You've probably seen the posts. They pop up in late-night Facebook groups or on "alternative" health blogs where someone, usually with a lot of conviction and zero lab equipment, claims that germs are not a real thing. It sounds wild. In an era where we can literally watch a virus replicate through an electron microscope, how are we still debating this?
Honestly, it’s kinda fascinating.
This isn't just about people being "uneducated." It’s a collision of history, philosophy, and a deep-seated distrust of modern medicine. When people say germs aren't real, they are usually recycling a 19th-century argument called "Terrain Theory." They aren't necessarily denying that bacteria exist under a lens; they’re denying that these microscopic hitchhikers actually cause disease.
But here’s the reality: Germ Theory is one of the most rigorously tested frameworks in human history. To say germs aren't real is to ignore centuries of empirical evidence that has doubled the human lifespan.
The Fight Between Pasteur and Béchamp
To understand why anyone would think germs are not a real thing, you have to go back to France in the 1800s. It was basically a scientific soap opera. On one side, you had Louis Pasteur. He’s the guy who gave us pasteurization and the rabies vaccine. Pasteur argued that invisible microorganisms—germs—invade the body from the outside and make us sick.
On the other side was Antoine Béchamp.
Béchamp was a brilliant chemist, but he had a very different idea. He promoted "Terrain Theory." According to Béchamp, the environment of the body (the "terrain") is everything. He believed that microbes only become "pathogenic" or harmful when the body is already diseased or acidic. In his view, germs were more like scavengers coming to clean up a mess rather than the intruders who caused the mess in the first place.
It's a seductive idea. It puts all the power in your hands—if you just eat right and stay "alkaline," you're invincible.
But science doesn't care about what feels empowering. It cares about what’s true. Pasteur’s Germ Theory won because it worked. When doctors started washing their hands and sterilizing instruments based on Pasteur’s work, the death rate in hospitals plummeted.
If germs weren't real, why would bleaching a surgical scalpel stop a patient from getting gangrene? The terrain of the patient didn't change in the five minutes it took to wash a knife, but the presence of microbes did.
👉 See also: Understanding MoDi Twins: What Happens With Two Sacs and One Placenta
What We See Under the Microscope
If you head into any microbiology lab today, you can see the "imaginary" culprits for yourself. We have moved far beyond the blurry shapes Pasteur saw.
We have high-resolution imaging that shows the exact mechanism of infection. Take Staphylococcus aureus, for example. We can watch these bacteria adhere to skin cells, secrete toxins that punch holes in cell membranes, and then feast on the nutrients that leak out. If germs are not a real thing, then what exactly are we filming under these $500,000 microscopes?
It’s not just a coincidence.
Think about Koch’s Postulates. Robert Koch, a contemporary of Pasteur, laid out four strict rules to prove a specific microbe causes a specific disease.
- The microbe must be present in every case of the disease.
- You have to be able to isolate that microbe and grow it in a pure culture.
- That cultured microbe must cause the disease when introduced into a healthy organism.
- You must be able to re-isolate that same microbe from the newly infected host.
Scientists have done this thousands of times. Whether it’s Yersinia pestis (the plague) or Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the link is undeniable. If you take a healthy person and introduce enough of a specific pathogen, they will get sick, regardless of how "clean" their terrain is.
The Problem With the "Terrain Only" Argument
The people who claim germs are not a real thing often point to the fact that two people can be exposed to the same cold virus, but only one gets sick. They say, "See! It's the terrain!"
Well, yeah. Sorta.
Modern medicine doesn't actually ignore the "terrain." We just call it the immune system. Factors like sleep, nutrition, stress, and genetics absolutely dictate how hard a virus hits you. But the virus still has to be there. You can have the most compromised "terrain" in the world, but if you are in a sterile bubble with no pathogens, you aren't going to catch the flu.
It takes two to tango. You need the seed (the germ) and the soil (your body).
✨ Don't miss: Necrophilia and Porn with the Dead: The Dark Reality of Post-Mortem Taboos
Denying the seed exists because the soil is important is like saying seeds aren't real because they won't grow on a concrete sidewalk. The concrete is a "bad terrain" for the seed, but the seed is still a physical, causative entity.
Real World Consequences of Germ Denial
This isn't just a harmless internet debate. When the idea that germs are not a real thing goes mainstream, public health collapses.
Look at the history of London’s "Great Stink" in 1858. Before Germ Theory was widely accepted, people believed in "miasma"—the idea that bad smells caused disease. They thought cholera was just "bad air." Because they didn't believe in microscopic germs in the water, they kept dumping sewage into the Thames, right next to the drinking water intakes.
Thousands died.
It wasn't until John Snow (the doctor, not the Game of Thrones guy) tracked a cholera outbreak to a specific water pump on Broad Street that the truth came out. He didn't fix the "terrain" of the city; he took the handle off the pump so people would stop drinking the germ-infested water.
The deaths stopped almost instantly.
We see the same thing today with the resurgence of measles. Measles is one of the most contagious "imaginary" things on the planet. If you are in a room with someone who has it, and you aren't vaccinated, you have a 90% chance of catching it. It doesn't matter if you drink green juice every morning or "align your chakras." The virus is real, it’s physical, and it is incredibly efficient at its job.
The Nuance: Why the Myth Persists
Why is this still a thing in 2026?
Partly because "The Establishment" has a trust problem. Big Pharma has done some objectively terrible things, from the opioid crisis to price gouging on insulin. When people feel lied to by doctors or pharmaceutical companies, they start questioning everything.
🔗 Read more: Why Your Pulse Is Racing: What Causes a High Heart Rate and When to Worry
"If they lied about how addictive this pill is, maybe they're lying about germs, too."
It's a logical fallacy, but it’s a human one.
Additionally, microbiology is invisible to the naked eye. Most of us go through life without ever seeing a bacterium. We take it on faith that the "experts" are right. For some, that's a bridge too far. They want to believe in things they can control. You can control your diet (terrain), but you can't control a microscopic virus floating in a grocery store aisle. Denying the germ is a way to reclaim a sense of safety in a chaotic world.
How to Protect Yourself (In the Real World)
Since germs are, in fact, very real, what should you actually do? You don't need to live in a state of germaphobic panic, but you should respect the biology.
Focus on the "Seed" (The Germs):
- Wash your hands. It sounds like something your kindergarten teacher told you, but mechanical friction with soap and water is the single most effective way to disrupt the lipid membrane of many viruses.
- Air quality matters. We’ve learned a lot lately about how viruses hang out in the air. Proper ventilation or HEPA filtration in your home can significantly reduce the "viral load" you're exposed to.
- Surface awareness. While "fomite" (surface) transmission is less common than respiratory spread for things like COVID-19, it’s still the primary way things like Norovirus move around. Keep the counters clean.
Focus on the "Soil" (Your Terrain):
- Vitamin D and Zinc. These aren't "cures," but they are essential components for your T-cells to function correctly. If you're deficient, your "terrain" is basically inviting the germs to move in and stay a while.
- Sleep. Your immune system does its heaviest lifting while you’re unconscious. If you're running on four hours of sleep, your "terrain" is vulnerable.
- Fiber. About 70% of your immune system lives in your gut. Eating diverse fibers feeds the "good" germs (probiotics) that help fight off the "bad" ones.
Final Perspective
Believing that germs are not a real thing might feel like a radical act of rebellion against a flawed system. But the microscopic world is indifferent to our politics or our skepticism. Bacteria were here billions of years before us, and they’ll be here long after we’re gone.
The best way to stay healthy isn't to deny the existence of pathogens, but to understand them. We live in a world teeming with life we can't see. Some of it helps us digest food; some of it tries to use our cells as 3D printers for their own replication.
Respect the science. Wash your hands. Take care of your body.
And maybe stay off the weirder corners of the internet for a while.
Actionable Steps for Better Health
- Test, don't guess: If you're worried about your "terrain," get a blood panel to check your Vitamin D levels. High levels of inflammation can be measured via C-Reactive Protein (CRP) tests.
- Microbiome support: Incorporate fermented foods like kimchi or kefir. These introduce "good" bacteria that compete with pathogens for space in your gut.
- Critical thinking: When you see a claim that sounds too simple—like "disease doesn't exist"—ask who benefits from you believing it. Usually, it's someone selling a "terrain-balancing" supplement that isn't regulated by the FDA.
- Hygiene balance: You don't need to bleach your entire life. Over-sanitization can actually lead to other issues, like allergies. Aim for "clean," not "sterile," unless you're performing surgery in your kitchen.
The evidence is clear. Germs are real. They are tiny, they are powerful, and they are a fundamental part of the biological world. Denying them won't make you safer; it just makes you more vulnerable to the very things you're trying to ignore.