You’re standing in the Hotel Krat, the record player is silent, and that "Golden" trophy feels miles away. Honestly, collecting every single vinyl in Lies of P is a total headache if you aren't paying attention to the subtle cues Neowiz tucked away in the side quests. It’s not just about finding items; it’s about lying your heart out—or telling the truth when the moment demands it. If you want to get how to get all records lies of p figured out, you have to realize right now that you cannot do this in a single playthrough.
It’s physically impossible.
The game forces you into binary choices. You either get one record or the other based on a specific dialogue branch. This means you’re looking at a minimum of two full runs through the nightmare of Krat.
Most people mess up the "Lie" system early on. They think they have to lie 100% of the time to get the rewards, but the records are tied to specific NPC outcomes. You need to understand how "Humanity" functions as a hidden stat. When you see the message "The gears are turning" or "You feel warmth," you’re on the right track. But if you miss a single cryptic letter or forget to talk to a dying woman before a certain boss dies, that record is gone until New Game Plus.
The Records You’ll Probably Miss First
Let's talk about Feel. This is usually the first one people grab, but it’s easy to overlook if you’re rushing to the boss. You’ve got to find the "Weeping Woman" in Elysion Boulevard. She wants her baby back. The "baby" is a puppet you find near a scrap watchman. You give it to her. You lie. You tell her the baby is cute. If you tell her it’s a puppet, you get nothing but a cold shoulder and a missed collectible.
Then there’s Divine Service. This one is tied to Cecile at the St. Frangelico Cathedral Library. Most players grab her holy mark, give it back, and then forget she exists. Don’t do that. After you beat the Fallen Archbishop Andreus, go back to her spot. If you gave her the mark, she leaves behind a letter and the record. If you didn't? Tough luck.
Music in this game isn't just background noise. It’s the literal metric of your soul. Listening to these records at the Hotel player actually increases your Humanity. You need that Humanity to trigger the "Golden" ending and to pick up certain late-game items. It’s a self-feeding loop.
The Brutal Truth About New Game Plus Records
You can’t just coast through your second run. There are exclusive "Golden" records that only show up in NG+. These aren't just duplicates; they are entirely new tracks required for the achievement.
💡 You might also like: Playing A Link to the Past Switch: Why It Still Hits Different Today
- Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 (Golden): You’ll find this at the Wandering Merchant in the Cerasani Alley.
- Quixotic (Golden): Check the Merchant inside the Red Lobster Inn at Malum District.
- Shadow Flower (Golden): Sold by the Merchant at the Lorenzini Arcade.
The trick is that these vendors only sell the golden versions once you've entered the higher difficulty. If you’re looking for how to get all records lies of p, you have to be prepared to open your wallet (or your Ergo pouch) for these guys.
The Choice Between Eugénie and Alidoro
This is the big one. This is where most completionist runs die a silent death.
Eugénie’s questline is complicated. To get Far East Princess, you have to kill Alidoro after the boss fight at Relic of Trismegistus. Decipher his cryptic vessel with Venigni. Read it. Then, talk to Eugénie. You have to tell her the truth—that the real Alidoro was her brother and he was a talented smith.
Wait.
If you want the other record, Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 (the non-golden version), you have to tell her a different story. You have to tell her he was just a talented workshop technician. You can’t do both in one run. It sucks, but that’s the way the game is designed to force replayability.
Tracking Down the Cryptic Encounters
Some records are just rewards for being a good (or very bad) person.
Why is tucked away behind Belle’s quest. You find her in the Grand Exhibition. Later, she moves to the Hotel. She asks you to find her friend, Atkinson. Atkinson is a monster now. He’s in the train station. He gives you a letter. You go back to Belle. If you want the record, you have to lie. Tell her he died fighting a monster. If you tell her he became a monster, she’s devastated, and you’re record-less.
📖 Related: Plants vs Zombies Xbox One: Why Garden Warfare Still Slaps Years Later
Then there is Antonia. Poor, sick Antonia. You have to work with Polendina to create a cure. If you choose to administer the cure, she dies peacefully after the Laxasia fight. If you don't? Well, the outcome changes, but for the record Memory of Beach, you need to follow through with the "cure" path and check her chair after she passes.
Specific Records and Their Locations
The list is long, and honestly, some are just easier than others.
- Someday: Sold by the Wandering Merchant in the Malum District. Cheap. Easy.
- Fascination: This requires the "Red Actress" questline. You need to give the Apple to Adelina in the Opera House before fighting the King of Puppets. If the King dies and you haven't given her the fruit, she dies without giving you the song.
- Misty E'ra: You get this from the Hermit's Cave. You need to decrypt the Mysterious Cryptic Vessel first. It’s a combat reward from a bulky elite enemy at the end of the path.
- Shadow Flower: This is a gift from Sophia. But only if you make the "right" choice regarding her physical body at the Ascension Bridge. Giving her peace is generally the trigger here.
The Golden Records Checklist
Don't confuse the standard records with the Gold ones. The Gold ones are strictly NG+ and strictly purchased.
- Memory of Beach (Golden): Abandoned Apartment Merchant.
- Fascination (Golden): Merchant near the Abandoned Apartment (yes, he has a few).
- Someday (Golden): Check the Merchant at the entrance to the Cathedral.
The difficulty spike in NG+ is real. Bosses hit like freight trains. But you need to push through because the record player in the Hotel won't fill up otherwise. You've got to sit there and let the music play. You can't just start the record and run away; to get the Humanity boost, you have to stay until the song finishes. You’ll see the icon in the corner of the screen glowing until the final note.
Why the "Lies" Matter for Collection
The game is called Lies of P for a reason. If you play a "Truth" run (which is a valid way to play), you will miss out on the majority of the humanity-based records. The records themselves are a reward for Pinocchio becoming "human." Humans lie to protect feelings. Humans appreciate art.
If you’re stuck on how to get all records lies of p, look at your current Humanity. Is your hair long and grey? Does the cat in the hotel let you pick it up? If not, you haven't lied enough. You need that high Humanity to unlock the final dialogue options with Simon Manus and the nameless puppet scenarios that lead to the final records.
Specifically, the record Symmetry of the Night is tied to a late-game choice regarding the heart.
👉 See also: Why Pokemon Red and Blue Still Matter Decades Later
Practical Steps for Your Completionist Run
Start by focusing on one extreme. Do a "Full Lie" run first. Do every side quest.
- Talk to everyone after every major boss. The NPCs move around.
- Read every letter. Sometimes the record won't trigger until the "Read" flag is set in your inventory.
- Check the Merchants. They update their stock.
- Don't kill NPCs unless the quest explicitly demands it (like Alidoro).
Once you hit NG+, switch your strategy. Tell the truths you didn't tell before. Buy the Golden versions immediately upon reaching the merchants so you don't forget.
The most common point of failure is the Eugénie/Alidoro quest. Double-check your Cryptic Vessels. If you kill Alidoro too early or too late, or fail to talk to Venigni before talking to Eugénie, the record is locked out. It's a very narrow window.
When you finally get that last golden record from the merchant in the late-game areas of NG+, the trophy should pop. Just remember to actually play the records. A record unplayed is just a piece of plastic in your inventory, and in the world of Krat, music is the only thing keeping the madness at bay.
Make sure you've listened to every single one to completion at the gramophone. You'll know it's "counted" when the record sleeve art appears on the screen and the track title stops being highlighted as "New."
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check your inventory against the list of non-golden records: Feel, Divine Service, Someday, Fascination, Quixotic, Why, Misty E’ra, Far East Princess, Memory of Beach, Shadow Flower, and Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1.
- Identify which Eugénie branch you took; if you have "Far East Princess," plan to get "Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1" in your next run by lying to her about Alidoro’s fate.
- Ensure you have the "Bright Red Apple" from Polendina’s shop to give to Adelina before the King of Puppets fight, or you'll be locked out of "Fascination" until the next playthrough.