You’re standing on the platform at Jersey City’s Exchange Place, staring across the Hudson River at the World Trade Center. It looks so close you could almost throw a stone and hit an office window. But honestly, getting from New Jersey to NY is less about distance and more about mastering a very specific, often chaotic dance of schedules, swipe cards, and sheer luck. People think it’s just a train ride. It isn't. It's a logistical puzzle that changes depending on whether it’s a rainy Tuesday or a Saturday night when the PATH train decides to run every 20 minutes instead of five.
New York City is the magnet. New Jersey is the backyard.
Every single day, hundreds of thousands of people make this trek. They aren't just commuters; they are experts in "the pivot." That’s when you see the NJ Transit board turn red with delays and immediately sprint toward the ferry or the PATH. If you're planning to move to the Garden State or just visiting for a Giants game, you need to know the reality. Forget the polished maps. The "best" way doesn't exist. There is only the "best way for right now."
The PATH Train vs. NJ Transit: Choosing Your Struggle
Most people lump all trains together. Huge mistake.
✨ Don't miss: La Quinta Inn NYC: What People Actually Think After Staying There
The PATH (Port Authority Trans-Hudson) is basically a subway. It runs 24/7. It connects Jersey City, Hoboken, Harrison, and Newark directly to Manhattan. It’s cheap—$2.75 a ride as of early 2026—and it’s generally the most reliable way to get into Lower Manhattan or the West Village. But here is the kicker: the weekend service is a whole different beast. If you’re coming from Hoboken on a Sunday, you’re likely taking a detour through Christopher Street before you ever see 33rd Street. It adds time. It adds frustration. You've been warned.
Then there’s NJ Transit. These are the big, double-decker "commuter" trains. They funnel into New York Penn Station.
If you are coming from further out—places like Montclair, Summit, or Princeton—this is your lifeline. The North East Corridor and the Coast Line are the heavy hitters. But New York Penn Station is currently a construction zone of varying intensities. The Gateway Tunnel project is finally underway to add more capacity, but until those new tunnels under the Hudson are finished closer to 2030, you are relying on century-old infrastructure. When a wire goes down in the Amtrak-owned North River Tunnel, everything stops. Just... stops.
Why the Bus is Secretly the Best (Sometimes)
Don't sleep on the bus. Seriously.
For folks in towns without a train station—think Weehawken, Union City, or even parts of Bergen County—the bus is king. Most of these lines spit you out at the Port Authority Bus Terminal (PABT) on 42nd Street.
Is the PABT pretty? No. It’s a labyrinth. But the "exclusive bus lane" (XBL) on the approach to the Lincoln Tunnel is a godsend during morning rush hour. It’s a dedicated lane that lets buses bypass miles of idling cars. You’ll zoom past Teslas and Ubers stuck in gridlock, feeling like a genius. Just keep in mind that the "outbound" trip in the afternoon doesn't have the same magic lane, so the ride home always feels longer. Always.
The Waterway Gamble
The NY Waterway ferry is the luxury choice for moving from New Jersey to NY. It’s fast. It’s breezy. It has a bar. It also costs significantly more—sometimes upwards of $9 to $18 for a single one-way trip depending on your departure point.
If you work in the Financial District or near Hudson Yards, the ferry is incredible. The Port Imperial terminal in Weehawken feels like an airport lounge. But you're paying for the privilege of not being underground. On a clear day, seeing the Manhattan skyline from the deck is worth every penny. On a foggy January morning when the Hudson is choppy? It feels a bit more like an expedition.
The ferry also runs "shuttle buses" on the New York side. They are free if you have a ferry ticket. They loop around Midtown and Downtown. Use them. Walking from the Pier 79 terminal at 39th Street to the middle of the city is further than it looks on a map, especially in a suit or heels.
Driving is a Trap
Just don’t. Unless you have a guaranteed, paid-for parking spot in Manhattan, driving from New Jersey to NY is a recipe for a mental breakdown.
The toll for the Holland Tunnel, Lincoln Tunnel, or George Washington Bridge is steep. Then there’s the congestion pricing in Lower Manhattan. New York City implemented its zone-based tolling to reduce traffic below 60th Street, meaning your "quick drive" could easily cost you $30 or $40 before you even pay for a parking garage.
- Holland Tunnel: Best for Lower Manhattan, but notoriously narrow lanes. If you are driving a large SUV, prepare for white-knuckle syndrome.
- Lincoln Tunnel: Direct access to Midtown. Usually the most congested because of the bus traffic.
- George Washington Bridge (GWB): The busiest bridge in the world. It connects Fort Lee to Upper Manhattan. It’s the only way to go if you’re heading to the Bronx or Connecticut, but the "lower level" vs. "upper level" choice is a daily lottery.
The "Secret" Connections
People often forget about the light rail. The Hudson-Bergen Light Rail doesn't go into New York. It stays in Jersey. But it connects the "Gold Coast" towns (Bayonne, Jersey City, Hoboken, Weehawken) to the PATH and Ferry hubs. If you find a cheap apartment in Bayonne, you can take the Light Rail to Exchange Place and then hop the PATH. It sounds like a lot of transfers. It is. But it’s often faster than driving two miles in heavy traffic.
Also, look at the E-ZPass discounts. If you absolutely must drive, make sure your account is set up for the "commuter" plans. Most people just pay the standard rate and lose hundreds of dollars a year. It’s a small detail that saves a lot of grocery money.
Dealing with "The Gap"
There is a weird phenomenon in New Jersey to NY travel: the 2:00 AM dead zone.
If you are out late in Manhattan, NJ Transit trains stop running around 1:00 or 1:30 AM. They don't start up again until 5:00 AM. If you miss that last train out of Penn Station, you are either taking a very expensive Uber (which will hit you with a "return toll" fee) or you’re heading to the PATH. The PATH runs all night, but after midnight, it switches to a "loop" service. Instead of separate trains for Hoboken and Jersey City, it combines them. You will sit at Christopher Street for ten minutes. You will go to Hoboken first even if you want to go to Newport. It’s a rite of passage.
👉 See also: 850 km to miles: What Most People Get Wrong About This Distance
Real Talk on Cost and Time
Let's break down a hypothetical commute from a popular spot like Montclair.
You leave your house at 7:30 AM. You drive to the Bay Street station. You pay for parking. The train ticket is roughly $8.00. The ride to Penn Station is about 45 minutes. Then you have to walk or take the subway to your office. Total time: 75 minutes. Total cost per day: roughly $20.
Compare that to living in Jersey City. You walk to the PATH. The ride is 15 minutes. Cost: $2.75.
This is why property values in Jersey City and Hoboken are basically the same as Brooklyn. You aren't just paying for an apartment; you are paying for those extra 10 hours a week you aren't sitting on a vinyl train seat.
Expert Tips for the Daily Grind
- Download the Apps: You need the NJ Transit app (for tickets and "DepartureVision"), the RidePATH app (for real-time train arrivals), and Citymapper. Google Maps is okay, but Citymapper handles the weirdness of the NY/NJ transfer points much better.
- The "Quiet Commute": On NJ Transit, the first and last cars of peak-hour trains are designated "Quiet Cars." No talking. No phone calls. No loud headphones. If you break the rules, a regular commuter will probably shush you within thirty seconds. It’s the closest thing to a library on wheels.
- The Newark Switch: Sometimes, the "direct" train to New York is delayed. You can often take a train to Newark Penn Station and then jump on a waiting PATH train or a different NJ Transit line. This is the pro move.
- Weather Proofing: The walk from the PATH to the subway at WTC or 33rd Street is all underground. You can stay dry. But if you’re taking the ferry, you are exposed to the elements. Dress in layers. The wind coming off the Hudson in February is no joke.
The reality of moving from New Jersey to NY is that you become a part-time meteorologist and a part-time civil engineer. You start noticing the tilt of the tracks and the sound of the tunnel fans. It’s a grind, sure. But there’s also something weirdly beautiful about that moment the train emerges from the tunnel and you see the skyline. Or when you’re on the ferry and the sun is setting behind the Statue of Liberty.
You’re in the middle of the world. You just happen to sleep on the other side of the river.
Your Next Move
If you’re planning this trip for the first time tomorrow, do yourself a favor. Don't buy a paper ticket at the machine. The lines are long and the machines are finicky. Download the NJ Transit app tonight, put your credit card info in, and buy a "One Way" ticket in advance. All you have to do is activate it when you see the train coming. This one tip will save you from missing your train while stuck behind a tourist trying to figure out how to insert a five-dollar bill. Check the "Service Advisory" section of the PATH or NJ Transit website about an hour before you leave. If there’s a "Cross-Honoring" notice, it means one system is broken and the other is taking their passengers for free. That’s your signal to change your route immediately.
The infrastructure is old, the crowds are thick, but the system works—as long as you know how to play the game. Keep your E-ZPass charged, your phone battery full, and your walking shoes on. You'll be a local in no time.