Look, everyone thinks they know how to get to the Hamptons from NYC. You just hop on a train or drive out east, right? Well, sort of. But if you’ve ever spent four hours suffocating in a packed LIRR vestibule or sat staring at the brake lights of a Jitney on the Long Island Expressway for half a Saturday, you know it's rarely that simple. Getting out to the East End is basically a high-stakes chess match against traffic, timing, and your own wallet.
The truth is, your choice of transport says a lot about what kind of weekend you’re trying to have. Are you looking to save money for those $25 lobster rolls in Montauk? Or are you ready to burn cash to avoid the 495 crawl? There's no "best" way—only the way that sucks the least for your specific situation.
The LIRR and the Infamous Cannonball
Most people default to the Long Island Rail Road. It’s the classic move. You head to Penn Station or Grand Central Madison, grab a ticket to Southampton or East Hampton, and hope for the best.
The crown jewel—or the nightmare, depending on who you ask—is the Cannonball.
This is the only non-stop train from Manhattan to Westhampton. It leaves Penn Station on Friday afternoons, usually around 4:00 PM. It’s fast. It’s efficient. It’s also incredibly crowded. If you don't have a reserved seat in the Hamptons Reserve car, you might find yourself standing for two hours. Honestly, it's a bit of a scene. People start drinking rosè the second the train leaves the tunnel. It’s loud, it’s sweaty, but it gets you there in about 95 minutes to Westhampton and roughly two hours to Montauk.
If you miss the Cannonball, you’re looking at the regular Montauk branch trains. These usually require a transfer at Jamaica. Pro tip: Check the schedules for the new service out of Grand Central Madison. It has eased some of the Penn Station chaos, but Jamaica remains the bottleneck of the entire operation. If your connection is tight, you’re going to be sprinting across platforms with a weekend bag hitting your knees. Not fun.
The Hampton Jitney vs. The Luxury Liners
If you hate trains, you take the bus. But we’re not talking about a Greyhound here. The Hampton Jitney is a literal institution.
👉 See also: 3000 Yen to USD: What Your Money Actually Buys in Japan Today
It’s been running since the 70s and basically functions as the social circulatory system of the East End. There are three main lines: the North Fork, the Westhampton, and the Montauk. You pick it up at various stops along 3rd Avenue on the Upper East Side.
The Jitney is fine. It’s reliable. They give you a little snack and a bottle of water. But the real game-changer is the Hampton Ambassador. This is their "luxury" arm. Think wider seats, more legroom, and—crucially—fewer people. It costs more, but if you have to sit in three hours of traffic, you want to do it in a seat that actually reclines.
Then there’s Blade.
You've probably seen the helicopters buzzing over the East River. It’s the ultimate "I’ve made it" (or "I’m charging this to the company") move. It takes about 35 minutes. You fly out of the 34th Street Heliport and land in East Hampton or Southampton. Is it expensive? Extremely. We’re talking hundreds, sometimes over a thousand dollars for a seat. But you skip the LIE. You skip the LIRR. You basically buy back four hours of your life.
Driving Yourself: A Survival Guide
Driving is for the brave or the local. If you’re renting a car or taking your own, you are at the mercy of the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and the Sunrise Highway (Route 27).
Route 27 is the real killer. Once the LIE ends and it narrows down to a single lane in each direction through towns like Water Mill and Bridgehampton, everything grinds to a halt. This is known as the "Trade Parade" because of all the service trucks heading out in the morning and back in the evening.
✨ Don't miss: The Eloise Room at The Plaza: What Most People Get Wrong
If you must drive, leave at 10:00 AM on Thursday or 6:00 AM on Friday. If you wait until 4:00 PM on Friday, you might as well just walk. Also, watch out for the speed traps in Quogue and Sagaponack. The local cops do not play around, and they know exactly where the weekenders like to speed.
The Logistics Most People Forget
One thing nobody tells you: once you get off the train or the bus, how do you get to the house?
Ubers and Lyfts exist in the Hamptons, but they are wildly expensive and often have long wait times during peak hours. A ride from the East Hampton train station to a house in Northwest Woods can easily run you $60 for a ten-minute trip.
Many people rely on local taxi companies like M&V Limo or Hampton Taxi, but you usually have to call them in advance. If you're staying further out, like in Amagansett or Montauk, having a bike or a moped isn't a bad idea, though the roads are narrow and drivers are often... distracted.
Summary of Options
- LIRR Cannonball: Fastest for the price, but can be a frat party on rails.
- Hampton Ambassador: Best comfort-to-price ratio if you don't mind the traffic.
- Driving: Total freedom once you arrive, but a nightmare on the way there.
- Blade: For when time is worth more than a month's rent.
The Off-Peak Secret
If you want the "real" Hamptons experience without the soul-crushing commute, go in September.
The water is still warm, the restaurants actually have tables available, and getting to the Hamptons from NYC becomes a breeze. The LIRR isn't a sardine can, and the Jitney actually arrives on time. Most "locals" (the people who live there year-round) wait until after Labor Day to breathe.
🔗 Read more: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Next Steps
Before you book anything, do these three things:
1. Check the LIRR TrainTime app immediately. It’s the most accurate way to see real-time delays and track which platform you need at Jamaica. If you see a "sold out" sign for the Hamptons Reserve on the Cannonball, prepare to stand or book a Jitney instead.
2. Reserve your Jitney seat at least two weeks out. During July and August, the popular Thursday and Friday afternoon slots sell out fast. Don't be the person trying to book a seat at noon on Friday; you'll end up on the "late" bus that gets in at midnight.
3. Map your arrival to your destination. If your rental is more than 3 miles from a transport hub, pre-arrange a car service or check the availability of the "Circuit" electric shuttles which operate in certain villages like East Hampton and Southampton for free or very low cost.
Getting out there is a grind. But once you're sitting on Coopers Beach with a cold drink, you'll probably forget about the two-hour delay on the LIE. Probably.