You’ve just stepped off a Metro-North train, the celestial ceiling of the Main Concourse is glowing above you, and suddenly it hits you: your Amtrak leaves from the other side of town in twenty minutes. Moving from Grand Central Terminal to Penn Station is a rite of passage for every New Yorker and a nightmare for every tourist. It’s only about a mile. You could practically throw a baseball and hit the Madison Square Garden marquee if the skyscrapers weren't in the way. But in Manhattan, that mile can feel like a marathon if you choose the wrong exit or get stuck in a gridlocked Uber on 42nd Street.
Honestly, people overthink this.
They stand in the middle of the terminal staring at Google Maps while commuters swarm around them like angry hornets. Don't be that person. Whether you’re hauling three suitcases or just sprinting with a briefcase, there are exactly three ways to do this trip effectively. Everything else is a waste of time.
The Shuttle Is Your Best Friend (Usually)
The "S" train—the 42nd Street Shuttle—is the classic way to handle the Grand Central Terminal to Penn Station trek. It’s a weird little stub of a subway line. It only goes back and forth between Grand Central and Times Square. That’s it. It’s basically a horizontal elevator.
You follow the gray "S" signs. You walk through those long, slightly subterranean-smelling tunnels. You hop on. Three minutes later, you're at Times Square.
Now, here is where people mess up. Once you get to Times Square, you have to transfer to the 1, 2, or 3 trains (the red line) heading downtown. It’s one stop to 34th Street–Penn Station. If you’re fast, the whole ordeal takes 15 minutes. If you’re slow or the MTA is having a "moment," give it 25.
But wait. There’s a catch.
The walk inside the stations is actually longer than the train ride itself. If you have heavy bags, those stairs at Times Square are going to feel like climbing Everest. And if it’s rush hour? Forget about personal space. You’ll be pressed up against a guy eating a bagel and a teenager playing TikToks without headphones. It’s the authentic New York experience, for better or worse.
Why the M42 Bus Is a Trap
Look, I get the appeal of the bus. You stay above ground. You see the Chrysler Building. You think, "Hey, I’ll just hop on the M42 or the M34."
Don't do it.
Midtown traffic is a sentient beast that feeds on your hopes and dreams. I once watched a man walk from Lexington Avenue to 8th Avenue faster than the bus moved. Unless it is 3:00 AM on a Tuesday or there’s a blizzard that cleared the streets of cars, the bus is a rolling parking lot. If you absolutely must stay above ground and can't walk, just grab a cab. At least in a yellow taxi, you have air conditioning and a driver who knows how to aggressively weave through delivery trucks.
✨ Don't miss: Weather for Jal NM: What Most People Get Wrong
The New Player: The LIRR at Grand Central Madison
For decades, the only way to get to Penn Station's rail lines was to actually go to Penn Station. But things changed recently. With the opening of Grand Central Madison—that massive, deep-earth cavern built under the existing terminal—the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) now runs into Grand Central.
This is a game-changer if your goal is actually just to get on a Long Island-bound train. You don't even need to go to Penn Station anymore for that.
However, if you are trying to reach Amtrak or NJ Transit, you still have to make the cross-town jump. Some people think they can take an LIRR train from Grand Central Madison to Penn Station. You can't. They are two different branches. It’s a common misconception that causes a lot of missed trains. Don't be the person arguing with a conductor because you thought the "City Ticket" worked like a subway transfer. It doesn't.
Walking: The "Secret" Fastest Way
If the weather is nice and you aren't carrying a literal trunk, just walk. Seriously.
💡 You might also like: American Airlines 191: What Most People Get Wrong About the Crash
Exit Grand Central on the 42nd Street side. Turn right. Walk down to 7th Avenue or 8th Avenue and then hang a left toward 34th Street. It’s about 15 to 20 minutes of brisk walking.
Why is this better?
- Predictability. You aren't waiting for a train that might be delayed.
- The Sights. You walk past the New York Public Library and Bryant Park.
- Health. You’ll burn off that $9 terminal croissant.
The route is simple: 42nd St to 7th Ave, then down to 34th. Penn Station is tucked right under Madison Square Garden. You can't miss it—it's the building that looks like a giant concrete cylinder compared to the architectural masterpiece you just left.
The Ride-Share Reality Check
Uber, Lyft, Revel—they all exist. They are all expensive. On a Friday afternoon, a ride from Grand Central Terminal to Penn Station might cost you $30 and take 40 minutes.
If you have a ton of luggage, you don't have much choice. But pro tip: walk one block away from the terminal entrance before calling your ride. Trying to get an Uber to find you in the chaos of the Grand Central taxi stand is a recipe for a "Driver Cancelled" notification. Walk to 43rd and Vanderbilt. It’s quieter. It’s easier. Your sanity is worth the extra 100 steps.
Navigating the Penn Station "Labyrinth"
Once you actually arrive at 34th Street, your journey isn't over. Penn Station is famously confusing. It’s divided into different concourses:
- Moynihan Train Hall: This is where you go for Amtrak. It’s beautiful, across 8th Avenue from the "old" Penn, and actually has decent food.
- NJ Transit Concourse: Located mostly between 7th and 8th Avenues.
- LIRR Concourse: The lower levels.
If you are taking an Amtrak, tell your driver to drop you at Moynihan, not Penn Station. It will save you a ten-minute walk through a crowded basement.
Summary of Actionable Steps
Stop stressing and just follow this logic tree for your next cross-town transfer:
💡 You might also like: Outer Banks Motel Buxton: Why This Old-School Spot Still Wins Over Luxury Resorts
- Traveling light and on a budget? Take the "S" Shuttle to Times Square, transfer to the downtown 1, 2, or 3 train for one stop. Total cost: $2.90.
- Have 20 minutes and want some air? Walk down 42nd Street to 7th Avenue, then south to 34th Street. It’s a straight shot.
- Carrying heavy bags? Take a Yellow Cab from the official stand on 42nd and Vanderbilt. Avoid the "illegal" livery drivers who approach you inside the terminal.
- Headed to Long Island? Check the boards for Grand Central Madison before you even leave the building. You might not need to go to Penn at all.
- Headed to Amtrak? Aim for Moynihan Train Hall (8th Ave), not the main Penn Station entrance on 7th Ave.
New York moves fast, and the connection between these two hubs is the heartbeat of the city's transit. Stick to the subway or your own two feet, and you'll almost always beat the traffic. Ignore the "helpful" people offering private rides and keep your eyes on the overhead signage. You've got this.