Memory is a weird, glitchy thing. You’re just sitting there, maybe stuck in traffic or waiting for the microwave to beep, and suddenly a smell or a specific chord in a song hits you. Boom. You're thinking about her. Girlfriends from the past have a way of sticking around in the attic of your brain long after the boxes are supposed to be taped shut. It isn't always about "the one that got away" or some dramatic, cinematic regret. Sometimes it’s just the brain doing its weird filing thing. Honestly, it's normal.
Human psychology is messy. Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist who has spent decades studying the brain in love, points out that romantic rejection and long-term attachment trigger the same parts of the brain associated with physical pain and addiction. When we think about old partners, we aren't just remembering a person; we are often revisiting a version of ourselves that doesn't exist anymore.
👉 See also: James A. Smith Obituary: Why This Man’s Legacy Still Matters
The Science of Why They Stick Around
Your brain isn't a hard drive. It's more like a living, breathing web of associations. When you were with those girlfriends from the past, your brain was literally being rewired. Neurotransmitters like dopamine and oxytocin created deep grooves. This is why you can remember the exact layout of an apartment you haven't stepped foot in for twelve years but can't remember where you put your car keys ten minutes ago.
There is also this thing called the Zeigarnik Effect. Essentially, the human brain hates unfinished business. If a relationship ended abruptly—or even if it just faded out without a "movie moment" of closure—your brain keeps the tab open in the background like a browser window you forgot to close. It’s trying to solve a puzzle that might not even have all the pieces anymore.
Digital Ghosting and the Social Media Trap
Technology has made moving on objectively harder. In the 90s, if you broke up, you might have a few photos in a shoebox. Maybe you’d see them at a grocery store once a year. Now? They are everywhere.
The phenomenon of "orbiting" is real. That’s when an ex doesn't talk to you but watches every single one of your Instagram stories. It keeps the connection on life support. According to a study published in Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, people who remain "friends" with exes on social media often experience higher levels of distress and lower personal growth. It’s basically digital masochism. You see a photo of them at a wedding and your brain does a backflip trying to figure out if that guy next to them is a cousin or a new boyfriend. It’s exhausting.
Comparison is the Thief of Contentment
We tend to "rosy retrospect." That’s the fancy psychological term for filtering out the bad stuff. You remember the time you laughed until you cried on that road trip, but you conveniently forget the three-hour argument about directions that preceded it. This creates a "phantom ex" scenario.
When your current life gets stressful, your brain retreats to the idealized version of girlfriends from the past. It’s a defense mechanism. You aren't necessarily missing her; you’re missing a time when you felt younger, or more spontaneous, or less burdened by taxes and career anxiety.
The Role of "The One That Got Away"
Is there actually such a thing? Probably not in a mathematical sense. But emotionally, it’s a powerful narrative. Author and researcher Dr. Nancy Kalish conducted a landmark study on "rekindled romances" and found that people who reconnect with lost loves often find the intensity is just as high decades later.
However, there’s a catch.
Most of these reunions work best when the original breakup was caused by external factors—like moving for college or parental interference—rather than internal ones like personality clashes or betrayal. If you broke up because you couldn't stop fighting about how to spend money, you're probably still going to fight about that twenty years later. The "past" part of girlfriends from the past is usually where they belong for a reason.
💡 You might also like: Fresh Christmas Ideas for Bulletin Board Displays That Actually Look Good
How to Actually Clean Out the Mental Attic
If you find yourself stuck in a loop of nostalgia, you have to be proactive. You can't just wait for the thoughts to stop. That’s not how brains work.
- Audit your digital space. If seeing her name pop up makes your stomach drop, hit the mute button. You don't have to be dramatic and "block" everyone, but "out of sight, out of mind" is a cliché because it’s true.
- Write the "True Story" list. If you’re romanticizing an ex, grab a notebook. Write down five things that were actually terrible about the relationship. Be specific. The time she insulted your favorite hobby. The way she’d go silent for two days when she was mad. It balances the scales.
- Identify the trigger. Are you thinking about her because you're lonely, or because you're bored? Usually, nostalgia is a symptom of a current need not being met.
- Acknowledge the growth. It’s okay to be grateful for what you learned. Maybe one of those girlfriends from the past taught you how to cook, or introduced you to your favorite band, or showed you what you don't want in a partner. That’s value you get to keep.
Moving Toward Real Closure
Closure isn't something someone else gives you. It isn't a final conversation or a "we need to talk" coffee date. Honestly, those usually just make things worse and lead to more confusion.
Real closure is just the realization that the person you remember doesn't exist anymore. People change. Cells regenerate. The girl you dated in 2018 is effectively a different person now, and so are you. You’re mourning a ghost.
The goal isn't to reach a state of total amnesia. That’s impossible unless you have a traumatic brain injury. The goal is to get to a point where the memory is just a neutral fact. Like knowing the capital of Ohio. It’s just information. No sting. No heart rate spike. Just a part of your history that helped build the person you are standing as today.
Actionable Steps for the Here and Now
- Stop the "Investigation": If you are checking her LinkedIn or Venmo history, stop. It’s a hit of cheap dopamine that leaves you feeling hungover. Delete the bookmarks.
- Focus on "Future You": Spend the energy you’re using on nostalgia to plan something for next month. A trip, a new gym routine, or even just finishing a book.
- Talk it out, but once: Vent to a friend for thirty minutes. Get it all out. Then, ask that friend to tell you to shut up if you bring it up again for the rest of the night.
- Practice Mindfulness: When the thought of a past girlfriend enters your head, acknowledge it. "Oh, there’s that thought again." Then, focus on the feeling of your feet on the floor. It sounds hippy-dippy, but it breaks the neural loop.
- Re-frame the Narrative: Stop calling them "mistakes." Call them "training." You're a more complex, seasoned version of yourself because of those experiences. Use that seasoning for your current or future relationship instead of wasting it on a memory.