:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/LBB-Lemon-Ups-Cookie-2000-d59e894d16984d33b3ac12319e872df6.png)
You know that feeling when you open a fresh box of Girl Scout cookies and the smell just hits you? It’s basically a core memory for most of us. But while everyone usually fights over the Thin Mints or the Samoas (or Caramel deLites, depending on your local baker), there’s a relatively new kid on the block that’s been causing quite a stir since 2020. I'm talking about Girl Scout cookies Lemon Ups. Honestly, they aren't just your standard lemon shortbread. They’re kind of a vibe shift for the whole organization.
When these dropped, they replaced the older Savannah Smiles in many regions. People were devastated. Change is hard, especially when it involves sugar. But Lemon Ups brought something different to the table: a glazed bottom and messages of empowerment stamped right into the dough. It’s weirdly motivating to eat a cookie that tells you "I am a go-getter" before you dunk it in tea.
The Science of the Crunch: What Makes Lemon Ups Different?
If you’re expecting a soft, pillowy lemon cake, look elsewhere. These are crunchy. They have a specific snap that reminds me of a high-end digestive biscuit but with a bright, citrusy punch. The design is pretty intentional. One side is a smooth, lemon-flavored glaze that provides most of the sweetness, while the other is the embossed shortbread.
There are two main commercial bakers for the Girl Scouts: ABC Bakers and Little Brownie Bakers. This is where things get a bit confusing for the average buyer. Depending on where you live, you might get Lemon Ups or you might get Lemonades. They aren't the same. Lemonades (from ABC) are a shortbread cookie with a slice-of-lemon design and a tangy icing, whereas Lemon Ups (from Little Brownie Bakers) are the ones with the inspirational phrases.
The Nutritional Reality
Look, nobody is buying these for a health kick. But if you’re tracking your macros or just curious, a serving size is typically two cookies. That'll run you about 140 calories. They use real lemon juice—sorta. It’s mostly natural flavors and citric acid doing the heavy lifting to get that tartness.
Is there a lot of sugar? Yes.
Is there palm oil? Unfortunately, yes, though the Girl Scouts of the USA (GSUSA) claim they are committed to sustainable sourcing through the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO).
It’s a complex issue. Most mass-produced snacks rely on palm oil for that specific shelf-stable texture. If you’re someone who strictly avoids it, these might be a skip, but for the once-a-year treat, most people give it a pass.
Why the Phrases Actually Matter
It sounds cheesy. I get it. Stamping words like "I am an innovator" or "I am a leader" onto a snack feels like peak corporate branding. But for the Girl Scouts, this was a strategic pivot. They wanted the cookies to reflect the actual mission of the program, which is leadership development.
I talked to a local troop leader last year who mentioned that the younger scouts actually use the cookies as a talking point. When a kid sells a box of Girl Scout cookies Lemon Ups, they aren't just selling a snack; they’re selling the idea of confidence. It’s marketing, sure, but it’s marketing with a soul.
The phrases you'll usually find include:
- I am a leader
- I am an innovator
- I am a go-getter
- I am a risk-taker
- I am creative
- I am resilient
They vary. Sometimes you get a box that seems to have ten "creative" cookies and zero "leaders." It’s the luck of the draw.
The Great Lemon Debate: Lemon Ups vs. Lemonades vs. Savannah Smiles
We have to address the elephant in the room. The "Lemon-Gate" of the cookie world. For years, the Savannah Smile—a dusted, lemon-flavored powdered sugar nugget—was the gold standard. When GSUSA phased them out for Lemon Ups, the internet went through the five stages of grief.
Savannah Smiles were messy. You’d finish a bag and look like you’d just been through a flour explosion. Lemon Ups are much cleaner. The glaze stays on the cookie. No powdered sugar on your black leggings.
But flavor-wise? They are worlds apart. Savannah Smiles were tart and acidic. Lemon Ups are sweeter and more balanced. If you prefer a shortbread texture over a melting-in-your-mouth sensation, you’ll probably lean toward the current iteration.
Distribution Map Shenanigans
Where you live determines your cookie fate. It’s basically a geographic lottery.
If your local council is served by Little Brownie Bakers (LBB), you get Lemon Ups. If they use ABC Bakers, you get Lemonades. People often move across the country and realize their favorite cookie "tastes different." It’s not your imagination. The recipes, ingredients, and even the names change. For example, LBB makes Samoas, while ABC makes Caramel deLites. They look similar, but the coconut-to-chocolate ratio is tweaked.
How to Level Up Your Lemon Ups
Eating them straight out of the box is fine. It’s the classic move. But if you want to be a bit "extra," there are ways to incorporate these into actual desserts.
- The Cheesecake Crust: Pulse a box of Lemon Ups in a food processor with a bit of melted butter. It makes a killer base for a blueberry or raspberry cheesecake. The lemon notes in the crust cut right through the heavy cream cheese.
- Ice Cream Sandwiches: Take two cookies, slap a scoop of high-quality vanilla bean ice cream in the middle, and freeze them for an hour. The glaze on the bottom of the cookie acts as a moisture barrier so they don't get soggy immediately.
- Tea Pairing: These are surprisingly good with Earl Grey. The bergamot in the tea plays really nicely with the lemon zestiness of the cookie.
The Logistics of Buying in 2026
It’s getting easier to find them, but the "season" is still a thing. Usually, it runs from January to April. However, with the Digital Cookie platform, you don’t necessarily have to hunt down a booth outside a grocery store anymore.
The price has been creeping up. You’ve probably noticed. Inflation hits everything, even the scouts. Depending on your region, a box might cost you $6 or even $7 now. It’s a steep jump from the $3.50 or $4 of a decade ago.
Does the money actually go to the girls? Mostly. The council takes a cut for programming and camps, the baker gets paid for the product, and the local troop gets a portion (usually around 15-20%) to fund their specific activities. When you buy a box of Girl Scout cookies Lemon Ups, you’re essentially micro-funding a camping trip or a STEM project.
Myths and Misconceptions
There’s a weird rumor that circulates every year that Girl Scout cookies are "fake" or "plastic." That’s just internet nonsense. They are shelf-stable processed foods, yes, but they meet all FDA standards.
Another common mistake is thinking you can buy these year-round at the grocery store. You’ll see "tributes" or "knock-offs" from brands like Keebler or Dollar General. Some are decent. None are exactly the same. The Keebler "Lemonade" style cookies are close, but they lack that specific Lemon Up crunch and the embossed messaging.
Final Thoughts for the Cookie Season
If you haven't tried them yet, get one box. Just one. They are the perfect palate cleanser after you’ve downed an entire sleeve of Thin Mints. They feel a bit more "adult" than the chocolate-heavy options, and they actually hold up well if you store them in the freezer.
The reality is that Girl Scout cookies Lemon Ups represent a shift in how the organization sees itself. They aren't just selling sugar; they are selling a brand identity. Whether you care about the "Go-Getter" message or you just want a citrusy snack to go with your coffee, these cookies have earned their spot in the lineup.
Next time you see a troop setting up a table, don't just grab the usual. Take a look at the Lemon Ups. They might surprise you with how well that glaze balances out the tartness.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check the Baker: Look at the side of the box or ask the scout which bakery they use. If it's Little Brownie Bakers, you're getting the authentic Lemon Ups.
- Freeze a Box: Lemon-flavored cookies actually taste sharper and more refreshing when consumed cold.
- Support Locally: Use the "Cookie Finder" app to locate a booth nearby rather than buying marked-up boxes from third-party resellers on eBay or Amazon.
- Check for Allergens: Always read the label if you have sensitivities, as these do contain wheat, soy, and milk, and are often processed in plants that handle peanuts.
The cookie season is short. Don't overthink it—just enjoy the crunch. Every box sold is a tiny investment in a kid's future leadership skills, which makes the sugar rush feel a little more justified.