Finding a "good" pizza joint in New Jersey isn't exactly a challenge. You can basically throw a rock and hit a decent margherita pie. But Gianni's Pizzeria Little Silver is one of those spots that locals guard like a secret, even though the parking lot is constantly packed.
It's located at 495 Prospect Ave, right in that sweet spot where Little Silver, Red Bank, and Oceanport all sort of blur together. If you’ve lived in Monmouth County for more than a week, you've probably seen the white delivery cars zipping around. But there’s a specific culture to this place that goes beyond just "fast delivery."
The Legendary Chicken Vodka Wrap
Honestly, we have to start here. If you walk into Gianni's and don't hear someone order a Chicken Vodka Wrap, you might actually be in a simulation. It’s the undisputed heavyweight champion of their menu.
Most places do a vodka sauce that’s either too watery or tastes like plain marinara with a splash of cream. Gianni’s is different. It’s thick, orange, and slightly sweet but carries that punchy depth you only get from a slow simmer. They take breaded chicken cutlets—crispy, not soggy—and tuck them into a wrap with that sauce and a massive amount of melted mozzarella.
It’s heavy. It’s a nap in a tortilla. It's also remarkably consistent. You’ve probably had "signature dishes" at other places that are hit-or-miss depending on who is working the line. At Gianni's in Little Silver, that wrap tastes the same on a Tuesday afternoon as it does on a frantic Friday night.
👉 See also: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
More Than Just a Pizza Shop
While "Pizzeria" is in the name, the Little Silver location functions more like a high-volume Italian kitchen. Their menu is surprisingly deep.
What to Actually Order (Besides the Wrap)
- The Penne Vodka: If you like the wrap, the pasta version is the logical next step. They don't skimp on the prosciutto bits in the sauce, which adds a salty, smoky layer most people miss.
- Grandma Pie: It’s thin, crunchy, and topped with fresh basil and spots of mozzarella. It’s a bit lighter than their standard round pies if you’re not looking to feel like a lead balloon afterward.
- Chicken Portobello Salad: Kinda funny to recommend a salad at a pizza place, but they do it right. It’s loaded with roasted red peppers and marinated mushrooms. It’s actually a "real" meal, not just an afterthought of iceberg lettuce.
- The Buffalo Chicken Pizza: It’s got a kick. They use a buffalo sauce that actually respects the vinegary heat of a real wing sauce instead of just being orange oil.
The Little Silver Vibe
The shop itself isn't a "fine dining" destination. Let’s be real. It’s a classic Jersey counter-service spot. There are tables, and you can definitely sit down with the kids after a soccer game, but the energy is focused on the hustle.
The staff there handles a ridiculous volume of orders. On a Friday night, the phone rings incessantly, and the "Order Up!" bell is a constant soundtrack. Despite the chaos, there’s a rhythm to it. They’ve been part of the community since the early 90s—1992, specifically—and that longevity shows in how they handle the local rush.
One thing people often overlook is their involvement with the town. If you check the Little Silver Recreation sponsor lists, Gianni’s is almost always there. They feed the local kids, they sponsor the sports teams, and they've become a literal landmark for people giving directions: "Make a left at the Gianni's."
✨ Don't miss: Curtain Bangs on Fine Hair: Why Yours Probably Look Flat and How to Fix It
Navigating the Menu Like a Pro
If you’re a first-timer or just haven't branched out, there are a few "pro moves" to keep in mind.
First, the portions are massive. A "small" salad can easily be shared by two people. The wraps are essentially two meals if you have any self-control (which, let's be honest, most of us don't when vodka sauce is involved).
Second, they offer gluten-free crusts. In a town like Little Silver where health-conscious diets are common, they’ve adapted well. It’s a 10-inch thin crust that actually holds up to toppings without turning into a cracker or a sponge.
Third, if you're ordering for a crowd, the Catering Trays are the way to go. Their Chicken Parm and Eggplant Rollatini trays are staples at graduation parties and Shore-house weekend hangouts. The Eggplant Rollatini is particularly good—stuffed with a ricotta blend that isn't grainy, which is a common sin in the world of catering-grade Italian food.
🔗 Read more: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
A Word on Consistency and Growth
Gianni's has expanded quite a bit. You’ll find locations in Oakhurst, Colts Neck, Neptune, and Red Bank. But each one has its own personality. The Little Silver spot feels the most "neighborhoody" because of its location. It's tucked away from the main highway madness of Route 35, making it a true local hub.
Are there ever bad days? Sure. Any high-volume kitchen will have a night where the garlic knots are a little too toasted or the delivery takes an extra twenty minutes because it’s raining and half the county ordered pizza at 6:15 PM. But the reason they’ve stayed in business since '92 while other shops open and close within eighteen months is that "floor." Their "bad day" is usually still better than most places' "good day."
Actionable Tips for Your Next Visit
If you're planning to hit up Gianni's Pizzeria Little Silver this week, here is the smart way to do it:
- Download the App: They have their own rewards program (the "Ribbon" system). You can earn points for free pizzas, which is a no-brainer if you’re a regular.
- Order the "Vodka Roll" for a Twist: If you want the flavor of the wrap but want something more "pizzaiolo," the Vodka Roll is fried chicken and sauce tucked into pizza dough. It’s a game-changer.
- Check the Daily Specials: They often have pasta specials or specific hero sandwiches that aren't on the permanent online menu. It’s worth asking what the "chef's special" is if you’re bored of your usual order.
- Time Your Pickups: If you're picking up on a Friday or Saturday, add ten minutes to whatever time they give you over the phone. It’s a busy spot, and quality takes a second.
- Try the Homemade Dressing: Their house Italian dressing is legit. It’s got that perfect herb-to-vinegar ratio that makes even a basic garden salad feel worth the money.
Whether you're stopping in after a beach day at Sea Bright or just grabbing a quick lunch before heading to the train station, Gianni's remains a pillar of the Monmouth County food scene. It’s not fancy, it’s not "artisanal" in a pretentious way—it’s just solid, reliable Jersey Italian food that hits the spot every single time.