You’re sitting in the parking lot, staring at the designated "Curbside" sign, wondering if you actually remembered to add the heavy cream to your cart. We've all been there. Groceries are a chore. Giant Eagle pick up—officially branded as Curbside Pickup—is supposed to be the antidote to that hour-long wander through the aisles where you inevitably buy three things you didn't need and forget the one thing you did.
It works. Mostly.
But if you’ve used it more than once, you know it isn't always a seamless teleportation of food into your trunk. There are weird quirks with the "eAdvantage" offers, the way substitutions happen, and the specific timing of when your credit card actually gets hit. Getting the most out of Giant Eagle pick up requires a bit more strategy than just clicking "place order" and hoping for the best.
The Reality of Curbside Convenience
Let's talk about the elephant in the room: the price. One of the biggest misconceptions is that you’re paying a massive premium for someone else to walk the aisles. Honestly, for most orders over $35, the pickup fee is waived. That’s the industry standard now, similar to what you’ll see at Kroger or Walmart. However, Giant Eagle does something slightly different with their pricing structure.
The prices you see online are generally the same as the in-store prices, provided you’ve linked your myPerks or Advantage Card. If you haven't done that, you’re basically throwing money away. The system relies on that loyalty link to apply the "Big Red" coupons and the weekly circular deals. Without it, you’re paying "guest" prices, which are significantly higher.
Timing matters too.
If you place an order at 10:00 AM on a Tuesday, your experience will be wildly different than a 5:00 PM Sunday rush. Why? Because the "personal shoppers" are human beings. On a slow Tuesday, they have time to pick the best-looking honeycrisp apples. On a Sunday afternoon, they’re sprinting. If you want high-quality produce, you have to time your slot for the morning when the shelves are freshly stocked and the pickers aren't under the gun.
How the Substitution Game Really Works
Substitutions are the bane of the online grocery world. You want the 16-ounce organic peanut butter, but they're out. Do they give you the 40-ounce conventional tub or nothing at all?
Giant Eagle’s app allows you to set preferences for every single item. This is the part everyone skips because it's tedious. Don't skip it. If you’re picky about your bread brands, mark "Do Not Substitute." If you’re flexible, you can leave a note. Pro tip: The notes field is actually read by the shoppers. If you write "Please get the greenest bananas possible," they usually try to make it happen.
There is a specific logic to how they charge for subs. Usually, if they swap an item for something more expensive, you might end up paying that higher price unless there’s a specific store policy in place for that week’s promotion. It's inconsistent. Check your receipt before you leave the parking lot. Once you drive away, getting a refund for a weird substitution becomes a three-day customer service saga involving phone calls and "let me speak to a lead" conversations.
Dealing with the myPerks Transition
Giant Eagle has been aggressively moving everyone from the old Fuelperks+ system to the newer myPerks program. It's confusing. Basically, myPerks is more flexible—you can choose between gas discounts or money off your groceries. When you use Giant Eagle pick up, your perks are calculated based on the final total after any out-of-stock items are removed.
Wait.
Did you know your "Pay at Pickup" option is essentially gone at most locations? Most orders are now pre-authorized on your card. The "pending" charge on your bank account will almost always be slightly higher (usually around 10-15%) than your actual total. This is a "buffer" for weighted items like meat and produce. If you buy a steak that is 1.2 lbs instead of 1.0 lbs, the store needs to know the funds are there. Don't panic when you see a $120 charge for a $100 order; it settles to the correct amount within a few business days.
Navigating the App Without Losing Your Mind
The Giant Eagle app is... fine. It’s not a masterpiece of software engineering. It can be laggy, especially when searching for niche items like "gluten-free tamari" or "specific brand of Greek yogurt."
📖 Related: Mizzou Out of State Tuition: Why That Price Tag Isn't What You’ll Actually Pay
- Use the Barcode Scanner: If you’re at home and just finished a box of cereal, scan the barcode with your phone. It’s 10x faster than typing.
- Check the "Weekly Ad" Section First: Instead of searching, browse the digital circular. This ensures you’re actually getting the deals that make Giant Eagle worth the trip.
- The "Clip" Factor: You have to manually "clip" digital coupons in the app. They don't just apply because the item is in your cart. This is a major point of friction. If you don't click that little plus sign, you pay full price. It’s annoying, but it’s how they track engagement.
What Happens at the Curb?
When you arrive, you follow the signs to the Curbside area. You’re supposed to "Check In" via the app or by calling the number on the sign.
The app check-in is superior because it uses GPS to tell the staff you’re close. If you wait until you’re in the parking spot to check in, you’re going to wait 10 minutes. If you check in when you’re 2 miles away, they usually have the bins staged and ready to roll the second you pull in.
One thing people often ask: Should you tip? Giant Eagle policy generally discourages it, as these are hourly employees part of the store staff, unlike Instacart drivers who are independent contractors. However, during a blizzard or a 95-degree heatwave, a few bucks is a kind gesture that most employees won't turn down, even if they aren't technically supposed to solicit it.
The Produce Problem
Let’s be real. Trusting a stranger to pick your avocados is an act of extreme faith. Many people refuse to use Giant Eagle pick up for this exact reason. They’ll buy their canned goods, paper towels, and frozen pizzas online, then park and run inside for five minutes just to grab the fruit.
If you want to avoid that, use the "Instructions" box. Be specific. "Smallest head of cabbage" or "Three yellow bananas, two green ones." The more specific you are, the less likely you are to end up with a bag of mushy tomatoes.
Also, check the "Sell By" dates on your dairy. Occasionally, pickers will grab the item at the very front of the shelf because it’s faster. That’s usually the item that expires in two days. If you get home and find your milk is about to turn, call the store. They are usually very good about giving a credit to your account without making you drive back.
Is it Actually Faster?
Sometimes, no.
If you factor in the time spent navigating the app, clipping coupons, and waiting in the parking lot, you might only save 20 minutes. But it’s not just about the minutes. It’s about the mental load. It’s about not having to navigate a crowded store with a cart that has one wonky wheel while a toddler has a meltdown in aisle four.
For many, the value of Giant Eagle pick up is in the budgeting. When you shop online, you see your total in real-time. There is no "checkout shock." You can see you’re at $150 and decide you don't actually need the $12 artisanal cheese, so you remove it. That’s hard to do when you’re already standing at the register with a line of people behind you.
Hidden Features You Might Miss
There are a few "pro" moves that regular users swear by.
First, the Pharmacy integration. In many locations, you can coordinate your prescription pickup with your grocery order. You have to handle the pharmacy side separately in their specific app or via phone, but you can often get them brought out at the same time.
Second, the Alcohol policy. Yes, you can order beer and wine in many states (like Ohio or Pennsylvania, depending on local laws). You just have to have your ID ready. They won't just leave it in the trunk; they have to physically see you and scan the ID.
📖 Related: August 10 Which Day: Why This Date Actually Matters More Than You Think
Third, the Paper Bag vs. Plastic debate. Depending on your local municipality’s laws and Giant Eagle's sustainability initiatives, you might see a small charge for bags. You can sometimes opt for "no bags" if you have your own crates in the trunk, though this varies by store. It’s worth asking the attendant the first time you go.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Order
Don't just wing it next time. If you want the smoothest experience possible, follow this specific workflow:
- Sync the Card: Ensure your myPerks or Advantage Card is definitely linked. Check your profile. If it says "Guest," stop and fix it or you'll pay 20% more.
- Shop the Circular: Go to the "Weekly Ad" tab first. Clip the coupons for things you were going to buy anyway.
- The 48-Hour Rule: Start your cart a day or two early. You can add things as you realize you're out. Just make sure to "Update Order" before the cutoff time (usually 4-6 hours before pickup).
- Morning Slots: Aim for a pickup between 8:00 AM and 11:00 AM. The store is cleaner, the staff is fresher, and the out-of-stock items are minimal.
- Check the "Total": Look at your email confirmation. If a "Must Buy 2" deal didn't trigger, it’s because a coupon didn't clip or an item was slightly different than the one in the ad.
- The "Two-Mile" Check-In: Signal you're coming when you're a few minutes away, not when you're already parked. It cuts your wait time in half.
- Inspect the "Big Three": Before you drive away, pop the trunk and quickly glance at the eggs (cracks?), the bread (squashed?), and the meat (correct cut?). It’s much easier to fix a mistake while the employee is still standing there.
Giant Eagle pick up isn't perfect, but it's a massive tool for anyone trying to claw back some time in their week. Once you get past the initial learning curve of the app and the coupon clipping, it becomes a predictable part of the routine. Just keep an eye on those substitutions and always, always clip those digital coupons.