars, Professor Ronald Mallett at the University of Connecticut looked at light. Mallett has spent a huge chunk of his career trying to figure out a way of going back in time using lasers. His theory is based on the idea that if gravity can bend time, and light can create gravity, then a circulating beam of light might be able to "twist" time into a loop.

He calls it a "ring laser."

The idea is to create a circulating cylinder of light that drags the space inside it. Think of it like stirring a cup of coffee with a spoon; the spoon is the light, and the coffee is space itself. If you stir it hard enough, you might create a "Closed Timelike Curve" (CTC). Mallett’s work is controversial. Many of his peers, like Ken Olum and Allen Everett, have pointed out flaws, arguing that his laser would need to be infinitely long or require more energy than the universe provides. But Mallett’s drive comes from a deeply human place—the death of his father when he was a boy. It's a reminder that even the most complex science is often driven by our basic desire to fix what’s broken.

The Grandfather Paradox and the Multiverse Safety Net

Let’s say you actually do it. You build the machine, you find the exotic matter, and you go back. Now you have to deal with the logic. The "Grandfather Paradox" is the classic headache: if you go back and stop your grandfather from meeting your grandmother, you are never born. If you aren't born, you can't go back. If you don't go back, they do meet.

Your brain hurts yet?

Novikov’s Self-Consistency Principle suggests that the universe simply won't let you change things. It says the probability of an event that creates a paradox is zero. You might go back to stop a fire, but your very presence there is what accidentally knocks over the candle. You were always part of the history.

On the flip side, the Many-Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics—pioneered by Hugh Everett III—gives us a way out. It suggests that when you "go back," you’re actually stepping into a parallel timeline. You can prevent the fire there, but in your original timeline, the house still burned down. You’ve just created a new branch of reality. It’s a cleaner solution, but it means you can never really "fix" your own past; you just visit a version of it that goes better.

Why Entropy Is the Ultimate Veto

Here is the real kicker: The Second Law of Thermodynamics. It states that entropy—basically, disorder—always increases in a closed system.

Time has an arrow.

The universe likes to move from order (a whole egg) to disorder (a scrambled egg). To reverse time, you’d have to reverse entropy on a universal scale. It’s like trying to un-drop a glass of milk. While the equations of physics (like those in General Relativity) are technically time-symmetric—meaning they work just as well going forward or backward—the reality of the universe is messy and chaotic.

Modern Tech and the "Soft" Way Back

We might never build a physical booth that transports us to the Victorian era. But the technology for "digital" time travel is getting weirdly good. We’re already seeing "deadbots" and AI-driven recreations of historical figures based on their writings and voice recordings. It isn't going back in time in a physical sense, but for the human brain, the line is blurring.

We also have the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). Every time that telescope looks at a distant galaxy, it is looking into the past. Because light takes millions of years to reach us, we aren't seeing those stars as they are now; we're seeing them as they were shortly after the Big Bang. It’s a passive form of time travel, but it’s the only one we can prove works 100% of the time.

The Realities of Time Dilation

If you aren't picky about going backward, going forward is actually pretty easy. Just get moving.

Russian cosmonaut Gennady Padalka spent 879 days in space. Because he was traveling at high speeds relative to people on Earth, he experienced time slightly differently. When he returned, he was technically 0.02 seconds younger than he would have been had he stayed on the ground. He is, by all definitions, a time traveler. He went into the future.

To make a significant jump—say, a hundred years—you’d need a ship that can travel at a significant fraction of the speed of light. If you traveled at 99.9% the speed of light for what felt like five years to you, you’d come back to find that decades, or even centuries, had passed on Earth. Everyone you knew would be gone. This is "Twin Paradox" territory, and it’s a one-way trip. There's no return flight.

Actionable Insights for the Time-Obsessed

While we wait for a breakthrough in quantum gravity or the discovery of negative mass, there are ways to engage with the concept of time that don't involve breaking the laws of physics.

  • Study Special Relativity: To understand why time is fluid, you have to understand the math. Start with Einstein's "Relativity: The Special and General Theory." It’s surprisingly readable for a book that changed the world.
  • Track "Real" Time Travel: Follow the updates from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN. They aren't building a TARDIS, but they are smashing particles to understand the conditions of the early universe—essentially looking back at the beginning of time.
  • Archive Your Own History: If the goal of going back in time is preservation, use high-fidelity digital archiving. Use M-DISC technology for long-term data storage that lasts 1,000 years, far longer than a standard hard drive or cloud account.
  • Visit the Past Geologically: If you want to see what the world looked like millions of years ago, visit the Grand Canyon or the Burgess Shale. These sites are physical records of deep time, showing layers of history that predate humans by eons.

The dream of physically stepping into the past remains out of reach for now. The energy requirements are too high, the paradoxes are too messy, and we still haven't figured out how to keep a wormhole from snapping shut on our heads. But the fact that the math almost allows it is enough to keep the search alive. We are a species that hates losing things—people, opportunities, moments. As long as we have regrets, we will keep looking for a way to turn the clock back.